We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byRobert Ottey
Modified over 2 years ago
Page 1 CPSS-IOSCO Principles for FMIs and TM Assessments Ana Giraldo Guatemala - April 2013
Page 2© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. CPSS – IOSCO Principles Vs Thomas Murrays Risks Key differences Comparison of CPSS-IOSCO, AGC and TM CPSS-IOSCO principles in TM public ratings Agenda
Page 3© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. I. CPSS-IOSCO Principles vs Thomas Murrays Risks
Page 4© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. PrincipleAsset Commitment LiquidityCounter party Asset Servicing FinancialOperatio nal Asset Safety Governance & Transparency General Details Principle 1: Legal Basis Principle 2: Governance Principle 3: Framework for the comprehensive management of risks Principle 4: Credit Risk Principle 5: Collateral Principle 6: Margin Principle 7: Liquidity Risk Principle 8: Settlement Finality Principle 9: Money Settlement Principle 10: Physical Deliveries Principle 11: Central Securities Depositories Principle 12: Exchange-of-value Settlement Systems CPSS-IOSCO vs TM Ratings
Page 5© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. PrincipleAsset Commitment LiquidityCounter party Asset Servicing FinancialOperati onal Asset Safety Governance & Transparency CSD on CSD Principle 13: Participant-default rules and procedures Principle 14: Segregation and Portability Principle 15: General Business Risk Principle 16: Custody and Investment Risk Principle 17: Operational Risk Principle 18: Access and Participation Requirements Principle 19: Tiered Participation Arrangements Principle 20: FMI Links Principle 21: Efficiency and Effectiveness Principle 22: Communication Procedures and Standards Principle 23: Disclosure of rules and Key Procedures Principle 24: Disclosure of Market Data CPSS-IOSCO vs TM Ratings
Page 6© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. II. Key Differences Between Thomas Murrays Assessments and IOSCO Self- Assessments
Page 7© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. Thomas Murray Asset Servicing Risk Continuous Updates Data Validation Adherence to best market practices Transparenc y Separate assessment per type of FMI Key Differences with other Assessments
Page 8 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 8 Private and Confidential Asset Servicing Risk Why Asset Servicing Risk is important? Trend: There is an increasing number of CSDs providing asset servicing and corporate actions- related services to participants. Risk : Asset servicing carries a high degree of risk given that it is a commercial activity. In many cases it can be provided in competition with custodians. It is also the area with the largest potential losses for a CSD. TM weighting: TM gives a high weighting to the overall risk score to asset servicing risk. In fact, it is the heaviest single weighted risk in our methodology. Involvement of CSDs: There is a varied degree of involvement in asset servicing ranging from simple interest payment distribution to complex corporate actions processing. Back
Page 9 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 9 Private and Confidential Asset Servicing Risk Why Asset Servicing Risk is important? Back
Page 10 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 10 Private and Confidential Data Updates Continuous Updates Thomas Murray provides on-going surveillance on changes to the CSDs, CCPs and capital market infrastructures. Thomas Murray receives information directly from local sources such as support banks, CSDs, stock exchanges and regulators. There is also a (at least) monthly monitoring of websites to ensure developments are not missed. Daily newsflashes are sent to clients and other interested parties in respect of changes and developments in the marketplaces. A risk impact is added every time a piece of news has a relevant impact on any of the assessed entities. Assessments are updated and revised upon receipt of information. The ratings are also reviewed and taken to the Ratings Committee if a significant event takes place. There are also annual general updates with the co-operation of the CSDs and the support banks to validate the data. Back
Page 11 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 11 Private and Confidential Permanent Updates Number of Newsflashes Sent by Thomas Murray Back
Page 12 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 12 Private and Confidential Data Validation Validation Thomas Murray information is collected from CSDs but data is validated by some participants that are our support banks. The support banks provide an annual update and review of Thomas Murray assessments. Examples of support banks:
Page 13 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 13 Private and Confidential Best Market Practice Adherence to best market practices Thomas Murrays assessment methodology is based on best market practices rather than minimum standards. Thomas Murray provides a gap analysis that shows the CSD where it stands compared to best market practices. The rating scale is designed in a way that CSDs can determine how far they are from the best market practice in each risk.
Page 14 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 14 Private and Confidential Transparency Transparency of methodology and reports Thomas Murrays assessment methodology is published so CSDs can understand the basis they have been rated. TM methodology is prescriptive and detailed enough for CSDs to determine their strengths and weaknesses in each risk. TM reports are available to all our clients and public rating reports are publicly available. TM reports are also available to the CSDs once they are finalised/updated. Since the reports highlight the strength and weaknesses, CSDs can use them to decide areas to work on and issues to address.
Page 15 Thomas Murray © 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 15 Private and Confidential Separate Assessments Analysis per type of entity Thomas Murray undertakes separate assessments and analysis according to the type of infrastructure entity. Different types of risks apply to different type of infrastructure entity (e.g. CPSS-IOSCO principles for FMIs apply equally to all FMIs although some principles are not applicable to all (e.g Principle 6: Margin, only applies to CCPs). Back
Page 16© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. III. Comparison Between AGC, CPSS- IOSCO and TM on Key Issues
Page 17© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. Thomas Murray AGC CPSS/IOSCO
Page 18© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. IV. CPSS-IOSCO Principles for FMIs in TM Public Ratings
Page 19© 2013 Thomas Murray Ltd. PrincipleCPSS-IOSCOComment on Publicly Rated CSD 4 – Credit RiskAn FMI should effectively measure, monitor, and manage its credit exposures to participants and those arising from its payment, clearing, and settlement processes. An FMI should maintain sufficient financial resources to cover its credit exposure to each participant fully with a high degree of confidence. XXX participants do not have any credit exposure in the case of pre- funded on-exchange trades. For off-exchange settlements, there is full counterparty exposure if the participant chooses to settle on an FOP basis. If settled DVP, there is no risk of principal loss, but some consequential market losses may occur since there are no fails management mechanisms. While XXX doesnt undertake a thorough check on participants, other agencies check that requirements are met. 5 - CollateralAn FMI that requires collateral to manage its or its participants credit exposure should accept collateral with low credit, liquidity, and market risks. An FMI should also set and enforce appropriately conservative haircuts and concentration limits. XXX supports the settlement of repo and reverse repo transactions on the Exchange and accepts the deposit of securities as collateral. 6 - MarginA CCP should cover its credit exposures to its participants for all products through an effective margin system that is risk-based and regularly reviewed. Not applicable as XXX does not act as central counterparty in the market.
Page 20 Thomas Murray © 2012 Thomas Murray Ltd.Page 20 Private and Confidential Thank you! December 2012
The World Bank FMI Principles Relevant issues for CSDs Froukelien Wendt, IMF Miami, 24 September 2012.
The Securities and Exchange Commission as a matter of policy, disclaims responsibility for any private publication or statement of any of its employees.
Enterprise Risk Management October 9, 2007 Marie Rey, Managing Director Risk Management, DTCC.
THOMAS MURRAY RISK RATING REPORTS – STRUCTURE AND CONTENT AND METHODOLOGY CAIRO October 2011.
CPSS-IOSCOs Proposed Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures The World Bank role and experience ACSDA General Assembly Bermuda, 25 March 2011 Froukelien.
The New CPSS-IOSCO Principles for FMIs Fez,26 April, 2012 Ceu Pereira The World Bank.
Principles for financial market infrastructures Mexico’s experience 1 National Banking and Securities Commission Vice Presidency of Securities Supervision.
Legal Task Force Session In ACG15 November 4th, 2011 Seoul, Korea.
Page 1 © 2009 Thomas Murray Ltd. AMEDA Leadership Forum Alexandria, Egypt, 27-29th April CCPs and other Risk Containment Models.
Disclosure Framework -Study of integrative framework- September 2008 Japan Securities Depository Center, Inc.
Asset Safety Risk Fez, Morocco 25 April © 2012 Thomas Murray Ltd. Page 2 PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL Thomas Murray’s definition: ‘The risk that assets.
Page 1 Depository Risk Controls Jim Micklethwaite 21 April 2006.
SUPERVISION FRAMEWORK FOR CLEARING AND SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS: MAIN ELEMENTS AND SOME ISSUES TO INCLUDE IN THE OVERSIGHT OF THE SYSTEMS Global Payments Week.
The Clearing Corporation: Best Practices August 11, 2005.
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE, MINING AND COMMODITIES TRANSPORT TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION PHARMACEUTICALS AND LIFE SCIENCES Break out session:
New EU Rules on Derivatives Trading The EMIR Reporting Technical Standards Victoria Cooley OTC Derivatives & Post Trade Policy Financial Conduct Authority.
OVERSIGHT part II - practical issues Carlo Winder 9th Conference on Payments and Securities Settlement Systems, Ohrid, 5-8 June 2016.
© National Bank of Belgium Exploring Frontiers in Payments Systems Development Washington DC, May 29 - June 1, 2007 Johan PISSENS Head of Oversight Unit.
1 WFC 2015, Mexico Worldwide implementation of the PFMI Froukelien Wendt, Monetary and Capital Markets Department, IMF.
The Importance of National Payments Systems in Reducing Market Risk S.W.I.F.T. Regional Conference in Central and Eastern Europe Prague, Czech Republic:
New EU Rules on Derivatives Trading Introduction to the EMIR technical standards Barry King OTC Derivatives & Post Trade Policy Financial Conduct Authority.
Hannes Van Eeden, Head of Finance and Company Secretary October 9,2007.
AECSD John Woodhouse Director Capital Markets, Thomas Murray The Impact of the Financial Crisis on CSD Risks.
CPSS-IOSCO’S PROPOSED PRINCIPLES FOR FINANCIAL MARKET INFRASTRUCTURES Moderator: Monica Singer, CEO, Strate, South Africa (By video) Jeffrey S. Mooney,
1 CPSS-IOSCO Principles The self-assessment experience ACSDA Senior Summit – Dec/13 INFORMATION CLASSIFICATION (CHECK WITH AN “X”): RESTRICTEDCONFIDENTIALINTERNAL.
Page 1 © 2008 Thomas Murray Ltd. Corporate Actions 8 th AMEDA Meeting South Africa, October 2008.
Working Group #2 - Report Credit & Liquidity Risk.
25 seconds left….. 24 seconds left….. 23 seconds left…..
Jeopardy Topic 1Topic Q 1Q 6Q 11Q 16Q 21 Q 2Q 7Q 12Q 17Q 22 Q 3Q 8Q 13Q 18Q 23 Q 4Q 9Q 14Q 19Q 24 Q 5Q 10Q 15Q 20Q 25 Final Jeopardy.
G-30 Self Assessment CDS “A Case Study” Bruce Butterill Vice-President, Product Management The Canadian Depository for Securities Limited November, 2003.
Integrity Reliability Risk Management Profitable Proudly South African Operational Excellence Learning Organisation Teamwork Global Best Practices Customer.
CPSS-IOSCO Task Force Beyond the November 2001 Report P. Parkinson ACSDA Seminar Lima, Peru November 15, 2002.
Registry system data exchange General design requirements Pre-sessional Consultations on Registries 19 October 2002 New Delhi, India UNFCCC secretariat.
New European Regulations covering Investable Indices Two new sets of European Regulations covering Benchmarks (Indices) where there are investment products.
Compliance with IOSCO requirements AMEDA Leadership Forum Alexandria Egypt Monday 27 th April 2009 by Dr. Ashraf EL Sharkawy Senior Advisor to the CMA.
Credit Support Annex under ISDA framework vis-à-vis Legal and Regulatory Scenario in India.
1.7.3.G1 Depository Institutions Take Charge of Your Finances
JCR-VIS Credit Ratings Commercial Banks JCR-VIS Entity Ratings Bank Finance Ratings JCR-VIS August 11, 2005 RATINGS OF PENSION FUNDS A Presentation by.
Large Value Systems: Applying International Standards World Bank Training Course, in Cooperation with AMF and BMA Bahrain, March 16, 2005 Massimo Cirasino.
©2010 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 13/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Internal Control and Control Risk Chapter 10.
Dubai Financial Market Presentation to AMEDA: I.Role of DFM CSD in Managing Corporate Actions II.DFMs Settlement Model April 2012.
Addition Facts = = =
1 Financial Market Development: Sequencing Of Reforms To Ensure Stability Presented By V. Sundararajan Fi fth Annual Financial Markets And Development.
Chapter 10 Banking and the Management of Financial Institutions.
Superfinanciera, Primera en Transparencia. Cartagena de Indias, March 30 th, 2012 ACSDA’s General Assembly Gerardo Hernández Correa Superintendent of.
1 PART 1 ILLUSTRATION OF DOCUMENTS Brief introduction to the documents contained in the envelope Detailed clarification of the documents content.
1 17 Commercial Bank Operations. 2 Chapter Objectives Describe the most common sources of funds for commercial banks Describe the most common uses of.
International Accounting Standard 33 Earnings per Share.
ACSDA Leadership Forum CDS Financial Risk Model Summary of Key Financial Risk Controls Nauman Mahmood, Managing Financial Risk Director October 9,2007.
© 2016 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.