Presentation on theme: "The Swedish Board of Agriculture - unhealthy competition and dual roles. The European Commission Directorate General for Competition 2012."— Presentation transcript:
The Swedish Board of Agriculture - unhealthy competition and dual roles. The European Commission Directorate General for Competition 2012
Lars-Håkan Håkansson, DVM, president Agneta Johnsson, DVM Per Arvidsson, DVM Mikael Fälth, DVM
ViS Veterinarians in Sweden (Veterinärer i Sverige) ViS, Veterinärer i Sverige, (Veterinarians in Sweden) is an organisation that consists of private practitioners It was founded in 2002 It has about 250 members The purpose of the organisation is to try to create a situation of sound competition and an independent supervisory authority in Sweden
The District Veterinary Organisation, (DVO), (Distriktsveterinärorganisationen), (Distriktsveterinärerna) The state-owned district veterinary organisation was founded in 1931 with the only purpose to fight tuberculosis and some other contagious diseases amongst animals in Sweden. In the 1980s the approximately 300 district veterinarians still worked almost exclusively with farm animals. In the 90s they started treating more and more small animals and sport horses due to the decresing numbers of farm animals. In 1995 the Swedish government decided to create a new organisation. This made the organisation to fall apart and nearly half of the district veterinarians resigned and became private practitioners. This created major disagreements beetween the state and private practitioners which still exixts and tends to increase
Official Reports of the Swedish Government (Statens Offentliga Utredningar, SOU) 1993 SOU 1992:88 Bråkenhjelmska utredningen Veterinär verksamhet 2004 SOU 2004:100 Tillsynsutredningen Tillsyn – Förslag om offentlig tillsyn 2005 SOU 2005:74 Nytt djurhälsoregister – bättre nytta och ökad säkerhet 2007 SOU 2007:24 Veterinärutredningen Veterinär fältverksamhet i nya former 2009 SOU 2008:118 Styra och ställa – förslag till en effektivare förvaltning 2009 SOU 2009:08 Trygg med vad du äter - nya myndigheter för säkra livsmedel och hållbar produktion 2011 SOU 2010:106 Folkhälsa – Djurhälsa. Ny ansvarsfördelning mellan stat och näring
Official Reports of the Swedish Government (Statens Offentliga Utredningar, SOU) 2007 Veterinärutredningen, SOU 2007:24, ”Veterinär fältverksamhet i nya former”, (About the District Veterinary Organisation) One of the most comprehensive and expensive investigations SOU ever has put through. The report proposes that the state district veterinary organization is privatized in two stages in the southern and in the animal- dense parts of Sweden. Later the clinical veterinary activities of state management may be privatized in all of Sweden. The BoA’s dual roles, with both clinical veterinary services and supervision of the overall veterinary profession in the country, has contributed to market malfunctioning. It damages the credibility of the Authority and leads to an inefficient market surveillance and enforcement.
Official Reports of the Swedish Government (Statens Offentliga Utredningar, SOU) 2009 ”Trygg med vad du äter - nya myndigheter för säkra livsmedel och hållbar produktion”, SOU 2009:08, (About the Authorities in the rural sector) Also one of the most comprehensive investigations SOU ever has put through.
The BoA should be closed and a new authority should be established solely engaged in regulatory activities because it is undesirable that the authority that has to control the Agricultural sector in Sweden at the same time has the role to support this.
The reports analysis of the present authorities show that there is a need for reform to justify a more radical government reform. It recreates a clear national responsibilities by adapting to the new responsibilities at European level and the EU Commission's organization of the DGs and an application of the principle of a central legislation, a central authority. This will facilitate the national implementation of the EU common regulatory framework and the basis for a more effective Swedish EU work.
It represents a refinement of the State's commitment to meet societal needs while minimizing government intrusion on the operation of private markets based on the principle that authorities should only engage in competitive activity if special circumstances exist
The proposed new agency structure clearly defines the roles in the veterinary field. Today the BoA is responsible the both for management in veterinary matters and for the State veterinary organization. This means that the authority now is Sweden's largest single employer of clinically active veterinarians and also responsible for supervision of of all vets, both the authority's own employees and competing veterinarians. This scheme is fundamentally inappropriate and could undermine confidence for the veterinary management tasks
The BoA’s dual roles, with both clinical veterinary services and supervision of the overall veterinary profession in the country, has contributed to market malfunctioning. It damages the credibility of the Authority and leads to inefficient market surveillance and enforcement
Other reports 2000 the Swedish Authority for Administrative Development, (Statskontoret) Authorities engaging in commercial activities 2002 The Parliamentary Auditors (2002/03: 4). The study "The terms of the veterinary services” 2006 Swedish Trade and Industri, (Svenskt Näringsliv): Unhealthy competition knocks out private enterprise.
Swedish Competition Authority “Konkurrensverket” The market for animal health care is characterized by competition problems and conflicts between DVO and private veterinarians. The market lacks of important conditions for efficient competition and efficient use of resources for the benefit of the community, the owners or consumers. This can particularly be unfair to smaller businesses in the animal health care market. The Competition Authority consider it unsuitable to combine the business and customer relationship with that of exercising of authority where the customers are the regulated persons.
Furthermore, the Competition Authority regards that the Board of Agriculture has dual roles, ie. both a producer- and regulatory role, including its role of exercising of authority. It is important to distinguish between exercising of authority, as the Board of Authority regards should be operated under public management, and other tasks, which in some cases could justify a spin-off. The Competition Authority has previously proposed various measures to address these problems.
These reports and this final statement from the highest authority regarding competition in Sweden, the Swedish Competition Authority, has not affected the Department of Rural Affairs or the Board of agriculture in any way.
“Veterinärer i Sverige”, ViS, request that the European Commission enjoins Sweden to remove the competitive distortion in the veterinary sector.
Ministry for Rural Affairs Swedish Board of Agriculture District Veterinarians, Headquarters 80 District veterinary stations, 400 veterinary surgeons Ministry for Rural Affairs Swedish Board of Agriculture The world's largest veterinary company? No counterpart in EU.
Swedish Board of Agriculture 80 District veterinary stations, 400 veterinary surgeons Ministry of Finance 110 MSEK every year Cheap loans for investments in equipment, ( ca 2 % lower than for private practitioners) 110 MSEK every year, (12,5 MEUR)
The District veterinarian More than 80 % of their work concerns small animal and sport horses. They work exactly in the same way private practitioners do except that they can act as official veterinarians. (Which gives them a great advantage in terms of competition.)
The most aggressive marketing of all veterinary companies in Sweden Translation: HORSE AND SMALL ANIMALS Specialist in diseases of dogs and cats. MEDICINE SURGERY X-RAY Food for small animals Swedish Board of Agriculture The District Veterinary Organisation
Small animals Translation: The District Veterinary Station in Laholm Clinic for small animals We welcome all dog and cat owners to our fine new premises. ………………………………………………… ………………………………………………… Swedish Board of Agriculture The District Veterinary Organisation
10 vets, 5 assistants. Specialists in dentistry for horses. Open 24/7 for small and large animals. Clinic head: “My dream is to get an indoor lunging path for the horses”
Selling fodder to small animals
Article from RAID 2012
The Director-General of the Bord of Agriculture inaugurates a district veterinary clinic
The Minister for Rural Affairs inaugurates an District veterinary station
We also request that the European Commission enjoins Sweden to create an independent supervisory authority, consisting of civil servants who are not in a financially position of dependence to the subject under their supervision. The latter request implies that veterinarians that perform supervisory work will not be permitted to run a veterinary practice. This also includes a request that the European Commission enjoins Sweden to create an independent supervisory authority for veterinarians.
Ministry for Rural Affairs Swedish Board of Agriculture District Veterinarians, Headquarters Department for Animal Welfare and Health Swedens animal-owners Supervisory activities Commercial activities 80 District veterinary stations, 400 veterinary surgeons Also official veterinarians, same persons Ministry for Rural Affairs Swedish Board of Agriculture Department for Animal Welfare and Health Supervisory activities
Swedish Board of Agriculture Swedens animal-owners 80 District veterinary stations, 400 veterinary surgeons 50 % of the fees from commersial actvities
We also request that the European Commission investigates whether the subsidising of a major veterinary organisation, whose primary purpose is to provide cheap veterinary care to the country's livestock producers, should be regarded as an illegal governmental subsidy.
We also request that the European Commission investigates whether the Board of Agriculture, in order to sharpen its competitive edge, is in breach of EU's working hours legislation by avoiding reporting actual worked hours and instead call unreported time as "duty working hours", (förtroendearbetstid).
We request that the European Commission investigates the consequences, both from the perspective of employees and employers of the introduction of new regulations for veterinary nurses.