Presentation on theme: "1 Realign Setusamudram Channel Aspects of National sovereignty, security and livelihood of coastal people S. Kalyanaraman, Ph.D., Director, Sarasvati Research."— Presentation transcript:
1 Realign Setusamudram Channel Aspects of National sovereignty, security and livelihood of coastal people S. Kalyanaraman, Ph.D., Director, Sarasvati Research Centre, Former Sr. Exec., Asian Development Bank, 17 April 2007 Download from:
2 Location map. Inset: bathymetry map of the Gulf of Mannar (reproduced from Murty et al., 1994)
3 Setusamu dram Channel Passage – current alignment
5 Computer simulation: Ram Sethu saved coastline from tsunami on Dec. 26, Evidences for Rama Setu 2. Preparedness for next tsunami 3. Impact on coastal life and national sovereignty
6 Sir AR Mudaliar Committee Report 1956: Choose canal, NOT mid-ocean channel passage We are convinced that the Adam’s Bridge site is unsuitable for the following reasons: Shifting Sandbanks in this area present a far more formidable problem – both at the stage of construction and during maintenance – than the sand dunes on the island site. Approaches to a channel would be far too open with no possibility of construction of protective works. A channel at this site – even if it can be made and maintained (which is unlikely) – would entail definite navigational hazard. Channel would be bordering on the Sethusamudram Medial Line. In these circumstances we have no doubt, whatever that the junction between the two sea should be effected by a Canal; and the idea of cutting a passage in the sea through Adam’s Bridge should be abandoned.
7 Consequences of Sethusamudram Channel Bharatam’s sovereignty and integrity undermined by declaring these as international waters under US pressure Tsunami assessment was not done –Removal of the proven Tsunami protector in Rama Sethu –Opens up serious potential damage of entire Kerala and Tamilnadu coast when next tsunami hits (per T.Murthy, leading Tsunami expert and advisor to GOI) –Thorium deposits in Kerala (Aluva, Chavara), Tamilnadu (Manavalakurichi) that support nuclear power source for India will be desiccated –Tsunami protection measures NOT incorporated in the project Ancient heritage monument with attested evidences (textual and scientific); Damage to Rama Setu a violation of Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 (A monument which has remained in existence for over 100 years)
8 Dhanushkodi to Talaimannar Pamban cantilever bridge NASA image: Adam’s bridge
9 Suggestio falsi, suppressio veri: Ambika Soni New Delhi, Mar 06, 2007: Government on Tuesday said there are no archaeological studies that reveal the existence of a Ram Setu bridge between India and Sri Lanka. However, a NASA satellite picture has shown the existence of a stretch of land bridge in the Palk Strait between the countries, Minister of Tourism and Culture Ambika Soni said in a written reply to the Rajya Sabha today. She informed the house that as there are no archaeological studies to confirm the fact, the government was not planning to take any preservation initiative in this direction. ttp://zeenews.com/articles.asp?aid=358346&sid=NAT ttp://zeenews.com/articles.asp?aid=358346&sid=NAT
10 Evidence from NASA websites A news report date-lined Rameswaram, 15 April 2007 in the New Indian Express (page 7) noted:"... Baalu said the government and the Sethusamudram project officials had written to NASA on the Adam's Bridge, but there has been no reply from NASA." Item 1: February 2000 Report of NASA Shuttle Radar Topography Mission (SRTM) of NASA aboard space shuttle Endeavour launched in February "Sri Lanka is shaped like a giant teardrop falling from the southern tip of the vast Indian subcontinent. It is separated from India by the 50km (31mi) wide Palk Strait, although there is a series of stepping- stone coral islets known as Adam's Bridge that almost form a land bridge between the two countries." Item 2: April 1966 Report of NASA 168/section3b.htm Exploring space with a camera by NASA " Gemini XI. This photograph from an altitude of 410 miles encompasses all of India, an area of square miles," GEORGE M. LOW, then the Deputy Director, Manned Spacecraft Center, NASA, notes. "Bombay is on the west coast, directly left of the spacecraft's can-shaped antenna New Delhi is just below the horizon near the upper left. Adam's Bridge between India and Ceylon, at the right, is clearly visible. A cloudless region surrounds the entire subcontinent. Differences in color, green near the west coast, and brown inland, delineate regions of heavy vegetation and semiarid areas." The picture by NASA is available on the NASA website. 168/section3b.htm
11 Research report Asiatic Society, 1799, Asiatick Researches: Or, Transactions of the Society Instituted in Bengal, P. 52 refers to the bridge called Setband (alt. spelling, setuband like Allahband; setu-bandha), broken in 3 places. It also notes “The people call it a bridge; or otherwise it appears to have wood growing on it, and to be inhabited.”Asiatick Researches: Or, Transactions of the Society Instituted in Bengal, P. 52
12 Malabar Bowen map (1747) drawn by Netherlands shows Ramarcoil I (that is, Rama temple).
13 Map drawn by Joseph Parks, Australian Botanical explorer (1788) shows Ramar Bridge (Map in Sarasvati Mahal Lib., Thanjavur) Map of 1804, by James Rennel, First Surveyor General of India, renamed Ramar Bridge as Adam’s bridge
14 Religious and cultural sites, 8th- 12th centuries Schwartzberg Atlas, p. 34.
15 Islamic expansion and changing Western views of South Asia, 7th-12th centuries Schwartzberg Atlas, v., p. 33.
16 Puranic India (Bharata) Schwartzberg Atlas, v., p. 27.
17 India of the Vedas and the Epics Schwartzberg Atlas, v., p. 13.
18 ( Madras Presidency Administration Report, 1903 and a Travelogue, 1744 refer to the bridge Glossary entry: Adam. …”Called the bridge of Rama… It really joined Ceylon to India until 1480, when a breach was made through rocks during a storm. A subsequent storm enlarged this and foot traffic then ceased…Partly above and partly below water; but when covered has now here above three or four feet of water…” Source: Manual of the Administration of the Madras Presidency./C.D. Maclean (1903). New Delhi, AES, 3 Vols., 2440 p., Contents: Vol. 1: Chapters 1-9 Containing: The Principal Articles of the Manual Arranged so as to Conform to the Order of Subjects in the Yearly Presidency Administration Report. Vol. 2: Appendices Containing: Articles and Statements, Supplementary of the Articles in Vol. 1 Arranged Under General Heads. Vol. 3: Glossary of the Madras Presidency: A Classification of Terminology, a Gazetteer and Economic Dictionary of the Province and Other Information, the Whole Arranged Alphabetically and Indexed. Travelogue A book by Alexander Hamilton, 1744, A New Account of the East Indies: Giving an Exact and Copious Description of the Situation, P. 338 describes his visit to ‘zeloan’ (alt. spelling for Ceylon) by walking on the bridge.
19 Hon’ble Mu. Karunanidhi cites evidence for Rama Setu In a book titled, Ramanathapuram District Gazetteer published in 1972, Mu. Karunanidhi writes a foreword and praises the contents Mu. Karunanidhi the current Chief Minsiter of Tamilnadu was also CM at that time. The book refers to Rama Setu (also called Adam’s bridge or Nala Setu).
20 Setu in texts ( The word ‘setu’ in Tamil, Sanskrit and almost all bharatiya languages means ‘bridge’) Valmiki describes the construction of Sethu in detai (85 shlokas). hastimaatraan mahaakaayaaH paaSaaNaamshca mahaabalaaH parvataamshca samutpaaTya yantraiH parivahanti ca Valmiki Ramayana Vaanara having huge bodies, with mighty strength uprooted elephant-sized rocks and mountains and transported them by mechanical contrivances (yantraih). Vedavyasa refers to Nalasetu nalasetur iti khyāto yo 'dyāpi prathito bhuvi rāmasyājñā ṃ purask ṛ tya dhāryate girisa ṃ nibha ḥ MBh which even today, popular on earth as Nala's bridge, mountain-like, is sustained out of respect for [Lord] Rama's command. (Nala was son of Vis’wakarma) Kalidasa's Raghuvams’a (sarga 13): Rama, while returning from SriLanka in pushpaka vimaana: "Behold, Sita, My Sethu of mountains dividing this frothy ocean is like the milky way dividing the sky into two parts" Kaavya in Prakrit by King Pravarasena II ( CE) called “Setu bandha or Ravanavaho.”; "Dasamuha Vadha" (Setubandha Kavya) by the King Damodara Sen (5th Century). Skanda Purana (III ), Vishnu Purana (IV ), Agni Purana (V-XI), Brahma Purana ( ) refer to the construction of Rama Setu. Skanda Purana (VI ) describes the installation of threee Shiva linga at the end, middle and beginning of Rama Setu and making the same bridge submerged and thereby creating Setu-Teerth. This is also related in Kurma Purana ( ). Garuda Purana ( ) lists sacred places including Setubandh and Rameswar. Narada Purana (Uttara Bhag ) extols the greatness of Rama- Setu.
21 Bore-hole locations Geomorphology Consequences of dredging and opening of Rama Setu: Likely destruction of fragile coral islands by sediments and turbulent tides of Bay of Bengal entering the tranquil Gulf of Mannar Alternatives: Realign canal towards Pamban; like Panama Canal, locks could be provided both in the Palk bay side and Gulf of Mannar side so that such calamities could be prevented. Source: Dr. S. Badrinarayanan
22 Geological, archaeological evidence: Dept. of Earth Sciences (March 2007) Since the calcareous sand stones and Corals are less dense than normal hard rock and quite compact, probably these were used by the ancients to form a connecting link to Sri Lanka, on the higher elevations of the Adams bridge ridge and this is analogous to modern day causeway. Around Rameswaram, there are raised Teri formations that supported a rich assemblage of mesolithic – microlithic tools indicating the presence of strong human habitation and activity in these areas as early as 8000 to 9000 years B.P and as recent as 4000 years B.P. On Sri Lanka side there are indications of human habitation extending to late Pleistocene (about 13,000 B.P) based on bone and fossils of human and animal form. All these point to a flourishing human activity on both sides of Adams Bridge and probably when the sea levels were just right the link between India and Sri Lanka could have been established.
23 Setu in Epigraphs Hampi inscription of Krishnaraya Saka 1430 (1508 CE) in Epigraphica Indica refers to Rama Setu
24 New Shipping Canal route damages Rama Setu Status: 12 April 2007: About 1.4 % dredging done in the Rama Sethu area (35.05 kms.) Dhanushkodi Thalaimannar ~ 30 kms Rama Sethu – shoal remains ~3.5 m Current Sea Level ~ 12 m ~300 m hole Sea levels change; and were 130 m lower about 18,000 years ago, that is, the Setu would have been used to link Dhanushkodi and Talaimannar
25 Impact on the livelihood of coastal people U. Arulanandam, President, Singaravelar Fishermen's Forum : the project is being implemented to enforce the international boundary line in the waters. Once the canal is a reality, it will become an unofficial boundary line on the sea between India and Sri Lanka. The channell would seal fishermen’s entry into Srilanka waters where fish thrive.
26 From ancient times, the Gulf of Mannar, Palk Bay have been treated as Historic Waters (Internal Waters of Bharatam-Srilanka). An arbitrary international boundary has been drawn and called the Sethusamudram Canal without any evaluation and without studying the impact of tsunami of Dec. 26, US Navy Operational Directive of 23 June 2005 refused recognition of the Historic Waters claim. USA asserted its authority by sending its naval ships. Geopolitics: USA : Diego garcia, Trincomalee, Straits of Malacca China: Gwadar, Haumtota, Sitwe
27 Serious consequences of Route 6, suddenly chosen Route 6, cutting through Rama Setu, ignores other expert committee-recommended options n
28 Seven shell bangles from burial of an elderly woman, Harappa; worn on the left arm; three on the upper arm and four on the forearm; 6.3 X 5.7 cm to 8x9 cm marine shell, Turbinella pyrum (After Fig. 7.43, Kenoyer, 1998) Harappa museum. H to 637; 676 to 679. Wide bangle made from a single conch shell and carved with a chevron motif, Harappa; marine shell, Turbinella pyrum (After Fig. 7.44, Kenoyer, 1998) National Museum, Karachi HM ,500 year-old S’ankha industry, Gulf of Mannar
29 Fast track Sethusamudram Channel Project (SSCP): 1. US Navy operational directive, 23 June 2005: 2. Chairman TCPT replies to PMO 30 June 2005 ; 3. Inauguration of SSCP 2 July Waters of Palk Bay between coast and boundary with Sri Lanka claimed as internal waters; waters of Gulf of Mannar between coast and maritime boundary claimed as historic waters. This claim is not recognized by the United States. U.S. conducted operational assertions in 1993 and 1994, to Gulf of Mannar claim in (jiska laat uski bhains or tadi eduttavan tandal kaaran) Aug 76 Act No. 80 Enables government to declare waters as historic. Jun 79 Law No. 41 United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea (1958), Convnention of the Territorial Sea and Contiguous Zone recognizes HISTORIC Waters Agreement between Sri Lanka and India on the Maritime Boundary between the two Countries in the Gulf of Mannar and the Bay of Bengal and Related Matters 23 March 1976 on Historic waters
30 Importance of Thorium for Bharat From BARC website: Thorium deposits - ~ 3,60,000 tonnes The currently known Indian thorium reserves amount to 358,000 GWe-yr of electrical energy and can easily meet the energy requirements during the next century and beyond. India’s vast thorium deposits permit design and operation of U-233 fuelled breeder reactors. These U-233/Th-232 based breeder reactors are under development and would serve as the mainstay of the final thorium utilization stage of the Indian nuclear programme.
31 Thorium/titanium placer deposits due to churning action of ocean currents
32 Next tsunami through channel route will destroy Kerala and Tamilnadu coastline: tsunami energy will funnel through as Ram Setu barrier is dented. This serious consequence should be evaluated by a multi-disciplinary team as recommended by Rameswaram Judge. Be prepared for a probable next tsunami. Geoscientific investigations on the active convergence zone between the east Eurasian and Indo-Australian Plates along Indonesia (GINCO I) FSSONNE cruise SO-137 Fault-lines and earthquake zones
33 Tsunami effect: 2,60,000 lives lost Destruction of Aceh island, damage in beaches north of Chennai and Nagapattinam Sea-bed has risen by about 200 m. 2/3 of the aquatic life and corals devastated in the Biosphere Reserve/Marine National Parks
34 Prof. Tad S. Murthy’s views Prof. Tad S Murthy is a tsunami expert who advised Govt. of India on tsunami warning system and edited Tsunami journal for over 20 years Prof. Tad S Murthy’s objections were cited in PMO’s letter of Jan He said: Change the mouth of the alignment (Bay of Bengal) norwestwards to avoid destruction of Kerala by next tsunami "The Sethusamudram canal has many characteristics similar to the Alberni canal, and this is the reason I am concerned. In the March 28, 1964, Alaska earthquake tsunami, outside of Alaska the largest tsunami amplitude was at the head of the Alberni canal well inland and not at the open coast as everyone expected. Later, I explained this was due to (a phenomenon known as) quarter wave resonance amplification," Murty explained.” From Personal Communication, Feb. 2007: “I requested him (Raghupathy) to consider slightly re-orienting the entrance of the Sethu canal on the Bay of Bengal side, so that in future tsunami events, tsunami energy will not be preferentially funnelled into the Sethu canal. Shri Raghupathy assured me that he will look into this matter. When a senior IAS officer like Shri Raghupathy says something, I beleive him and I have no further concerns on this matter.”
35 Incorporate Tsunami protection measures; tsunami protection wall, Japan Save the livelihood of coastal people who safeguard the coral and algae reefs Preserve the status of Historic Waters S’ankha (turbinella pyrum), like Sri Rama is an abiding metaphor of Bharatiya Civilization
36 Ancient Setu coins of Jaffna, 13 th century and Parantaka Chola copper plate (10 th century) (Nagaswamy R Thiruttani and Velanjeri Copper Plates. State Dept. Of Archaeology, Tamilnadu. Madras. See: L’Hernault F L’Iconographie de Subrahmanya au Tamilnad, Institut Francais d’ Indologie. Pondichery, p.111, ph. 63.) The copper plates indicate that Aparajitavarman went to Setutirtha. Setupati coinage, 16 th and 17 th century Obverse: Sri Ganapati, seated.Reverse, in Tamil, Se-Tu-Pa- (Ti missing).
37 References NASA, Google Earth photgraphs and other information Dept. of Earth Sciences, Govt. of India (March 2007) Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 cited at Other references from google search on Rama Sethu, Adams Bridge, Sethusamudram Project