Presentation on theme: "Developing a Function-Means Tree"— Presentation transcript:
1Developing a Function-Means Tree What functions will the design have? By what means will those functions be achieved?Taken from engineering design: a project-based introduction by dym & little
2It helps to go beyond the terminology and to know what you’re really trying to do. Think of the “functions” as what you must do.Think of the “means” as how you might do it.The Function-Means Tree is a tool for listing the primary functions of a design and various means of achieving those functions.The Function-Means Tree should flow out of the Attributes List, PCC, Objectives-Constraints Tree, and Design Specifications.
3Before you start too far down the path of “brainstorming” various design alternatives… Determine the primary functions that are required.Show these on the top level of the treeList various means by which each function may be implemented.Show these on the next level of the treeDetermine secondary functions that would result from implementing each of the means.The tree continues to alternate between means and functions until you reach a reasonable termination point.
4Here is a partial Function-Means Tree for a cigarette lighter. IGNITE LEAFY MATERIALSElectrically Heated WireApply heat to leafy materialsGenerate electric currentWall-outlet-based systemBattery-based systemControl electrical currentConvert chemical energy to electrical currentStore electricityConvert electricity to heatMiniature heat pumpResistive wireProtect users from post-usage burnsFocused SunlightLaserFlameStore fuelControl flameIgnite fuelSparkElectrical resistanceProtect electric current from flameSupply fuel for flameButaneGasolinePrimary functionPossible means of achievingthe primary functionSecondary functionsThis is from an example for a cigarette lighter (found in Dym & Little). Each function is shown in a rectangle, and the means for achieving that function are shown in trapezoids. This is not a complete tree, but it shows that employing a particular means to achieve a function results in secondary functions…and secondary means. There may be quite a bit of “fallout” for particular means. Visualizing the means in this manner may help students see the complexity of various design choices.Secondary meansFunctionTertiary functionsMeans