Presentation on theme: "Therapeutics for Hemophilia A June, 2013"— Presentation transcript:
1 Therapeutics for Hemophilia A June, 2013 Roger L. Lundblad, Ph.D.Consultant in BiotechnologyChapel Hill, North CarolinaAnd Adjunct Professor, Department of Pathology,University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina
2 Hemophilia in 1960-1970 University of North Carolina Experience 53 hemophilia A patients with 91 bleeding episodes; 13.3 units plasma/episodeRoberts, H.R., Graham, J.B., Webster, W.P., and Penick, G.D., Plasma transfusion therapy in hemophlila, in The Hemophilias, ed. K.M.Brinkhous, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA, 1964Therapeutics Costs10 to 20 cents a unitGreen, D., Therapeutic materials, in Hemophilia, ed. D.Green, C.C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, USA,. 1972
3 Therapeutic Products for Hemophilia A – A Statement of the Problem -2013 Hemophilia A is a congenital disorder affecting 1 in 10,000 males associated with the absence of factor VIII activity (severe, moderate, mild) – severe is less that 1% factor VIII with major problems – raise level to 5% (moderate) and the clinical picture is markedly improved. With a world population of 6 billion, there should be some 600,000 individuals with hemophilia A – my best guess is that there are likely 150,000 individuals being treated with high purity or ultra-high purity products.The dominant cost in the treatment of hemophilia A is the cost of therapeutic product – in the US, this is approximately $100,000 (US)/year – thus, despite a somewhat small consumer base, it is business with a cash flow of approximately 2.0 billion U.S./year – and this does not consider products such as FEIBA™ or NOVOSEVEN™ which are used to treat factor VIII inhibitors.There are a number of recombinant and plasma-derived therapeutic products; All products appear to be effective in providing hemostasis. Viral safety, while a risk factor with the plasma-derived products ( Modrow, S., Wenzel, J.J., Schimanski, S., et al., Prevalence of nucleic acid sequences specific for human parvoviruses, hepatitis A and hepatitis E viruses in coagulation factor concentrates, Vox Sang. 100, , 2011) does not appear to be a significant problem with the use of plasma-derived products.The development of inhibitors is the greatest risk factor in treatment of hemophilia A but there is substantial progress in tolerization ( Auerswald, G.,Bidlingmaier, C., and Kurnik, K., Early prophylaxis/FVIII tolerization regimen that avoids immunological danger signals is still effective in minimizing FVIII inhibitor developments in previously untreated patients – long term follow-up and continuing experience, Haemophilia 18, e18-e20, 2012).Prophylaxis is still an emerging concept and value depends on metrics used.The development of new factor VIII therapeutic products with extended half-life is proceeding rapidly. It is not known as to how such products will affect treatment cost.Gene therapy for hemophilia A is approaching reality.
4 Factor VIII Products -2013Treatment of hemophilia A is somewhat unique in that there are no competing technologies other than replacement therapy with factor VIII protein. The downside to this is that there are no “niche” markets for factor VIII. Greater than 90% of hemophilia A care cost is therapeutic product.Factor VIII protein may be obtained by recombinant DNA technology (including fusion protein production) and subsequent modification of protein (PEGylation).Factor VIII can be obtained from plasma fractionation. Other products from plasma such as IVIG and albumin support factor VIII manufacture from plasma (see Grifols, V., Financing plasma proteins: unique challenges, in Blood, Plasma and Plasma Proteins: A Unique Contribution to Modern Healthcare, ed. J.L. Valverde, IOS Press, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 2006 (Pharmaceuticals Policy and Law 7, , ). This is not different from the petrochemical industry (see Curran, L.M., Waste minimization practices in the petrochemical refining industry, J.Hazardous Mater. 29, , 1992)
5 Concept in Hemophilia Treatment -2013 Home TreatmentPipe, S., Visions in haemophilia care, Thromb.Res. 124 (Suppl 2, S2-S5, 2009.Mondorf W, Siegmund B, Mahnel R, Richter H, Westfeld M, Galler A, Pollmann H. Haemoassist--a hand-held electronic patient diary for haemophilia home care. Haemophilia Mar;15(2):Baker, J.R., Riske, B., Voutsis, M., et al., Insurance, home therapy, and prophylaxis in U.S. youth with severe hemophilia, Am.J.Prev.Med. 41 (Suppl. 4), S338-S345, 2011.Group Medical TreatmentLock, J., De Bruin, A., Scholten, M., et al., The group medical appointment (GMA) in haemophilia and von Willebrand’s disease: a new development in outpatient paediatric care, Haemophilia 12, , 2012.FutureFranchini, M. and Mannucci, P.M., Past, present and future of hemophilia: a narrative review, Orphanet J. Rare Dis.7:24, 2012.Knobe, K. and Berntorp, E., New treatments in hemophila: insights for the clinician, Ther.Adv.Hematol. 3, , 2012..Philippidis, A., Developing a balanced business model for gene therapy, Hum.Gene Ther. 22, , 2011..
6 Recent Advances in Factor VIII Development of products with extended circulatory half-life (see Sheridan, C., Hemophilia market awaits next-generation therapies, Nature Biotechnol. 29, 960, 2011).Pegylated Factor VIIICoupling to inserted surface cysteineCoupling to lysine residuesGlycopegylationFusion protein with Fc domainFactor VIII bound to PEGylated liposomesEngineered single chain factor VIII (Schulte, S., Pioneering designs for recombinant coagulation factors, Thromb.Res. 128 (Suppl 1), S9-S12, 2011).
7 Pegylated Factor VIIIThere has been significant progress on the development of pegylated factor VIII in the past two years.Ivens, I.A., Baumann, A., McDonald, T.A., et al., PEGylated therapeutic proteins: a review for haemophilia caregivers, Haemophilia 19, 11-20, 2013.Tang, L., Leong, L., Sim, D., et al., von Willebrand factor contributes to longer half-life of PEGylated factor VIII in vivo, Haemophilia , in press, 2013Kosloski, M.P., Pisai, D.S., Mager, D.E., and Balu-lyer, S.V., Allometry of factor VIII and informed scaling of next-generation therapeutic proteins, J.Pharm.Sci., in press, 2013.
8 Factor VIII Engineered for Extended Half-Life Eloctate™ (Factor VIII-Fc fusion protein), Biogen-Idec, BLA application accepted by FDAConcept of Fc fusion protein with prolonged half-life based on binding to neonatal Fc receptor (Suzuki, T., Ishii-Watabe, A., Tada, M., Importance of neonatal FcR in regulating the serum half-life of therapeutic proteins contains the Fc domain of human IgG1: a comparative study of monoclonal antibodies and Fc-fusion proteins to human neonatal FcR, J.Immunol. 184, , 2010.Factor VIII-Fc fusion protein has demonstrated extended half-life in a clinical trial (Powell, J.S., Josephson, N.C., Quon, D., et al., Blood, 119, , 2012.Inhibitor formation was not observed and there was an approximate 1.5 – fold extension of therapeutic half-lifePeters, R.T., Toby, G., Lu, Q., et al., Biochemical and functional characteristic of a recombinant monomeric factor VIII-Fc fusion protein, J.Thromb.Haemost. 11, , 2013.
9 Gene Therapy for Hemophilia A Johnson, J.M., Denning, G., Doering, C.B., and Spencer, C.T., Generation of an optimized lentiviral vector encoding a high-expression factor VIII transgene for gene therapy of hemophila A, Gene Ther., in press, 2013.McIntosh, J., Lenting, P.J., Rosales, C., et al., Therapeutic levels of FVIII following a single peripheral vein administration of rAAV vector encoding a novel human factor varient, Blood 121, , 2013.Zhu, F., Liu, Z., Wang, X., et al., Inter-chain disulfide bond improved protein trans-splicing increases plasma coagulation activity in C57BL/6 mice following portal vein FVIII gene therapy by dual vectors, Sci.China Life Sci. 56, , 2013.The above studies show that a combination of vector development and factor VIII engineering combine for progress in gene therapy for hemophilia A.
10 Biomarkers for Factor VIII A biomarker is defined as “a characteristic that is objectively measured and evaluated as an indicator of normal biological processes, pathogenic processes, or pharmacological responses to a therapeutic intervention.” Downing, D.O. for the Biomarkers Definitions Working Group, NIH, Bethesda, MD, USA, Biomarkers and surrogate endpoints: Preferred definitions and conceptual framework, Clin.Pharmacol.Therapeutics 69, 89-95, See also DeCaprio, A.P., Introduction to Toxicological Biomarkers, in Toxicological Biomarkers, ed. A.P. DeCaprio, Taylor & Francis, New York, NY, USA, 2006The major biomarker for hemophilia A is the activated partial thromboplastin timeClinical endpoint = stopping of bleedingThe availability of a documented clinical endpoint is a distinct advantage for gene therapy.
11 Assay of Factor VIIIFactor VIII is a cofactor (with apologies to hard-core biochemists) for the activation of factor X by factor IXa in a reaction which also requires calcium ions and platelets.The partial thromboplastin time (PTT) (developed in Chapel Hill) is likely the most reliable assay.There are all sorts of chromogenic assays which measure color and may or may not measure factor VIII.The assay is very important since factor VIII is “sold” by the unitLundblad RL, Kingdon HS, Mann KG, White GC. Issues with the assay of factor VIII activity in plasma and factor VIII concentrates. Thromb Haemost Dec;84(6):942-8.
12 Development of Concept of Blood Transfusion Development of transfusion medicine was critical to hemophilia therapyDirect donor to recipientPope Innocent vii (1406) donors and recipient expired, physician left the country1628 – William Harvey, Concept of Circulation1665 – Richard Lower – Blood Transfusion in dogs1818 – James Blundell – first successful blood transfusionTransfusion is species specificBlood may be transfused directly from vessel to vesselBlood may be passed into an intermediate container and remain for a short period of time before infusion into the recipient
13 First Treatment of Haemophilia A Lane, S., (1840), Lancet I,Treatment was reactive to a surgical procedure.Use of Whole bloodBlood collected from a donor into a funnel/syringe device4-6 ounces – 100 – 250 mLWithin the scope of the article, the patient recovered and did reasonably well
14 Technology Advances Required for the Use of Blood for Haemophilia A J. Braxton Hicks – 1869 – use of sodium phosphate as an anticoagulant – although mechanism not understood. It was not very successfulHicks, J.Braxton, Cases of transfusion with some remarks on a new method of performing the operation, Guys Hospital Reports, Series 3, Volume 14, 1-14, 1869Compared phosphate with whipping to remove fibrine.Transfusion used basin to collect blood and funnels for transfer.Low success rate – use of phosphate was based on the development of salt solutions for infusion.Duncan, J., On re-infusion of blood on primary and other amputations, Brit.Med.J. I, 192, 1886Cotterill, J.M., Severe injury from dynamite, tranfusion of blood, four times, recovery, Brit.Med.J. ii, 630, 1886
15 Technology Advances Required for the Use of Blood in the Treatment of Haemophilia A The development of anticoagulants for bloodAs noted by P.L. Mollison in an excellent review, the use of citrate allowed the separation of donor and recipient in space while the use of glucose enabled separation in time.Mollison, P.L., The introduction of citrate as an anticoagulant for transfusion and of glucose as a red cell preservative, Brit.J.Haematol. 108, 13-18, 2000.Boulton, F., A hundred years of cascading – started by Paul Morowitz ( ), a pioneer of haemostasis and transfusion, Transfusion Medicine 16, 1-10, 2006.
16 Factor VIII Therapy – 1936 Status 1840 – Lane (London) – Successful transfusion of whole blood for hemophilia1886 – Contrill (Edinburgh)-Phosphate anticoagulant1900 – Landsteiner - ABO blood grouping1911 – Addis – Defective prothrombin conversion in hemophilia1911 – Todd and White – Citrated blood for transfusion1915 – Ottenberg – Citrated blood for transfusion in hemophilia – correction for several days1916 – Addis – blood (phosphate) and serum corrected hemophilia for 24 hrs1916 – Rous and Turner – sucrose and citrate1936 – Blood bank at Cook County Hospital
17 Cohn FractionationDeveloped by E.J. Cohn and others at Harvard University in the late 1930’sMajor emphasis during WWIIFractionation of plasma by organic solvents, pH, and ionic strengthStill forms the basis for most human plasma fractionationBlombäcks developed derivatives of Cohn Fraction I such as I-0Pavlovsky used tannic acid precipitation to prepare derivatives of Cohn Fraction I
18 Early Development of Plasma Protein Therapeutics Dried Plasma – 1941Formalin-stabilized plasma – 1942Products from human placentaStable plasma protein fraction (PPF) –1952Cohn Fraction I – 1958Commercial IVIG – 1962 (although there were some studies in the 1940’sCryoprecipitate – 1963Commercial Factor VIII Preparations-1965Rh IgG – 1968Factor IX Concentrates – 1970 (also inhibitor products)
19 Economic “Drivers” for Plasma Fractionation 1940 – Albumin1960 – Factor VIII1900 – Present – IVIGSee Grifols, V., Financing plasma proteins: Unique challenges, in Blood, Plasma and Plasma Proteins: A Unique Contribution to Modern Healthcare, ed. J.L. Valverde, IOS Press, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 2006
20 Development of Modern Factor VIII Therapeutics Despite the advances in chromatography, plasma fractionation was (and for that matter with one exception) is still dominated by precipitation technologies.Chromatography did have an effect on plasma-derived therapeutic products until 1985 and that was immunoaffinity chromatography; immunoaffinity chromatography was developed in 1975 and successful in this context required the production of monoclonal antibodies.Introducing chromatography into a plasma fractionation facility is a disruptive innovation – see Govindarajan, V. and Kopalle, P.K., The Usefulness of Measuring Disruptiveness of Innovations Ex Post in Making Ex Ante Predictions, J.Prod.Innov.Manag. 23, 12-18, 2006.
21 Development of Modern Factor VIII Therapeutics Various groups continued to attempt make more effective derivatives of Cohn Fraction I.Jorpes, J.E., Blomback, B.,Blomback, M., and Magnusson, S., A pilot plant for the preparation of a human plasma fraction containing the human antihemophilic factor A (factor VIII) and v. Willebrand’s factor, Acta Med. Scand. Suppl. 379, 7-21, 1962Steinbuch, M., Precipitation methods in plasma fractionation, Vox Sang. 23, , 1972Newman, J., Johnson, A.J., Karpatkin, M.H., and Puszkin, S., Methods for the production of clinically effective intermediate- and high-purity factor VIII concentrates, Brit.J.Haematol. 21, 1-20, 1971Brinkhous, K.M., Wagner, R.H., Roberts, H.R., and Webster, W.P., Use of aliphatic amino acid precipitated antihemophilic factor in therapy of hemophilia, Bibl.Haemtol. 29, , 1968Judith Pool – CryoprecipitatePool, J.G. and Robinson, J., Observations in plasma banking and transfusion procedures for haemophilic patients using a quantitative assay fo antihemophilic globulin (AHG), Brit.J.Haematol , 1959.Pool, J.G., Hershgold, E.J, and Pappenhaggen, A.R., High-potency antihemophilic factor concentrate prepared from cryoglobulin precipitate, Nature 203, 312, 1964.Bennett, E., Dormandy, K.M., Churchill, W.G.L., Coward, A.R., Smith, M., and Cleghorn, T.E., Cryoprecipitate and the plastic blood-bag system: Provision of adquequate replacement therapy for routine treatment of haemophilia, Brit.Med.J. 2, 88-91, 1967.This enabled every blood bank to produce an effective therapeutic for hemophilia A.It was not possible to scale up the cryoprecipitate step for commercial fractionation, it was possible to include a “cold drop” at the start of the conventional plasma fractionation process as the cryosupernatant fraction could be taken through the Cohn Fractionation process.Still a useful approach (Kasper, C.K., Products for clotting factor replacement in developing countries, Semin.Thromb.Haemost. 31, , 2005)Immunoaffinity ChromatographyPedro Cuatrecasas – 1960’sLivingston, D.M., Immunoaffinity chromatography of proteins, Methods Enzymol. 34, , 1974Application to Factor VIII – 1982 – Baxter and AventisRecombinant DNA technologyStanford recombinant DNA – Cohen-Boyer patentHughes, S.S., Making dollars out of DNA. The first major patent in biotechnology and the commercialization of molecular biology, , Isis 92, , 2001Cutter/Genentech and Baxter/Genetics Institute
22 Factor VIII Concentrates 1960-1983 Kenneth Brinkhous, Harold Roberts, Gilbert White set the standards for hemophilia A care for several decades.Hemophilia dog colonyRobert Wagner and colleagues at UNC-CHAmino Acid Precipitation – Method IV Factor VIIIAlan Johnson at NYUPEG precipitationVirus ProblemsHougie, C., Thrombosis & Bleeding: an era of discovery, Trafford Publications, Victoria, BC, 2004
23 Development of Ultrahigh Purity Concentrates Drivers for something better than high purity concentratesProduct safety –”non-A,non-B hepatitis” –was not solved by heat treatmentFibrinogen overload – German regulatory agency – The circulatory half-life of factor VIII is approximately 14 hours; fibrinogen half-life is 4 days!
24 Development of Ultrahigh Purity Concentrates Immunoaffinity ChromatographyIsocratic method – best fit to manufacturingAntibodies to factor VIIIAntibodies to von Willebrand FactorConcomitant development of solvent/detergent technology at New York Blood Center.
25 Manufacture of Monoclonal-Purified Factor VIII Frozen PlasmaCryoprecipitateCold PrecipitateFibrinogen and Other StuffThaw at 2-4oC/centrifugeSupernatant Fraction to CohnSupernatant Fraction toMAB-Affinity stepThe highly purified factor VIII preparations no longer are effective for thetreatment of von Willebrand Disease – the high-molecular weight vWF isfound in the cold precipitate.Aronson (Aronson, D.L. and Chang, P., Ultracentrifugal analysisof factor VIII and von Willebrand factor in therapeutic preparations,Vox.Sang.69, 8-13, 1995) suggests that the interaction is complex with datasuggesting while infused factor VIII associated randomly with vWF while materialpurified from plasma using vWF affinity is unique
26 Recombinant DNA Technology and Factor VIII Cutter/GenentechKogenate®Baxter/Genetics InstituteRecombinate®Advate®Pharmacia/Wyeth(Genetics Institute)ReFacto® (B-domainless factor VIII)
27 Future Directions for Factor VIII Therapeutics Oldenburg, J., Dolan, G., and Lemm, G., Haemophilia care then, now and in the future, Haemophilia 15 (Suppl 1, 2-7, 2009Life expectancy have moved from 11 years in 1939 to 68 years in 1980Prophylactic use to prevent joint bleedingDelivery of therapyGene therapyImproved product
28 Future Directions for Factor VIII Therapeutics Current market is almost commodity in natureGrowth through product enhancementFactor VIII as a biopharmaceuticalGrowth into developing markets is constrained by infrastructureMarket needsProduct SafetyProduct efficacyTherapeutic effect driven by clinical endpointWhile a great product requires great science, great science does not make a great product
29 Future Directions for Hemophilia A Therapy Delivery “Cure”Gene TherapyGene FixingGene AugmentationDelivery of current product (avoid venipuncture)TransdermalOralPulmonaryNasalContinuous infusionImplantable pumpsFormulation issuesStability issuesModified Product (fraught with technical challenges)EngineeredChemically Modified
30 Gene Therapy for Hemophilia A Why has this not happened??Incredibly attractive commercial target for “proof of principle” for a technologyHowever, given the above, what is the “bottle?” – Is gene therapy a product or a service?Despite all of our knowledge, we still don’t understand gene expression??Addition cis-factors and trans-factors??Unknown epigenetic factors??Is there a specific cell type such that, for example, you cannot get sustained expression in muscle.Is the expression of factor VIII and von Willebrand Factor linked??
31 Gene Therapy for Hemophilia A Linkage of vWF and Factor VIII – Is this important for design of gene therapy?Fricke, W.A. and Yu, M.Y., Characterization of von Willebrand factor in factor VIII concentrates, Am.J.Hematol. 31, 41-45, 1989.Highly purified factor VIII from plasma associated with a small vWF multimerHighly purified factor VIII preparations do not correct von Willebrand disease.Montgomery, R.R. and Gill, J.C., Interactions between von Willebrand factor and Factor VIII: were did they first meet?, J.Pediatr.Hematol.Oncol. 22, , 2000.
32 Gene Therapy for Hemophilia A Co-expression of VIII and vWF required?Need different approachGene Therapy needs a business model – is it a service, a drug, a combination product – in some ways, has the same business issues as stem cells.Someone will make it work becauseGreat target – clear clinical endpoint and several animal model systemsGreat “proof-of-principle” such that company does not have to make money off success as it would validate a platform technology for a larger clinical target.
33 Future Directions for Hemophilia A Therapeutics Drug DeliveryNeedle-less delivery (See Prabhu, S., et al., Needles and needleless devices for infusion of anti-hemophilic factor concentrate: impact on protein structure and function, Haemophilia 12, 58-61, 2006)Infusion pumps – problems with long-term product stability – if this was easy, it would have happened for insulin.Need a new paradigm for this problem
34 Future Directions for Hemophilia A Therapeutics – Modified Proteins Saenko, E.L. and Pipe, S.W., Strategies towards a longer acting factor VIII, Haemophilia 12(suppl. 3), 42-51, 2006PEG Modification (Baxter and Nektar)Kingdon and Lundblad worked on this at UNC in the 1970’s with a total lack of successModification of lysine with small reagents results in factor VIII inactivation and the one published study on PEG modification does not provide optimismManning, F., et al., Effects of chemical modification on recombinant factor VIII activity, Thromb.Res. 80, , 1995Röstin, J., et al., B-domain deleted recombinant coagulation factor VIII modified with monomethoxy polyethylene glycol, Bioconjug.Chem. 11, , 2000PEGylated lipsomes (Bayer/Zilip (Amsterdam)/UC-Davis)Engineering to Improve StabilityPipe (Michigan)Lollar (Emory)
36 Future Direction for Hemophilia A Therapeutics Peptide Analogues – I was enthusiastic about this at one time but no longer – too many issues with regulation of activity expression.Lenting, P.J., et al., Ca2+ binding to the first epidermal growth factor-like domain of human blood coagulation factor IX promotes enzyme activity and factor VIII light chain binding, J.Biol.Chem. 271, , 1996Fay, P.J., et al., The A1 and A2 subunits of Factor VIIIa synergistically stimulate factor IXa catalytic activity, J.Biol.Chem. 274, , 1999Kolkman, J.A., et al., Regions and in the catalytic domain of blood coagulation factor IX are factor VIII-interactive sites involved in stimulation of enzyme activity, Biochem.J. 339, , 1999Bajaj, S.P., Factor IXa:Factor VIIIa interaction. Helix of factor IXa interacts with residues and spatially adjacent regions of the A2 subunit of Factor VIIIa, J.Biol.Chem. 276, , 2001
37 Future Directions for Hemophila A Therapeutics Carbohydrate ModificationIs carbohydrate heterogeneity a problem?Carbohydrate EngineeringDwek, R.A. et al., Targeting glycosylation as a therapeutic approach, Nat.Rev.Drug Disc. 1, 65-75, 2002Jones, J., Controlling N-linked glycan site occupancy, Biochim.Biophys.Acta 1726, , 2005
38 Some Basic Questions about Factor VIII Why is proteolysis associated with secretion?Why is factor VIII so big?Why is circulatory half-life dependent on von Willebrand factor?Why is half-life so short ?Hours instead of days?Why is there is a free sulfhydryl group?Why is copper bound? – does bound copper have anything to do with the free sulfhydryl group?What is the role of factor VIII in the activation of factor X by factor IXa?Factor IXa as a regulatory protease – what are factors involved in the increase in the increase in Vmax ? The decrease in Km is easier to manage.Is binding to platelets unique? Walsh PN, Camp E, Dende D. Different requirements for intrinsic factor-Xa forming activity and platelet factor 3 activity and their relationship to platelet aggregation and secretion. Br J Haematol Oct;40(2):
39 Why is secretion of factor VIII associated with proteolysis? Activity (or lack thereof) of single chain materialWould single-chain material be a better product?ReFacto™Why is thrombin activation required for normal factor VIII function?Is inactivation by activated protein C necessary?You need the answers to these questions when you consider engineered/modified factor VIIIFactor VIII as a thrombotic risk factorPabinger I, Ay C. Biomarkers and venous thromboembolism. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol Mar;29(3):332-6.