Presentation on theme: "Academic Staff Rate & Title Change Requests Annual Promotion Review"— Presentation transcript:
1 Academic Staff Rate & Title Change Requests Annual Promotion Review College of Letters and ScienceMarch 28, 2013Academic StaffRate & Title Change RequestsAnnual Promotion ReviewWelcome to the presentation “Academic Staff: Rate and Title Change Requests & Annual Promotion Review.”After you review a slide, click anywhere to advance the presentation. To exit the presentation at any time, press the Escape Key. To go back to a previous slide, press the Backspace Key. Click to begin the presentation.This presentation was given live on March 28, 2013, and was modified into a self-paced presentation. It is part of a series coordinated by L&S Administration, intended to connect L&S faculty and staff with topics and information that may be helpful in their positions. More presentations and information about this series of trainings can be found on the L&S Administrative Gateway, at: https://kb.wisc.edu/ls/page.php?id=25131Presenters: Cheryl Adams Kadera, L&S Human ResourcesDaun Wheeler, L&S Human Resources
2 This presentation includes the following topics: OverviewThis presentation includes the following topics:Rate and Title ChangesPromotionsJob Duty Changes
4 What are the reasons to give a rate adjustment? Rate and Title ChangeWhat are the reasons to give a rate adjustment?Change in Title/PromotionThis presentation will focus on change in title/promotion and change in job duties, because the vast majority of rate adjustments fall into these two categories.The vast majority of rate/title changes will fall under the first 2 categories so our focus will be on those requests.Change in Job DutiesSalary InequityCompetitive Factors (Outside Offer, market, etc.)
5 Rate and Title Change Per UPPP Chapter 10 The Unclassified Personnel Policies and Procedures (UPPP) defines promotions and change in duties.Per UPPP Chapter 10(http://www.ohr.wisc.edu/polproced/UPPP/1001.pdf):Promotion within a title series is “a natural career progression through which academic staff (and faculty) might be expected to progress in the area of specialty with successively greater experience, expertise, and responsibility in the particular position.” The specific criteria for the prefix vary depending upon the function chosen.This is important to keep in mind when preparing a justification. Performance cannot be the primary justification for changing the rate, changing job duties or promotion. You can certainly mention performance, but at this point it cannot be the main reason for submitting a rate change request.Change in Duties “is requested when a substantial change in the duties and responsibilities of a position occurs. The change has to be a qualitative rather than quantitative change to the duties” (i.e. not “more of the same”).We will look at this issue-- whether a change is more of the same tasks, or is something different– at greater depth later in the presentation.Under state statutes, it is NOT possible to grant a base adjustment to recognize good performance. Salary increases for good performance can only be provided through the annual pay plan process. (However, there may be future options for performance based adjustments under the new HR Design plan.)
6 Who are Category A and Category B staff? Rate and Title ChangeWho are Category A and Category B staff?There are two compensation categories for academic staff:Category A titles include administrative and professional positions and have salary ranges with a minimum and a maximum salary. Category B titles include instructional and higher-level research positions (e.g., Scientists, Researchers) and do not have salary ranges – only salary minima.
7 Unclassified Title Guidelines Rate and Title ChangeUnclassified Title GuidelinesThe Unclassified Title Guidelines is the best place to find unclassified titles, descriptions, criteria, and salary ranges. These guidelines will provide background information required to complete a request for a rate and title change.Clicking here will bring you to a page that has more information about the job titles in this category. . .
8 Unclassified Title Guidelines Rate and Title ChangeUnclassified Title Guidelines. . . it’s a page that shows more information about title descriptions. . .. . . whether it is Category A or B. . .. . . and salary ranges.
9 Salary Ranges Rate and Title Change Salary ranges associated with all titles can be found online at the address below.Most rates are campus-wide. However, L&S has their own instructional rates– which are posted in the L&S Gateway. These are mainly for Faculty Associate, Lecturer and Faculty Assistant titles. You should reference these L&S rates, if the rate and title change involves an instructional title.L&S Instructional Rates: https://kb.wisc.edu/ls/page.php?id=28638
10 What is the amount of a rate/title change increase? Rate and Title ChangeWhat is the amount of a rate/title change increase?In general, a change in title or change in job duties requires a 10% increase in order to be consistent with all staff in your unit.While policy allows a 5% increase, L&S asks departments to always give the full allowable 10% increase. This is for consistency, and because of the limited opportunities staff have for increases.**Keep in mind that when promoting to the next prefix level, you would raise the person to the campus/college salary minimum of the new title first (if applicable) and then give 10% on top of that.For employees that are currently below their new title’s minimum salary, this will translate into a greater than 10% increase.
11 “Raise to campus/college salary minimum +10%” Rate and Title ChangeAs you can see, this can result in substantial rate increases, if the employee is under the new title’s minimum salary.Examples of“Raise to campus/college salary minimum +10%”. . and then add a 10% raise, based on that new minimum salary. . .L&S also has minimum rates we follow which are higher than campus (Lecturers and Faculty Associate rates). . to get the new total.In the second example, the employee is already above the minimum range 3 salary. So the 10% increase is based on their current salary.The first example is an Assoc Advisor who is currently in Range 2.In the final example, the employee would be raised first to the L&S minimum, with the additional 10% increase based on that minimum.The title is changing to No Prefix, which is in Range 3.The first step is to raise raise them to the minimum salary of Range
12 Where do I start? Rate and Title Change All requests for rate and title change must be submitted through the electronic Rate /Title Adjustment system.Where do I start?The electronic PVL/Rate Adjustment System can be found at: https://orprd4.doit.wisc.edu/pvl/pvl.htmlIf you need access to the system, contact L&S HR and we will assist you.Research Associates increases are limited to change in job duties as it is not a promotion seriesAll departments should now have access to the system, but contact L&S HR if you have questions about access.DoIt can help with technical questions.*Postdocs (Research Associates) remain on paper formThe only exception to using the electronic system is for Postdocs, which remain on paper form. If you’re doing a rate change for a postdoc (Research Associate) , it would be due to a change in job duties (Postdocs aren’t in a promotional/title series), and a paper form must be submitted.
13 What is the effective date? Rate and Title ChangeThe Status History tab will show when the request was entered, the date department approval was entered, and the date L&S approval was entered.What is the effective date?Rate adjustments are effective on the first of the month following receipt of the request to L&S as indicated by the DEPARTMENT APPROVED status in the Rate/Title system (look at Status History tab). Academic year (9 month/ C basis) requests are effective on the first day of the next academic pay period.Draft status, Entered Status, Department Approved StatusThis is a common question to HR. Rate changes cannot be retroactive. The effective date may not be earlier than the date of department approval was indicated in the electronic Rate/Title System.Cannot be retroactive.Must contain all necessary materials/information (if substantial revisions are required, the effective date may be delayed until the appropriate information is received).Be aware– the effective date of the rate change may be delayed if the department does not respond in a timely manner to requests for additional information.
14 Who must approve a rate/title change? Rate and Title ChangeWho must approve a rate/title change?The supervisor and/or department must review and approve and enter the request into the electronic rate/title system.The College of Letters & ScienceAcademic Personnel OfficeAfter your department approves the request, the electronic system will advance the request to the next level of review.Until final approval is obtained, no university official is authorized to promise a base adjustment to an unclassified employee.While you may tell an employee that you have submitted a request for a base adjustment change, you may not promise that L&S or the Academic Personnel Office will approve that request. You must wait for the outcome of the full approval process before telling an employee whether their salary will be adjusted.
16 Annual Promotion Review PromotionsAnnual Promotion ReviewEach year departments and programs are required to review their academic staff employees for possible promotion if they fall into one of the following categories:Category A academic staff who have held the lowest-prefix title for at least three years, or the middle-prefix title for at least eight years; andCategory B (Research or Instructional) academic staff who have held the lowest or the middle-prefix title for at least six years.This exercise will require each person listed to be considered for promotion. Promotion is not required when a valid reason can be provided.Valid reason examples – does not meet criteria, performance issues, new to supervisor or unit within past year, layoff/nonrenewal in place, person is retiring/resignings are sent individual Chairs/Directors and Administrators each year (early March) with a list of staff who need to be reviewed in their department. If your department didn’t receive this , there are no staff in your department who are required to be reviewed for promotion.
17 Can we promote staff who aren’t included in the promotion review? PromotionsPROMOTIONSCan we promote staff who aren’t included in the promotion review?YES. Whether you are required to participate in the Annual Promotion Review or not, you may still have academic staff who could be considered for promotion. Employees can be considered for promotion at any point during the year; budget data is updated after promotions are approved and entered in HRS.HR keeps the Budget Office involved any time there is a rate change, and the department’s budget will be updated any time a promotion is approved.
18 Where Do I Start? Promotions PROMOTIONS The webpage also includes templates for writing the justification for why the employee should be promoted (we’ll show you a template later in the presentation, too.)Where Do I Start?L&S Gateway: https://kb.wisc.edu/ls/page.php?id=22078The Unclassified Title Guidelines (Criteria For Prefixes, Scope and Levels) will help determine when it’s appropriate to promoteFor Category B and professional Category A academic staff employees, a promotion would include a prefix change within the same title series (e.g., Associate Lecturer to no prefix Lecturer) based on the promotional criteria found in the Unclassified Title Guideline.Exceptions:Movement within the Program Manager, Lab Manager, and Unspecified Director will be based on evaluation of the Position Questionnaire (PQ).For your reference, full instructions are provided in the L&S Gateway web document “Academic Staff Promotion” at this address. (We’ll start reviewing these instructions on the next slide.)The criteria are also included in the Justification Templates referenced above. We hope that including the criteria on the templates will help your department provide strong justifications.
19 Supporting documents Promotions – Supporting Documents PROMOTIONS Supervisors must submit 3 supporting documents to their department administrator/HR/payroll staff:Current duties Worksheet: A template (found on the L&S Gateway) can be used to help you collect current duties from the employee or supervisor. Prior to giving this template to supervisors, Administrators/HR staff should complete the former duties section or provide a copy of the most recent job duties on file (typically Position Vacancy Listing (PVL) or last rate and title change). This prevents the supervisor from “recreating” the duties.If the duties haven’t changed, then the former and current duties will be identical.If the current job duties aren’t accurate, the department may need to make substantial revisions to align the request with the correct duties. Anything you can do to help us prevent this unfortunate situation is appreciated!
20 Promotions-Supporting Documents EXAMPLE: John’s former duties….This is an example of a Current Job Duties Worksheet. Before giving this to the supervisor, the staff member entered the information in the Former Duties column. That information was taken from the PVL John was hired under, since he had no other change of duties or promotion documentation in his file.
21 Promotions - Supporting Documents John’s duties may not change…..In some cases, an employee’s duties will not change. Changes are not required to promote an employee. Promotions are based on the employee’s progress, not necessarily a change in job duties.
22 Promotions PROMOTIONS Or John’s duties may change a little….. If the job duties change substantially, contact L&S to consult.And. . . a duty was also taken away.In other cases, an employees duties will change. Here, you can see that a job duty was added, because the left column is blank.If job duties change substantially (meaning 15% - 45%), first consult with L&S HR before you complete the request.If the job duties change substantially, contact L&S to consult.
23 Promotions - Supporting Documents Current Job Duties Worksheet (reviewed in the last slides)2. Most recent CV3. Justification for how the employee has met criteria for promotion. L&S has templates available on the Gateway which will help supervisors prepare letters of justification for promotion.Listed below is the criteria (from Unclassified Title Guidelines) we would use to evaluate whether John Smith should be promoted from Assistant Faculty Associate to Associate Faculty Associate:“Identifies instructional goals to be met; designs curriculum and/or techniques for accomplishing these goals. May train other staff in use of these techniques. Instructs students, either in formal classroom/laboratory settings or in non-credit supplements to formal course instruction. Works with faculty to identify and develop new methods of advancing instruction in the discipline. May assist in development of grant proposals for funding of model instruction programs. May make presentations to faculty and to staff members throughout the system and elsewhere on instructional programs and techniques.”
24 Promotions - Justifications Please use the Justification Templates when preparing a request for promotion. They are provided on the L&S Gateway. Below are some excerpts from templates:Promotions - JustificationsPROMOTIONSTemplates provide guidance for writing a strong justificationWe believe that Mr. John Smith meets the prefix definition of Associate Faculty Associate and should be promoted effective ______. In addition, we are requesting that his salary be increased by ____in recognition of his promotion.__________ “identifies instructional goals to be met.” For example:_________________________________________“designs curriculum and/or techniques for accomplishing these goals.” For example:__________ “instructs students, either informal classroom/laboratory settings or in non-credit supplements to formal course instruction.” For example:He teaches __________. His course evaluations have been outstanding, ranging from ______ to ______. The department average Is ______. Students have made such comments as “______” and “_______”.__________ “works with faculty to identify and develop new methods of advancing instruction in the discpline. For example:Given all of the above, we believe that John Smith should be promoted to Associate Faculty Associate effective ____________.
25 Promotions - Justifications When you review a justification for promotion you should be looking for strong examples of how the employee has met the criteria.If you read what’s written and questions remain as to “what’s the significance of this?”, you need to go back to the supervisor and ask for more detail.Here are some examples……
26 Promotions - Justifications Criteria-“designs curriculum and/or techniques for accomplishing instructional goals.” For example:WEAK EXAMPLE- John uses a collaborative instructional approach in the classroom…….What is the significance of this? How does it justify a promotion?STRONG EXAMPLE- John uses a collaborative instructional approach in the classroom and through a network of wikis, podcasts, live blogging, chat and posting tools, students, TA and instructor share and comment on the legal case studies and hypothetical situations discussed in class. The course enrolls upwards of 80 students and has generated a great deal of interest among students.
27 Promotions - Justifications Criteria- “Identifies instructional goals to be met.” For example:WEAK- John developed a troubleshooting wiki to facilitate response to the problems students encounter working with software….What’s the significance of this? How does this help students?STRONG- John developed a troubleshooting wiki to facilitate response to the problems students encounter working with software. The wiki not only reduces the time it takes to get back to students, but it shifts the burden for responding to questions from a single individual to the entire class. And, because John carries the wikis forward from one semester to the next, students benefit from the insights and experiences of former students while, at the same time, learning to use this form of communication.Also, remember that the L&S and campus individuals reviewing your request won’t have expertise in your field. Technical information and concepts should be explained in layperson’s language.
28 Promotions - Justifications Criteria- “Instructs students, either in formal classroom/laboratory settings or in non-credit supplements to formal course instruction”.WEAK- John teaches Journalism 202 and Journalism 403. His course evaluations have been outstanding.What do his evaluations look like and what do students say about him?STRONG- John teaches Journalism 202 and Journalism 403. His course evaluations have been outstanding, ranging from 4.25 to The department average is His students have made comments such as:-“John is understanding, accommodating, and willing to take extra time to help with questions. I would recommend this class to anyone."-"I think John is a very engaging and well qualified teacher. He’s extremely willing to explain problems to his students, that they might run into."-"Great instructor. Brings a lot of enjoyment to class with enthusiasm/knowledge."
29 PromotionsPROMOTIONSThe supervisor gave me all 3 supporting documents, what’s the next step?The Department administrator/HR/payroll staff should review the request for accuracy and to ensure that all necessary information and documents are included. That staff person can then enter it in the Rate and Title Change System.Once Department approved, L&S Human Resources staff will review the request, and if appropriate, submit to APO for review and approval.
31 Where do I start? Change in Job Duties CHANGE IN JOB DUTIES 1. Provide a current list of duties.You should always start with a copy of the most recent job duties on file. This is usually the PVL or most recent rate/title change request. If the last job duties on file are very outdated, please consult with L&S.A strong PVL with percentages is a critical starting pointThe “Goldilocks” factor – not too much or too little informationSpell out AcronymsUse the Current Work Duties Worksheet on the L&S Gateway to assist with this process.You should start with the Current Job Duties Worksheet that we reviewed earlier (available on the L&S Gateway). You’ll also be referencing the PVL or most recent request. Again, if you don’t start with the correct job duties, the request cannot go forward.Creating strong PVLs initially will help later with changes in job duties, promotions, or rate and title changes. Percentages are important because some titles are similar; the percentages can help determine whether the position should be in one title or another.With very broad and general descriptions, it may be difficult to justify that the new job duties assigned are beyond the description. On the other hand very narrow descriptions describing the position in minute detail can also make it difficult to show that something new is being added. This is why HR staff will work with you to provide “just the right amount” of description in PVLs.Individuals reviewing the change in duties request may not be familiar with acronyms your department uses. So always spell them out the first time you use them.
32 Change in Job DutiesCHANGE IN JOB DUTIESCompare “former” job duties to current job duties (item by item):Is it a substantial change in job duties? A general ballpark figure is 20-40% change overall.Is it a qualitative change vs. quantitative, ie. not “more of the same”EXAMPLE: Anna Advisor currently spends 50% of her time advising undergraduate Biology majors as part of her job duties. She now has 50 additional students she needs to advise. Would this warrant a change in job duties?Answer: It DependsIf Anna currently has a workload of 500 students she advises in Biology and these are just additional students due to an increase in enrollment, then it will not qualify as “new or changed”.When a job changes more than 45-50%, it is considered a new position that should be posted for open recruitment. Please consult with L&S HR in these situations.To determine the change percent, HR staff will go over the Job Duties Worksheet line by line and compare percentages. You should do this before submitting the request too, to ensure there is enough change to be approved.Anything 50% or above would look like a new position and need to go through open recruitment
33 Change in Job Duties CHANGE IN JOB DUTIES In this example, the only thing changing is the percentage of time spent on currently assigned activities, so the duties won’t qualify as new and changed.Change in Job DutiesCHANGE IN JOB DUTIESLooking at this sample Job Duties Worksheet, notice that the descriptions of the former and current duties match. The only differences are small percentages in the amount of time spent on these duties. This would not qualify as new or changed duties.
34 Change in Job DutiesCHANGE IN JOB DUTIESBut, if this is part of a bigger change, then it may qualify.For example, the Biology major has decided to merge with the Cellular & Molecular Biology program and Anna now has to learn the curriculum and policies of that new program in order to provide the undergraduate advising. In addition, she will be responsible for SOAR activities for both programs. She is also going to work with faculty from both majors to create internship opportunities.The following slide shows an example:
35 Change in Job Duties CHANGE IN JOB DUTIES The person completing the Job Duties worksheet should make it very clear (as this example does) what duties have been tweaked, what duties are completely new, and how percentages will change.This example shows that in addition to some other changes, this person has some entirely new job duties.
36 Change in Job DutiesCHANGE IN JOB DUTIES2. Provide an appropriate justification to explain the change in job duties:The justification should “write itself” and should mirror the new or changed job duties listed in the worksheet:SAMPLE:Anna Advisor started in the Department of Biology as an Associate Advisor in In 2011, she was promoted to Advisor. Since that time, her job duties have changed and she has taken on additional responsibilities. More information is provided below.In September 2012, the Executive Committees from the Departments of Biology and Cellular & Molecular Biology decided to merge their undergraduate programs as part of an Educational Innovation exercise for both units. As a result of that merger, Anna Advisor will now provide undergraduate advising to both units and serve as the SOAR advisor. She will now be involved in updating program material for both the biology and molecular biology majors. She will be responsible for creating a course guide list for the molecular biology major.Finally, she will work with the faculty in the biology and molecular biology majors to coordinate internship opportunities. Anna will need to contact various employers and businesses regarding possible opportunities for students. She will also create a newsletter to advertise internships.Start with a short summary about the individual, how long he or she has been there, and what has happened with the position.Next, you should explain the changes that have been laid out in the job duties worksheet, and why those changes are happening. This is the place to provide some additional explanations that aren’t necessarily part of the job duties.Job duties that are described in the justification section should also be included in the Job Duties Worksheet. If they are described in the justifications, but not included in the worksheet, HR reviewers will likely ask for a revision.
37 Change in Job DutiesCHANGE IN JOB DUTIESProvide information on how many staff/students the person supervises.Describe any budgetary responsibility this person has.The supervisor gave me all 4 items, what’s the next step?The Department administrator/HR/payroll staff should review the request for accuracy and to ensure that all necessary information and documents are included. The request can then be entered in the Rate and Title Change System.Once Department approved, L&S Human Resources staff will review the request, and if appropriate, submit to APO for review and approval.The final two pieces of information required for the request is how many (if any) people they are supervising, and budgetary responsibilities (again, if any).
38 Change in Job Duties WHAT IF I STILL HAVE QUESTIONS? Additional ResourcesPromotional policies, procedures and templates are available on the L&S Administrative Gateway at https://kb.wisc.edu/ls/page.php?id=22078Unclassified Title Guidelines:Unclassified Personnel Policies & Procedures (UPPP), Chapter 10:L&S Human Resources Staff:Cheryl Adams Kadera (change in duties, equity, misc. requests)Daun Wheeler (promotion requests)
40 Other HR Topics Job Security OTHER HR TOPICS……… L&S HR sends a list of staff that should be reviewed for increased security to departments each year. However, staff can be considered for increased job security at any time.Job SecurityThe Academic Staff Policies and Procedures (ASPP) 2.05 states, “Employing units shall annually review academic staff members who have five or more years of academic staff service at UW-Madison to determine whether a new or increased multiple-year appointment or rolling-horizon appointment or indefinite appointment shall be proposed. Individuals who currently hold rolling-horizon appointments shall be reviewed and a determination made about their eligibility for an indefinite appointment.”Increased job security for academic staff is appropriate when the following criteria are met:the quality of their performance warrants increased job securitytheir role is an integral part of their department’s or unit’s continuing mission; anda funding source can be identified that permits multiple-year, rolling-horizon, or indefinite appointmentsReason codes: Funding, performance issues, new to supervisor/unit, employee has max. job security allowed by department
41 Other HR Topics Consultant (PIR) vs. Employment OTHER HR TOPICS……… Issues come up when departments want to pay someone as an consultant when really, that person is in a employment relationship with the university.Consultant (PIR) vs. EmploymentPayment to Individual (PIR) requests. PIR is the required mechanism for making payment to non-employees or individuals that are defined as "a person who is not a company, partnership, corporation, association, organization, trust or estate, and for whom an employer-employee relationship does not exist.“Please consult with L&S HR before the start of work or service.Additional information can be found here:We have options to hire short-term academic staff, hourly, lump sum paymentsL&S HR has flexibility in payment and hiring options (e.g. lump sum, hourly, or short-term positions).If you’re unsure about whether an individual can be paid as a consultant, please contact L&S HR. It can create problems if you mistakenly promise a payment to an individual that doesn’t qualify as a consultant. They end up in title and salary that doesn’t support the fee you promised (and fringe benefit rate will apply as well).
42 For More Information Additional Questions? Please contact: L&S Human Resources Staff:Cheryl Adams Kadera (change in duties, equity, misc. requests)Daun Wheeler (promotion requests)End of Presentation.