Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byFrancis Crooke Modified over 3 years ago

1
Bi-intervals for backtracking on temporal constraint networks Jean-François Baget and Sébastien Laborie

2
2 Motivations My schedule problem (as a temporal constraint network) : Talk Mail Boss Slides meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Nodes are time intervals Arcs are disjunctions of Allen’s relations [Allen:83] QUESTION Is there a possible schedule solution ? QUESTION Is there a possible schedule solution ? This problem is NP-complete

3
3 Related Work Generate all instantiations of relations. Test networks consistency using path-consistency [Allen:83]. Use optimizations: constraints and relations ordering [Van Beek and Manchak:96]… Instantiate constraints : To handle mixed qualitative/quantitative relations : instantiate variables during backtrack To handle mixed qualitative/quantitative relations : instantiate variables during backtrack Use backtracking optimizations such as forward checking [Schwalb et.al.:97] Use backtracking optimizations such as forward checking [Schwalb et.al.:97] Finitely partition the infinite domains of interval values e.g., using an interval end-points encoding [Thornton et.al.:05] Backtrack on these finite partition. Instantiate variables :

4
4 Outline Instantiate variables with abstract intervals Backtrack with abstract intervals Forward checking with abstract intervals Forward checking (version 2) with abstract intervals Instantiate variables with bi-intervals Conclusion Backtrack with bi-intervals Forward checking with bi-intervals (in the paper)

5
5 Abstract intervals An abstract interval [x,y] is a pair of elements from a totally ordered list. They encode an infinite number of intervals of real numbers. Definition : Example : Talk Mail meets 17H10 18H30 Talk Mail 17H30 17H25 19H Talk Mail 17H40...... AB C Talk Mail

6
6 [a,b] possibilities instantiations [a,b] [b,c][d,a] [e,c][a,c][f,c][b,g] XXXX meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains ab c d [b,c],[d,a] ef g [e,c],[a,c] [f,c],[b,g] Ø Backtrack on abstract intervals Talk Mail Boss Slides talk mail boss mail talk mail boss

7
7 [a,b] [b,c][d,a] [e,c][a,c][f,c][b,g][h,a][d,i][d,b][d,j] XXXX XX meets met-by a b d [b,c],[d,a] i j [h,a],[d,i] [d,b],[d,j] Ø h [a,b] finishes starts equals meets contains possibilities instantiations Backtrack on abstract intervals Talk Mail Boss Slides talk mail boss slides boss slides

8
8 [a,b] [b,c][d,a] ab c d [b,c],[d,a] [a,b] [e,c],[a,c] [f,c],[d,c] [g,c],[b,h] e f g h Ø X talk mail talkmail boss slides Forward Checking on abstract intervals [a,b] meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail Boss Slides possibilities instantiations mail Impossible Slides equals Talk Mail meets Slides

9
9 slides Slides Boss Forward Checking on abstract intervals [a,b] [b,c][d,a] ab c d [b,c],[d,a] [a,b] [i,a],[d,j] [d,b],[d,k] [d,c],[d,l] j i l X k [d,j][d,b][d,k][d,c][d,l][i,a] [a,b] X X Ø talk mail boss [a,b] meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail possibilities instantiations

10
10 Outline Instantiate variables with bi-intervals Instantiate variables with abstract intervals Backtrack with abstract intervals Forward checking with abstract intervals Conclusion Backtrack with bi-intervals Forward checking with bi-intervals

11
11 Bi-intervals A bi-interval on a list of points encodes a set of abstract intervals [u,v] where u [A,B] and v [C,D]. Definition : Example : AB CDE The interpretation of the bi-interval into abstract intervals is : Z X Y [A,C], [A,X], [A,D], [A,Y], [A,E] [Z,C], [Z,X], [Z,D], [Z,Y], [Z,E] [B,C], [B,X], [B,D], [B,Y], [B,E] [ ] []

12
12 mailboss Backtrack on bi-intervals talkmail [a,b] [b,c][d,a] ab c d, Ø talk mail meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail Boss Slides possibilities instantiations -- [e,c][a,c][f,c][b,g] XXXX boss ef g

13
13 Backtrack on bi-intervals [a,b] [b,c][d,a] abd, Ø talk mail meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail Boss Slides possibilities instantiations -- slides [h,a][d,i][d,b][d,j] XX [a,b] boss hi j [e,c][a,c][f,c][b,g] XXXX

14
14 talkmail Forward Checking on bi-intervals [a,b] [b,c][d,a] ab c d, Ø X talk mail boss meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail Boss Slides possibilities instantiations Impossible Slides equals Talk Mail meets Slides -- slides

15
15 Forward Checking on bi-intervals [a,b] [b,c][d,a] abd, Ø X talk mail meets met-by equals finishes starts meets contains Talk Mail Boss Slides possibilities instantiations -- slides [e,a][d,f][d,b][d,g] XX [a,b] boss ef g

16
16 Outline Conclusion Instantiate variables with abstract intervals Backtrack with abstract intervals Forward checking with abstract intervals Instantiate variables with bi-intervals Backtrack with bi-intervals Forward checking with bi-intervals

17
17 Conclusion Backtrack on abstract intervalsForward checking on abstract intervals Backtrack on bi-intervals Forward checking on bi-intervals Domains are smaller Future Works: Explore other optimizations techniques and use bi-intervals in a hybrid algorithm

18
18 Thank you for your attention baget@lirmm.fr sebastien.laborie@inrialpes.fr

19
19 Experimental Results

20
20 Refining a bi-interval Algorithm: Refining a bi-interval constrained by the finished-by relation. Data: A bi-interval I= and an abstract interval J=[x,y]. Result: Let R be the refinement of I following J and the finished-by relation. We return FALSE if R is empty or a bi-interval whose interpretation in pointsList is R otherwise. if y (c,d) then return FALSE; if b ≤ x then return FALSE; if a ≥ y then return FALSE; if (a ≤ x and b ≥ y) then return ; if (a ≤ x and b ; if (a > x and b ≥ y) then return ; if (a > x and b ;

Similar presentations

OK

Jeopardy Q 1 Q 6 Q 11 Q 16 Q 21 Q 2 Q 7 Q 12 Q 17 Q 22 Q 3 Q 8 Q 13

Jeopardy Q 1 Q 6 Q 11 Q 16 Q 21 Q 2 Q 7 Q 12 Q 17 Q 22 Q 3 Q 8 Q 13

© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Viewer ppt online student 7 segment led display ppt on ipad Ppt on op amp circuits explained Ppt on bond length and bond Ppt on retail marketing mix Ppt on condition monitoring software Ppt on ram and rom history Ppt on charge-coupled device images Ppt on environmental degradation in india Ppt on regional trade agreements in africa