Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byJasmine Custard Modified over 4 years ago

1
How to do Bayes-Optimal Classification with Massive Datasets: Large-scale Quasar Discovery Alexander Gray Georgia Institute of Technology College of Computing Joint work with Gordon Richards (Princeton), Robert Nichol (Portsmouth ICG), Robert Brunner (UIUC/NCSA), Andrew Moore (CMU)

2
What I do Often the most general and powerful statistical (or “machine learning”) methods are computationally infeasible. I design machine learning methods and fast algorithms to make such statistical methods possible on massive datasets (without sacrificing accuracy).

3
Quasar detection •Science motivation: use quasars to trace the distant/old mass in the universe •Thus we want lots of sky SDSS DR1, 2099 square degrees, to g = 21 •Biggest quasar catalog to date: tens of thousands •Should be ~1.6M z<3 quasars to g=21

4
Classification •Traditional approach: look at 2-d color-color plot (UVX method) –doesn’t use all available information –not particularly accurate (~60% for relatively bright magnitudes) •Statistical approach: Pose as classification. 1.Training: Train a classifier on large set of known stars and quasars (‘training set’) 2.Prediction: The classifier will label an unknown set of objects (‘test set’)

5
Which classifier? 1.Statistical question: Must handle arbitrary nonlinear decision boundaries, noise/overlap 2.Computational question: We have 16,713 quasars from [Schneider et al. 2003] (.08

6
Which classifier? •Popular answers: –logistic regression: fast but linear only –naïve Bayes classifier: fast but quadratic only –decision tree: fast but not the most accurate –support vector machine: accurate but O(N 3 ) –boosting: accurate but requires thousands of classifiers –neural net: reasonable compromise but awkward/human-intensive to train •The good nonparametric methods are also black boxes – hard/impossible to interpret

7
Main points of this talk 1.nonparametric Bayes classifier 2.can be made fast (algorithm design) 3.accurate and tractable science

8
Main points of this talk 1.nonparametric Bayes classifier 2.can be made fast (algorithm design) 3.accurate and tractable science

9
Optimal decision theory Optimal decision boundary Star density Quasar density x density f(x)

10
Bayes’ rule, for Classification

12
So how do you estimate an arbitrary density?

13
Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) for example (Gaussian kernel):

14
Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) • There is a principled way to choose the optimal smoothing parameter h • Guaranteed to converge to the true underlying density (consistency) • Nonparametric – distribution need not be known

15
Nonparametric Bayes Classifier (NBC) [1951] • Nonparametric – distribution can be arbitrary • This is Bayes-optimal, given the right densities • Very clear interpretation • Parameter choices are easy to understand, automatable • There’s a way to enter prior information Main obstacle:

16
Main points of this talk 1.nonparametric Bayes classifier 2.can be made fast (algorithm design) 3.accurate and tractable science

17
kd-trees: most widely-used space- partitioning tree [Bentley 1975], [Friedman, Bentley & Finkel 1977] • Univariate axis-aligned splits • Split on widest dimension • O(N log N) to build, O(N) space

18
A kd-tree: level 1

19
A kd-tree: level 2

20
A kd-tree: level 3

21
A kd-tree: level 4

22
A kd-tree: level 5

23
A kd-tree: level 6

24
For higher dimensions: ball-trees (computational geometry)

25
We have a fast algorithm for Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) •Generalization of N-body algorithms (multipole expansions optional) •Dual kd-tree traversal: O(N) •Works in arbitrary dimension •The fastest method to date [Gray & Moore 2003]

26
We could just use the KDE algorithm for each class. But: •for the Gaussian kernel this is approximate •choosing the smoothing parameter to minimize (cross- validated) classification error is more accurate But we need a fast algorithm for the Nonparametric Bayes Classifier (NBC)

27
Leave-one-out cross-validation Observations: 1.Doing bandwidth selection requires only prediction. 2.To predict class label, we don’t need to compute the full densities. Just which one is higher. We can make a fast exact algorithm for prediction

28
Fast NBC prediction algorithm 1. Build a tree for each class

29
Fast NBC prediction algorithm 2. Obtain bounds on P(C)f(x q |C) for each class P(C 1 )f(x q |C 1 )P(C 2 )f(x q |C 2 ) xqxq

30
Fast NBC prediction algorithm 3. Choose the next node-pair with priority = bound difference P(C 1 )f(x q |C 1 )P(C 2 )f(x q |C 2 ) xqxq

31
Fast NBC prediction algorithm 3. Choose the next node-pair with priority = bound difference P(C 1 )f(x q |C 1 )P(C 2 )f(x q |C 2 ) 50-100x speedup exact

32
Main points of this talk 1.nonparametric Bayes classifier 2.can be made fast (algorithm design) 3.accurate and tractable science

33
Resulting quasar catalog •100,563 UVX quasar candidates •Of 22,737 objects w/ spectra, 97.6% are quasars. We estimate 95.0% efficiency overall. (aka “purity”: good/all) •94.7% completeness w.r.t. g<19.5 UVX quasars from DR1 (good/all true) •Largest mag. range ever: 14.2

34
Cosmic magnification [Scranton et al. 2005] 13.5M galaxies, 195,000 quasars Most accurate measurement of cosmic magnification to date [Nature, April 2005] more flux more area

35
Next steps (in progress) •better accuracy via coordinate-dependent priors •5 magnitudes •use simulated quasars to push to higher redshift •use DR4 higher-quality data •faster bandwidth search •500k quasars easily, then 1M

36
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, more…

37
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, more… fastest algs

38
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, more… fastest alg

39
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, more… fastest alg

40
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, more… fastest alg

41
Bigger picture •nearest neighbor (1-,k-,all-,approx,clsf) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Miller et al. 2003], etc. •n-point correlation functions [Gray & Moore 2000], [Moore et al. 2000], [Scranton et al. 2003], [Gray & Moore 2004], [Nichol et al. 2005 in prep.] •density estimation (nonparametric) [Gray & Moore 2000], [Gray & Moore 2003], [Balogh et al. 2003] •Bayes classification (nonparametric) [Richards et al. 2004], [Gray et al. 2005 PhyStat] •nonparametric regression •clustering: k-means and mixture models, others •support vector machines, maybe fastest alg we’ll see…

42
Take-home messages •Estimating a density? Use kernel density estimation (KDE). •Classification problem? Consider the nonparametric Bayes classifier (NBC). •Want to do these on huge datasets? Talk to us, use our software. •Different computational/statistical problem? Grab me after the talk! agray@cc.gatech.edu

Similar presentations

OK

Alex Szalay, Jim Gray Analyzing Large Data Sets in Astronomy.

Alex Szalay, Jim Gray Analyzing Large Data Sets in Astronomy.

© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

To ensure the functioning of the site, we use **cookies**. We share information about your activities on the site with our partners and Google partners: social networks and companies engaged in advertising and web analytics. For more information, see the Privacy Policy and Google Privacy & Terms.
Your consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.

Ads by Google

Ppt on college website project Ppt on sales order processing Ppt on indian air force Ppt on digital television technology Ppt on earthquake in india Ppt on limits and continuity in calculus Ppt on effect of global warming on weather forecast Ppt on db2 architecture Ppt on sources of energy class 10 Ppt on computer assisted language learning