Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byNathan Mepham Modified over 3 years ago

1
Alessandro Toschi ERC -workshop „Ab-initio DΓΑ“ Baumschlagerberg, 3 September 2013 „Introduction to the two-particle vertex functions and to the dynamical vertex approximation“ „Introduction to the two-particle vertex functions and to the dynamical vertex approximation“

2
I ) Non-local correlations beyond DMFT overview of the extensions of DMFT Focus: diagrammatic extensions (based on the 2P-local vertex) Outlook II) Local vertex functions: general formalisms numerical results/physical interpretation III) Dynamical Vertex Approximations (D Γ A): basics of D Γ A D Γ A results: (i) spectral function & critical regime of bulk 3d-systems (ii) nanoscopic system ( talk A. Valli)

3
Electronic correlation in solids - J multi-orbital Hubbard model Local part only! U Simplest version: single-band Hubbard hamliltonian:

4
No : spatial correlations Yes : local temporal correlations W. Metzner & D. Vollhardt, PRL (1989) A. Georges & G. Kotliar, PRB (1992) the Dynamical Mean Field Theory Σ(ω)Σ(ω) h eff (t) - J Σ(ω)Σ(ω) U non-perturbative in U, BUT purely local self-consistent SIAM „There are more things in Heaven and Earth, than those described by DMFT“ [W. Shakespeare, readapted by AT ]

5
(exact in d = ∞ ) h eff (t) DMFT DMFT applicability: ✔ high connectivity/dimensions low dimensions (layered-, surface-, nanosystems) phase-transitions ( ξ ∞, criticality) Instead: DMFT not enough [ spatial correlations are crucial] ✔ high temperatures U!! ξ

6
Beyond DMFT: several routes 1.Cellular-DMFT (C-DMFT: cluster in real space) 2.Dynamical Cluster Approx. (DCA: cluster in k-space) ★ cluster extensions [ ⌘ Kotliar et al. PRL 2001; Huscroft, Jarrell et al. PRL 2001] ij()ij() ★ high-dimensional (o(1/d)) expansion [ ⌘ Schiller & Ingersent, PRL 1995] (1/d: mathematically elegant, BUT very small corrections ) ★ a complementary route: diagrammatic extensions (C-DMFT, DCA : systematic approach, BUT only “short” range correlation included )

7
Diagrammatic extensions of DMFT ★ Dual Fermion [ ⌘ Rubtsov, Lichtenstein et al., PRB 2008] (DF: Hubbard-Stratonovic for the non-local degrees of freedom & perturbative/ladder expansion in the Dual Fermion space ) ★ Dynamical Vertex Approximation [ ⌘ AT, Katanin, Held, PRB 2007] (D Γ A: ladder/parquet calculations with a local 2P-vertex [ Γ ir ] input from DMFT ) ★ 1Particle Irreducible approach [ ⌘ Rohringer, AT et al., PRB (2013), in press ] (1PI: ladder calculations of diagram generated by the 1PI-functional ) [ talk by Georg Rohringer] all these methods require Local two-particle vertex functions as input ! ★ DMF 2 RG [ ⌘ Taranto, et al., arXiv 1307.3475 ] (D MF 2 RG : combination of DMFT & fRG ) [ talk by Ciro Taranto]

8
2P- vertex: Who’s that guy? To a certain extent: 2P-analogon of the one-particle self-energy In the following: How to extract the 2P-vertex (from the 2P-Greens‘ function) How to classify the vertex functions (2P-irreducibility) Frequency dependence of the local vertex of DMFT 1 particle in – 1 particle out U Dyson equations: G (1) (ν) Σ ( ν ) vertex 2 particle in – 2 particle out U BSE, parquet : G (2) vertex Year: 1987; Source: Wikipedia

9
How to extract the vertex functions? 2P-Green‘s function: 2P-vertex functions: numerically demanding, but computable, for AIM (single band: ED still possible; general multi-band case: CTQMC, work in progress) =+ F + Full vertex (scattering amplitude) What about 2P-irreducibility? = Γ (fRG notation) = γ 4 (DF notation)

10
Decomposition of the full vertex F 1) parquet equation: 2) Bethe-Salpeter equation (BS eq.) : Γ ph e.g., in the ph transverse ( ph ) channel: F = Γ ph + Φ ph

11
Types of approximations: 2P- irreducibility *) LOWEST ORDER (STATIC) APPROXIMATION: U

12
F ν + ω ν ‘ + ω ν‘ν‘ν Dynamic structure of the vertex: DMFT results = F( ν, ν ‘, ω ) spin sectors: density/charge magnetic/spin background = 0 intermediate coupling (U ~ W/2) (2n+1)π/β (2n‘+1)π/β for the vertex asymptotics : see also J. Kunes, PRB (2011)

13
full vertex F Frequency dependence: an overview irreducible vertex Γ fully irreducible vertex Λ background and main diagonal (ν=ν‘) ≈ U 2 χ m (0) ∞ at the MIT No-high frequency problem ( Λ U) BUT low-energy divergencies

14
full vertex F Frequency dependence: an overview irreducible vertex Γ fully irreducible vertex Λ background and main diagonal (ν=ν‘) ≈ U 2 χ m (0) ∞ at the MIT No-high frequency problem ( Λ U) BUT low-energy divergencies MIT [ talk by Thomas Schäfer ] Γ d & Λ ∞ singularity line ⌘ T. Schäfer, G. Rohringer, O. Gunnarsson, S. Ciuchi, G. Sangiovanni, AT, PRL (2013)

15
Types of approximations: 2P- irreducibility *) DIAGRAMMATIC EXTENSIONS OF DMFT: dynamical local vertices F( ν, ν ‘, ω ) Γ ( ν, ν ‘, ω ) Λ ( ν, ν ‘, ω ) Dual Fermion, 1PI approach, DMF 2 RG Dynamical Vertex Approx. (DΓA) methods based on F methods based on Γ c, Λ more direct calculation Locality of F? Locality of Γ C, Λ inversion of BS eq. or parquet needed

16
DMFT: all 1-particle irreducible diagrams (=self-energy) are LOCAL !! DΓA : all 2 -particle irreducible diagrams (=vertices) are LOCAL !! the self-energy becomes NON-LOCAL the dynamical vertex approximation ( DΓA ) AT, A. Katanin, K. Held, PRB (2007) See also: PRB (2009), PRL (2010), PRL (2011), PRB (2012) i j Λ ir

17
Algorithm (flow diagrams): SIAM, G 0 -1 ( ) Dyson equation G loc =G ii G AIM = G loc ii ( ) G ij ★ DMFT SIAM, G 0 -1 ( ) Parquet Solver G loc =G ii G AIM = G loc Λ ir (ω,ν,ν’) G ij, ij ★ DΓA ( ⌘ Parquet Solver : Yang, Fotso, Jarrell, et al. PRB 2009 )

18
DCA, 2d-Hubbard model, U=4t, n=0.85, ν = ν ‘= π / β, ω =0 Th. Maier et al., PRL (2006) k-dependence of the irreducible vertex Differently from the other vertices Λ irr is constant in k-space fully LOCAL in real space [ BUT… is it always true? on-going project with J. Le Blanc & E. Gull ]

19
Applications: Applications: DMFT not enough [ spatial correlations are crucial] low dimensions (layered-, surface-, nanosystems) U!! phase-transitions ( ξ ∞, criticality) ξ non-local correlations in a molecular rings nanoscopic DΓA [ talk by Angelo Valli]

20
Applications: Applications: low dimensions (layered-, surface-, nanosystems) phase-transitions ( ξ ∞, criticality) DMFT not enough [ spatial correlations are crucial] U!! ξ critical exponents of the Hubbard model in d=3 DΓA (with ladder approx.)

21
Ladder approximation: SIAM, G 0 -1 ( ) Parquet Solver G loc =G ii Λ ir (ω,ν,ν’) G ij, ij ★ DΓA algorithm : Γ ir (ω,ν,ν’) ) local assumption already at the level of Γ ir (e.g., spin-channel ) ) working at the level of the Bethe-Salpeter eq. (ladder approx.) Ladder approx. ) full self-consistency not possible! Moriya 2P-constraint G AIM = G loc Moriya constraint: χ loc = χ AIM Changes : ( ⌘ Ladder-Moriya approx.: A.Katanin, et al. PRB 2009 )

22
DΓA results in 3 dimensions G. Rohringer, AT, A. Katanin, K. Held, PRL (2011) ✔ phase diagram : one-band Hubbard model in d=3 (half-filling )

23
G. Rohringer, AT, A. Katanin, K. Held, PRL (2011) ✔ phase diagram : one-band Hubbard model in d=3 (half-filling ) DΓA results in 3 dimensions TNTN Quantitatively: good agreement with extrapolated DCA and lattice-QMC at intermediate coupling (U > 1) ✗ underestimation of T N at weak-coupling

24
G. Rohringer, AT, et al., PRL (2011) ✔ phase diagram : one-band Hubbard model in d=3 (half-filling ) DΓA results: 3 dimensions spectral function A(k, ω ) in the self-energy (@ the lowerst ν n ) not a unique criterion!! (larger deviation found in entropy behavior) See: S. Fuchs et al., PRL (2011)

25
G. Rohringer, AT, A. Katanin, K. Held, PRL (2011) ✔ phase diagram : one-band Hubbard model in d=3 (half-filling ) DΓA results: 3 dimensions

26
DΓA results: the critical region DMFT MFT result! wrong in d= 3 DΓA γ DMFT = 1 γ DΓA = 1.4 TNTN correct exponent !!

27
✔ phase diagram : one-band Hubbard model in d=2 (half-filling ) A. Katanin, AT, K. Held, PRB (2009) DΓA results in 2 dimensions DΓA exponential behavior! T N = 0 Mermin-Wagner Theorem in d = 2!

28
Summary: Going beyond DMFT (non-perturbative but only LOCAL) D Γ A results 1. spectral functions in d=3 and d=2 γ =1.4 & more... spatial correlation in nanoscopic systems cluster extensions (DCA, C-DMFT) diagrammatic extensions (DF, 1PI, DMF 2 RG, & D Γ A) (based on 2P-vertices ) 2. critical exponents unbiased treatment of QCPs (on-going work) talk A. Valli

29
Thanks to: ✔ all collaborations A. Katanin (Ekaterinburg), K. Held (TU Wien), S. Andergassen (UniWien) N. Parragh & G. Sangiovanni (Würzburg), O. Gunnarsson (Stuttgart), S. Ciuchi (L‘Aquila), E. Gull (Ann Arbor, US), J. Le Blanc (MPI, Dresden), P. Hansmann, H. Hafermann (Paris). ✔ PhD/master work of G. Rohringer, T. Schäfer, A. Valli, C. Taranto (TU Wien) local vertex/D Γ A nanoD Γ ADMF 2 RG ✔ all of you for the attention!

Similar presentations

OK

Electronic Structure of Strongly Correlated Materials : a DMFT Perspective Gabriel Kotliar Physics Department and Center for Materials Theory Rutgers University.

Electronic Structure of Strongly Correlated Materials : a DMFT Perspective Gabriel Kotliar Physics Department and Center for Materials Theory Rutgers University.

© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Ppt on gsm based car security system Ppt on indian textile industries in uganda Ppt on teachers day Ppt on carl friedrich gauss contribution Animated ppt on magnetism physics Download ppt on mutual fund Ppt on office 365 Ppt on bond length of hbr Ppt on ufo and aliens facts Ppt on operating system and its functions