Presentation on theme: "Only Children. G. Stanley Hall Being an only child is a disease in itself. Overprotected Overindulged."— Presentation transcript:
G. Stanley Hall Being an only child is a disease in itself. Overprotected Overindulged
Romeo & Juliet Alas, Was Juliet An Only Child?
Happier by the Dozen Early Industrial Psychologists had 12 children to demonstrate efficiency. Happily described in 1948 book, Cheaper by the Dozen
Lillian Moller Gilbreth
Cheaper by the Dozen Three Movies 1950 (based on 1948 book) 2003 & 2005 (stories unlike 1948 book)
Meta Analyses-Falbo & Polit Quantitative reviews of literature Over 100 studies Difference between onlies and others was small, even if statistically significant.
Key Findings The high achievement of only children was similar to that of children from 2-child families and firstborns. The achievement of only children was higher than children from 3+ child families.
Parent-Child Relations In terms of, Expert reports, Parental descriptions of children, & Children’s descriptions of parents First-time parents: More anxiety -> Greater vigilance First-time parents: higher expectations for their children than more experienced parents.
China’s One-Child Policy Began over 30 years ago. Extremely successful in reducing birth rate. Intended to promote modernization. Little Emperors
I began conducting research in China…..
Vanessa Fong 2004 Only Hope Teens were pushed by parents to achieve Teens were supposed to be vanguard of modernization 2007 Ethos Mismatch between simple values and more complex models parents want for their children
Falbo & Poston (1993)
Four Provinces in 1990 Province% Urban * Anhui (n=1000)44% * Beijing (n=1000)70% * Gansu (n=1000)50% * Hunan (n=1000)30%
Secondary Analyses Multilevel analysis. Mediation investigated: Parents’ reports of: Child getting way Homework help Educational expectations
Empty Model Used SAS PROC MIXED Random Variable = 200 schools Fixed Variable = None ICC =.34
Fixed Effects: Birth Order Order of birth, such as firstborn, middle born, last born. Sibship Size Number of siblings in a family, such as, 0, 1, 2, 3, etc.
Model 1: Onlies vs. Others
Raw Means-Sibship Size
Model 2: Family Characteristics Parents’ Education Range: None to College Degree Average: Primary - Jr. High Completion Family Income Range: Less than 1000 to Over 5000 Yuan Average: 2501 to 3500 Yuan
Model 3: Control Variables Individual Gender Grade Level School Region Province Beijing vs. Anhui, Gansu, Hunan
Model 4: Mediators? Child Getting Way Homework Help Educational Expectations
Child Get Way
2.73*** * 7.07*** 7.40*** 9.52*** 1.60*** -1.24*** 0.57*** * 0.28 Model * 7.17*** 7.16*** 9.71*** 1.24*** -1.32*** 0.75*** ** 0.86 Model *** ** 1.43** *** 2.08** Model *** 1.81** 2.40** 4.73*** 3.39*** Model 1 Educational Expectations Level One Variance Level Two Variance School-Level Control Variables Region (Urban) Province Beijing (1) vs. Anhui (0) vs. Hunan (0) vs. Gansu (0) Individual-Level Control Variables Gender (female) Grade (sixth) Family Characteristics Parents’ Education Family Income Sibling Effect One (1) vs. FB, 2C (0) vs. LB, 2C (0) vs. FB, 3+C (0) vs. MB, 3+C (0) vs. LB, 3+C (0) Measure Table. Results of Multilevel Models Predicting School Achievement Note. Unstandardized regression coefficients presented here. *p <.05; **p <.01; *** p <.0001
What’s Next? 2008 Chinese Data –Secondary Students –College Students –Young Adults