Presentation on theme: "Government Intelligentsia. Army Population The Key Actors in THE REVOLUTION TO COME:"— Presentation transcript:
Government Intelligentsia. Army Population The Key Actors in THE REVOLUTION TO COME:
Government 1900 Patrimonial = inherit Absolute Monarchy Hierarchy Bureaucratic Medieval Nikolaj II : Owned Russia! Of average intelligence Without a strong will Not a very happy little bear Family man Alexandra Fjodorovna, The Czaresse: Grand daughter of Victoria I. Born in Germany. Very willful. Believer in the absolute Monarchy. Russia loves to feel the whip
Problems were solved with oppression. The Czar used five tools to govern Russia: 1.The Civil Government – The Adminstration 2. The Secret Police 3. The aristocracy 4. The Army. 5. The Orthodox Church.
Did these five groups support the Czar? The Government: You followed orders. Radicals were shut up. Economy were run by the owners, the capitalists. So the Czar had no control over the Economy. The Secret Police: Suspicious about everything that wasnt State. You were considered an enemy if you didnt work for the state. Dual view – the state against its enemies the people. The aristocracy: In early 1800s tried to get more privilligies – loss of income Either liberals or reactionaries Lost most of their meaningful benefits No political group – Lenin was noble The army: 1,4 million men in arms Biggest army in the world Huge country no infrastruct ure Army non- political by tradition Served the guy in charge, no questions asked The church: 55 % were Russian Orthodox Lost its power when Peter the great had put civil servants as heads and Catharine the great took the land By tradition supporters of the monarch and non- political Liberal priests growing problem
How did you get a job in the Russian Administration? Your job was to help the Czar, you were a personal servant to him. You should please your superiors and the Czar. You were hired by your superiors and could be fired by him, no right to appeal. Never got fired since that meant that the superior made a mistake hiring you. No skills required, Loyalty and the ability to follow orders. Career? There were 14 grades, tjin. You start at the lowest 14th. Grade four and up = nobility. To get the good jobs you had to earn the higher grades. Problems caused by this : Higher civil servant had no contact with the people. Only the adjustable bureaucrat made a career. The people with drastic but good ideas never were promoted. Democracy never heard of. YOU FOLLOW THE BOSS, PERIOD, NO DISCUSSION!!!!
An image of Russian Administration = A Police-state. Czar. Ministry of Interior: Controlled Police. Prisons Censorship Proclaim state of emergency Secret Police w Agent. Guvernement, districts. Police department the most powerful. Could send people away up to five years w no trial. Villages. Village Councils.
Population in Russia % peasants. No private ownership. Family = ca 15 individuals.No enclosure movement. Serfdom (livegenskap) until 1861Very little interference from the State. What is good for the village is No nationalism = bad soldiers. good for the peasant. Population growth.Hunger for Land.
The power structure of the villages. The Village Council: Mir = the village community. Head of Village = Starosta = one person appointed by government. The Head of the family: Usually the grandfather. He owned everything. Dictator of the family. Bolsjak Sons of the family And husbands to the daughters. Women
Problems in the countryside: The Mir: What they decided went for the whole village. If they said that everybody should vote for Bolshevik – you voted for Bolshevik. Since the Starosta could be replaced he never disagreed with government. They decided on crops It only mattered what was good for the village. No feeling for the Nation = Bad soldiers. The Bolsjak-system: The young sons and husbands didnt own the land. No incitement to improve production. Growth = getting more land instead of improving methods. The individual had no idea which part of the land he would get. Didnt kick out the unproductive parts of farming society. No enclosure movement. The Hunger for Land: Peasants expected the Czar to give away the privately owned land to the mir and by that solving the problems in the countryside. Makes it easier for revolutionaries to recruit farmers.
Workers and Capitalists? WORKERS? Avery small part of the the Russian population Ca 1 million full time workers. Most workers were part time farmers. No right to form Unions. This will mean serious problems for the Bolsheviks CAPITALISTS? Wittes reforms Foreign investments 25 billion in gold Oil and coal producing giant The worlds fifth big economy Impossible to combine with Old ancient structure Police-state The smart civil servant will be radical anti-absolute monarch
THE INTELLIGENTSIA Whether the conflicts and the aggressions that exist in every society can be solved peacefully or explodes into a revolution is decided by in great extent by the presence or absence of democratic institutions capable of remedying discontent with laws, and the presence or absence of an intelligentsia who have decided to foment popular discontent with the purpose of seizing the power for themselves. Because it is the radical intelligentsia who transforms a stipulated discontent... to a relentless repudiation from the existing order. Revolts occur; revolutions are made. And they are made by groups of professional revolutionaries, that is to say the radical intelligentsia. My translation Pipes, Richard Den Ryska Revolutionen p 39
The Role of the intelligentsia and the individual Politicians The Intelligentsia in Russia: They need an ideology to exist. A RADICAL IDEOLOGY = This ideology gives the believers the insight that they have all the answers; They are the keepers of the truth. They are the social engineers that will save Russia. In order to do this they have the right to interfere in society They need money: The society must have a class of intellectuals, teachers, priests, professors etc. There superior insight in human life and behavior makes them keepers of a scientific truth, telling them how to raise the population They need support from finical groups in the society.
We will learn that in Russia a majority of the politicians were radical, why is that? The farmers and the workers never wanted to overthrow the Czar Revolution not by the people but for them. Compromises never worked. Expressing a different opinion meant jail Russian civil servants listen to the boss and followed orders Contact with the ordinary people was a big disappointment, they never wanted a revolution! Since you were violently oppressed you started using violent methods. No democracy meant that you took matters in your own hand. If you disliked a politician he had to be kicked out or killed Political power = Personal Power
Summing up, how this will help us to understand the future revolutions and how the Bolsheviks could get power so quick: 1.The Czar didnt want to rule and couldnt rule. 2.Major areas of the society were strictly hierarchal, most important the Government. To take power you had to change management, nothing else. 3.No democratic tradition = no democratic expectation. When the politicians are overthrown even if they were democrats nobody reacts. 4.Issues that people cared about were mainly concerning the Land Issue. They dont care about the right to vote etc. 5.Since the Czar had all the power, at least formally, the political struggle became focused on him and how to get rid of him, not on the actual problems. In a less hierarchal society revolution would have been unnecessary. When the Czar looses his power people are used to listening to one guy, hence they will take orders from the new guy in charge.