We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byMariano Mey
Modified over 2 years ago
Mike Emerson Partner Emerson Black Lawyers Brisbane © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Identify the property pool –Identify and value the wealth of the parties We are often charged with “finding the money” Assets may be actively concealed by a party –i.e. not “discovered” Onus of discovering party to reveal true financial circumstances –Process relies on veracity of the party disclosing Often necessary for other party to go FURTHER to reveal the TRUE financial picture © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Each party has an obligation to make a full and frank disclosure of his or her financial position Oriolo v Oriolo (1985) FLC 91 – 653 Full Court of the Family CourtFull Court of the Family Court Referred with approval to Smithers J in Briese v Briese (1986) FLC 91-713Referred with approval to Smithers J in Briese v Briese (1986) FLC 91-713 In financial proceedings each party must make a full and frank disclosure of all material facts & that such obligation is fundamental to the whole operation of the Family Law Act in financial cases and furthermore that mere compliance with the Rules of Court or Practice Directions does not alter the basic principle of the need for full and frank disclosure by the parties © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Failure to comply with such duty may result the Court doing the following: Excluding evidence that is not disclosed Imposing a consequence (including punishment for contempt of Court Making a finding that assets exist Each party has “a duty to the Court and to each other to give full and frank disclosure of all information relevant to the case, in a timely manner” Rule 13.01 (2) states that the duty of disclosure starts with the pre-action procedure for a case and continues until case is finalised © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Requirements for full and frank disclosure includes inter alia: A party’s earnings; Vested or contingent interests in property (including property owned by a legal entity or partially owned or controlled by a party); Other financial resources of a party; Trusts over which the party has an direct or indirect power or control; Certain disposals of property in the 12 months immediately before or since separation; Liabilities and contingent liabilities. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Conciliation Conference Pre Trial Conference Trial If a parties financial circumstances “have changed significantly” since initial Form 13 filed. Starting point for disclosure (Division 13.05) Court may order a party to file an affidavit giving further particulars of the party’s financial affairs Updated Form 13 to be filed prior to certain events such as (Division 13.06): © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
FACTS Husband (“H”) transferred some funds to woman he had been involved with for many years H optometrist by profession & parties had est. number of successful optical business Profits of business invested in real estate At time of trial 23 properties & identifiable property exceeding $33M ISSUE Did H, in addition to monies undisclosed in foreign accounts, hold significant assets which he had failed to disclose including: Cash; Jewellery; Gold Bullion OUTCOME Chief Justice Holden made an adjustment of 10% to allow for the findings in relation to undisclosed assets Held that whether the non-disclosure is wilful or accidental is beside the point © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
OUTCOME Cohen J (Trial Judge) found wife’s evidence re business records and income from business should be rejected Full Court found evidence of her earnings inconsistent with outgoings –Business records she produced virtually useless Trial Judge held husband understated his income –Concluded he had $5,000 in safe –Rejected his claims that he loaned his brother $10,000 Trial Judge used statements made by wife to her bank re her takings and value of business to discredit her evidence Also found alleged unregistered mortgage (claim by wife) to be sham © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
ISSUES Wife alleges her accountant, in valuing a relevant company, discovered discrepancies re understatement of sales; may have impacted on valuation of business; Parties’ son gave evidence that it was husband’s practice to pocket cash payments without recording them; Wife’s Counsel submitted : Husband deliberately incorrectly coded entries in order to mask his misappropriation of cash from cash sales. OUTCOME Trial judge not prepared to make a positive finding re husband’s alleged misappropriate of cash from cash sales; Full Court held that where clear evidence of non-disclosure: “…the court should not be unduly cautious about making findings in favour of the other party” © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
ISSUES Husband applied for redundancy without informing the wife Redundancy entitled him to benefits of approx $160,000 OUTCOME Full Court held that the husband was under a duty to disclose to the wife before Consent Order made that he had applied for redundancy and what his benefits would be © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
FULL COURT HELD Wilful non-disclosure by the husband re abalone licence & true nature of his relationship with a third party in relation to sale of same; Husband’s failure to disclose robbed wife opportunity to litigate issue of true value of licence; Non-disclosure was of such magnitude to amount to a miscarriage of justice © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
FACTS Husband embarked on financial restructuring involving establishment of family trust and superannuation fund; Effect reduced net value of net assets by borrowing against matrimonial home and moving borrowed funds into superannuation fund. ISSUE The restructuring meant the funds could only be regarded as a resource not an asset. OUTCOME Full Court felt the Trial Judge could have solved the issue by applying s.75(2) to give wife a substantial adjustment in her favour © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
OUTCOME Mullane J (Trial Judge) found husband significantly understated income of number of his companies; Rejected evidence that number of financial records stolen from his accountant; Not satisfied 1997/98 records provided reliable; Husband failed to call accountant as witness; Full Court held such failure could be relied on by Trial Judge when drawing adverse inferences against husband; Also held that Trial Judge had clear evidence from wife’s statements, husband’s history in cash dealings, discrepancy between details provided to court and lending institute and other evidence to find that there was substantiated undisclosed income. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Blatant Deceiver Secretive Business Owner Person of Straw (benevolent relative / partner) Hopeful Investor (capital applied but no result yet) Small Business Operator (big contract pending) International Money Mover Warehouser Obstructive Procrastinator Puppet, Sham or Alter Ego Money Launderer © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Examples of how assets may be hidden or undervalued: Failure to disclose or acknowledge cash takings or skimming cash from business owned; Assets simply “hidden”; Failure to disclose assets or resources held overseas; Undervaluing assets; Purchasing or registering assets in the name of “friendly” parties; Sale or transfer of business assets or shares at an undervalue to friendly parties; Provision of a benefit to a related party; Failure to include goodwill value of a business or undervaluing a goodwill factor; Failure to disclose assets acquired post separation; © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Examples of how assets may be hidden or undervalued: Diversion of Funds; Collusion with an employer; Salary paid by a business to non-existent employee or money paid from the business to someone close; Debt repayment to a friend for a debt that doesn’t exit; Delay in signing long-term business contracts or Renewing leases until after divorce; Arrangements may be underway for a private company to be bought out by a public company at a substantial premium on share values; A failure to cooperate in relation to disclosure may in itself be a strong indication that a party has something to hide; © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Examples of how assets may be hidden or undervalued: Manipulation of doubtful debts and write offs; Manipulation of stock figures; The second receipt book; The holding of assets including cash in unidentified safe custody boxes; Lifestyle is often an indicator of funds being available which may not have been disclosed or acknowledged. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Initial client interview Client’s perception of when serious matrimonial problems arose Subtle changes picked up by the client © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
In the year prior to separation Jane noticed: Her husband changed the way he handled finances; Bank account balances were depleted; His pay no longer deposited in joint account; Creditors demanding payment on delinquent accounts; More frequent business trips. Her lawyers recognized that her husband had probably hidden significant assets and unless located they couldn’t be included in divorce settlement. Michaelson, William M, “Divorce: a game of hide and seek?”, Journal of Accountancy Vol 181 (3), P67 © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Form 13 – compare information disclosed with the following: Tax returns; Real Property Searches; ASIC searchs; Balance Sheets & Profit & Loss Accounts; Bank Statements; Quarterly BAS Statements. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Income Tax Returns; Pay Slips; Depreciation schedules may reveal an undervaluing of certain assets; Similarly with assets in a self managed superannuation fund; Bench marks; © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Personal finance statements or loan applications; Credit card statements are of great assistance; Financial Statements for business over several years; Quarterly BAS statements for businesses; Databases and registries should be utilized; Telephone accounts; © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Websites; Passports; It is usually easier to obtain information before separation; © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Special expertise / experience in unravelling complex financial structures; Valuing differing business entities; and / or Pinpointing discrepancies in financial statements; Carefully framing questions or requesting documents or pursuing lines of inquiry that might clarify these. The Family Law Rules 2004 made dramatic changes to the provision of accounting evidence in the Family Court. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Parties may each retain SHADOW EXPERTS to review the opinions of the single accounting expert; Need a good working relationship between accountant and lawyer Criteria for good forensic accountant: Competence and experience essential; Ability to communicate at a number of different levels; Confident and articulate but not aggressive demeanour; Used to meeting and dealing with people at all levels; Experience in writing reports and giving evidence; Resilience to withstand cross examination; Compliance with practice directions and rules of court pertaining to experts. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Meeting between client and forensic accountant should be arranged at an EARLY STAGE of the process; Not every separation requires a forensic examination; Knowledge of when to engage a forensic expert comes from experience; Clearly complex cases involving a number of corporate entities or trusts may require one. Similarly where there is specific knowledge of non-disclosure or high degree of suspicion of non-disclosure. © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Subpoenae Anton Piller Orders Mareva Injunctions Tools to assist in locating and identifying or preventing dissipation of the asset or removal from the Court’s jurisdiction © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
A mandatory injunction requiring respondent to permit the applicant to enter the respondent’s premises to search for, inspect and remove documents or things specified in the order; An order for seizure of evidence to enable party to prove existence of undisclosed asset; Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processing Ltd  Ch 55 at p 62 Ormrod LJ specified three essential pre-requisites: 1.Extremely strong prima facie case; 2.Damage, potential or actual, must be very serious for applicant; 3.Clear incriminating evidence and possibility defendants will destroy such material. Division 14.04 Family Law Rules © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
The order may: a)Require respondent to permit the applicant either alone or with another person, to enter the respondent’s premises and inspect or seize documents or other property; b)Require respondent to disclose specific information relevant to case; c)informing anyone other than his lawyer that an order has been made. Division 14.04(3) Family Law Rules Requirements of an affidavit in support of application See also Conditions or undertakings in Federal Court Practice Note (8 April 1994) © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Mazur v Mazur (1992) FLC 92-305 Only property briefcase containing $20,000 in closet in former matrimonial home Court held that it is essential for Court to take steps, when it is necessary, to permit property to be ascertained & to be retained Talbot v Talbot (1995) FLC 92-586 To grant an order against someone who is not, and will not be a defendant in an inter partes application would be “to introduce an unwarranted extension of the field of operation of what is, in any event, a very draconian procedure” Lindenmayer J © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
A temporary order which temporarily freezes assets to prevent dissipation of the asset within the jurisdiction of the court, or removal of the assets from the court’s jurisdiction Division 14.05 Family Law Rules Division 14.05 (1) A party may apply if: 1.Order will be incidental to an existing or prospective order made in favour of applicant; OR 2.Applicant has existing or prospective claim that is able to be decided in Australia © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Division 14.05 (2) Obligatory for applicant to file affidavit in support which includes: 1.Description of nature & value of respondent’s property in & out of Australia; 2.Reason applicant believes respondent’s property may be removed from Australia & why dealing should be restrained; 3.Damage likely to result; 4.Identification of anyone other than respondent who may be affected by order and how affected; 5.Amount and basis of substantive claim & if made ex parte details of possible response © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Waugh v Waugh (2000) FLC 93-052 Full Family Court held: before Family Court can make interlocutory injunction must be satisfied that risk of disposal of property in order to defeat judgement evident Jackson v Sterling Industries Ltd (1987) 162 CLR 612 “As a general proposal, it should now be accepted in this country that a Mareva injunction can be granted…. If the circumstances are such that there is a danger of [the defendant] absconding, or a danger of assets being removed out of the jurisdiction or disposed of within the jurisdiction or otherwise dealt with so that there is a danger that the plaintiff, if he gets judgement, will not be able to get it satisfied.” © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
The service of a subpoenae to produce documents and / or give evidence Lucas Industries v Hewitt (1978) 18 ALR 555 “The purpose of the process of subpoena is to facilitate the proper administration of justice between parties. For that purpose it is the policy of the law that strangers who have documents may be put to certain trouble in searching for and gathering together relevant documents and bringing them to court. It is according to the same principle that persons who have knowledge of facts are put to the inconvenience of being brought to court and are required to give evidence.” Subpoenae are a most useful tool to parties or practitioners to assist in production of records which may divulge hidden assets © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Bankers or financial institutions used by a party Accountants De Facto spouse or partner Compliant family member Credit card provider Solicitors Business organizations and employers © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Level 8 “Northpoint”PO Box 13166 231 North QuayGEORGE STREET POST OFFICE BRISBANE QLD 4000BRISBANE QLD 4003 Ph: (07) 3211 4222 Fax: (07) 3211 4277 Direct Email: firstname.lastname@example.org@embl.com.au email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org “Disclosure, Hidden Assets and Working with Forensic Accountants to locate them” by Mike Emerson, Partner Research Assistant: Kathryn Neri (Articled Clerk) Powerpoint presentation: Danielle Wright (Articled Clerk) © Emerson Black Lawyers 2005
Anton Piller Orders Page 1 Civil Search Warrants: How They Are Used In Fraud Cases ACFE 2014 Canadian Conference September 8, 2014 Rosanne Walters, CPA,
Pre-action Procedure for Financial Cases. Pre-action Procedure- Financial Cases Rule 1.05(1)- each prospective party to the case must comply with the.
Unit 2 Seminar Bankruptcy Law. Credit Cards Bank Loans Home Mortgages Car Loans Student Loans Character: employers, country clubs and some colleges and.
1. Is a challenging task Requires a great amount of work and time Involves numerous steps, which include*: 2 – write a business plan – obtain business.
CHAPTER 3: BUYING A LOCAL BUSINESS. OBJECTIVES: To find the factors you need to consider when purchasing a local business. To get a better idea of what.
International Accounting Standard 37 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets.
FUNDAMENTALS OF ACCOUNTING Dr. Rana Singh
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT SYSTEM Balance sheet Profit and loss Sales Claims/Warranty Stock Payroll Purchases Assets Cash Taxation Borrowings Risk DisclosuresManagement.
Chapter 36 Financing the Business Section 36.1 Preparing Financial Documents Section 36.2 Financial Aspect of a Business Plan Section 36.1 Preparing Financial.
INDEPENDENCE AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (Article IV): AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (Article IV): “A member should maintain objectivity and.
A GIA is a contract between a surety company and a contractor (or subcontractor)/principal. A GIA is a standard, typical document in the construction.
Chapter 7 Bootstrapping and Financing the closely held company.
Auditing: The Art and Science of Assurance Engagements Chapter 4: Legal Liability Copyright © 2011 Pearson Canada Inc.
Chapter 7 Commercial bank financial statement Salwa Elshorafa 2009 © 2005 Pearson Education Canada Inc.
TITLE 101 Introduction A real estate investment is substantial, perhaps your clients largest outlay of money, and therefore, the largest risk. A real estate.
1 The Work Sheet and Financial Statements Chapter 8.
Chapter 26 Chapter 11: Plan Confirmation. Disclosure Statement Hearing The disclosure statement hearing is the first step in the Chapter 11 reorganization.
BASIC FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Chapter 2. Introduction to Financial Statements Companies prepare interim financial statements and annual financial statements.
SMALL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT Chapter 7 Financing the Small Business.
Structures for Investors Presented by: Kerrie-Anne Bailey KAS Tax & Business Solutions Phone: (07) April.
Needles Powers Principles of Financial Accounting 12e The Statement of Cash Flows 15 C H A P T E R ©human/iStockphoto.
Willet C. Jim Financial Consultant Zenas Legal Practice (ACCA, B.Acc UZ)
Chapter 18 Escrow Procedures. The last step in the loan process is CLOSING, when the loan proceeds are distributed and a deed to the property is transferred.
MODULE 2 INTRODUCTION TO DIRECTORS’ DUTIES ADB Private Sector Development Initiative Corporate and Financial Governance Training Solomon Islands Dr Ann.
THE BANKERS BOOK OF EVIDENCE ACT, 1891 It is applicable to the whole of India except J&K This is applicable to any company under section 3 of Companies.
Small Business Loans Kim Pope, Vice President, Regional Manager Business Banking Group.
Financing the Small Business Dr. Muslim Suardi, MSi., Apt. School of Pharmacy, Faculty of Sciences UNIVERSITY OF ANDALAS.
Chapter 17 Completing the Audit Engagement McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Primary Function Major Source of Income Major funds used for this purpose 2.
DIRECTOR’S LEGAL LIABILITIES Doug Jackson Gungoll, Jackson, Collins & Box, P.C.
LITIGATION MANAGEMENT – Effective Cost Containment 2002 Conference Branson, Missouri.
Auditors’ Reports. McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2004 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved We have audited the accompanying balance sheet.
1 Chapter 6: Revenue Analysis. 2 Revenue Recognition Criteria Both the criteria should be satisfied: Good and service has been delivered Cash is collected.
Slide Auditors’ Reports. Slide Review of Audit Process 1. Obtain an understanding of internal control sufficient to plan the audit. 2. Determine.
The Advisers Act Custody Rule Presentation at the FIRMA 2011 National Risk Management Training Conference April 18, 2011 Kenneth J. Berman Gregory J. Lyons.
Understanding Business and Personal Law The Partnership Section 27.2 Sole Proprietorship and Partnership Partnership law is largely found in the Uniform.
Unit 9 Seminar Business Organizations. Things to do this unit: UNIT 9 – Read Chapter 13 and 14 – Respond to the Discussion Board – Attend the Weekly Seminar.
Copyright © 2007 Pearson Education Canada 1 Chapter 4: Legal Liability.
Company Law II. Shares All companies require funds to operate. Companies raise funds through shares and debentures. “Shares” means the interests of members.
Chapter 12 Exchange of non-monetary assets. exchange of non-monetary assets Non-monetary assets and monetary assets Monetary assets: currency held.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 53: Family Law Chapter 53: Family Law Business Law Legal, E-Commerce,
Chapter 14 Audit of Acquisitions, Related Equity Transactions, Long- Term Liabilities, and Equity.
EXPERT EVIDENCE: GETTING IT RIGHT Presentation to HICFG by Alistair Webster Q.C Elizabeth Nicholls.
Managerial Accounting Preparing and Using the Statement of Cash Flows Chapter 17.
CHAPTER FOUR – SOURCES OF FINANCE. SOURCES OF FINANCE Internal Sources Refers to funds that are generated from within the firm itself – from owner’s.
Financial Audit Autonomous Bodies AS 1 and 4 Session Accounting Standards.
Chapter 17 Completing the Audit Engagement. Review for Contingent Liabilities A contingent liability is defined as an existing condition, situation, or.
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.