Presentation on theme: "Rate myData! OR Is peer review broken? If so what needs to be done to fix it?"— Presentation transcript:
Rate myData! OR Is peer review broken? If so what needs to be done to fix it?
Opening up Peer Review
The Nature Open Peer Review Experiment
So why not take into account data??? In fact: why not make data a stand- alone, first-class citizen in the world of research outputs?
Open Access Data Publishing
The cost of NOT doing it properly
Data Availability & Checking
The problem has not gone away!! Also need RAW data, software and process details
Rate my Research?? Reproduce my Research?? ?
Wisdom of the Crowd replacing ‘Closed’ Peer Review?
Some Steps in the Right Direction?!
Rate my Repository Data What types of rating would we need? I downloaded this (usage stats) I examined this and found… (provide review) This helped shape my thinking (citation) This was (re)used as part of another study (citation) Another study was derived from this (citation) How would this be implemented? Social networking approach? Embed in ‘citation system’? Link to conventional publishing