Presentation on theme: "Presented by Ergin Akalpler"— Presentation transcript:
1 Presented by Ergin Akalpler THE IMPACT OF PRICE SUPPORT SYSTEM ON COMMON AGRICULTURAL POLICY OF THE EUROPEAN UNIONPresented by Ergin Akalpler
2 Crucial Question What is the impact of the price support system of the CAP on free trade? Which support instrument (such as export subsidies import levies etc.) better fits into the CAP to reduce the trade distortion and destabilizing effects on the market with respect to the welfare of consumers and to distribution effect?
3 What is researched:The impact of the price support system of the CAP for cereal products are taken into consideration as sample products in EU-15. The impact of the support measures on cereals are researched.
4 Method:Producer Subsidy Estimate is used to estimate the impact of support measures and Supply demand curve is used to illustrate the effects of support measures in the CAP. Theoretical and empirical researches are considered. Time series and linear regression technique are used for better forecasting.
5 The CAPIn 1968, 11 Years after the foundation of the EU CAP came into effect1987 single European ACT removedTechnical fiscal and Physical barreirs1993 Maastricht agreement:Economic and Politic Union, Monetary Union, EU citizenship,
6 Objectives of the CAP (Article 39) Increasing productivityFair living standards for producers.Market stabilityReasonable price for consumers andMaintenance of employment
7 Principles of the CAP Community preferences Market Unity Financial Solidarity
8 Protection in the CAPStrong Protection %75 external protection with intervention(cereals, butter, milk, beef, some fruit and vegetablesWeak protection %25 external protection without interventionEgg polutry wine, flowers some fruit and vegetables
9 Support measures of the CAP -Tariff Measures-Non tariff measures:Export import subsidies and quotas, Monetary compensatory payment, production quotas, interventions
10 Reforms of the CAP Mansholt Plan in 1968 Replaced 5 million small scale producer with large scale producers1988 Reforms, radical measures:Introduced set aside measures, early retirement of age 55, extensification of production type.
11 1992 Mac Sharry reforms: Direct payments instead of support measures Support prices for cerelas and cattle reduced 15%Beef support prices reduced 29%Set aside reduced 15%
12 1994 Uruguay roundagricultural support would be reduced 20% over a 6 year period.A reduction of 36% in budget spending on export subsidies21% cut in the quantity of subsidized export.
13 Agenda 2000 , A new policy for rural development The integration of the environmentThe involvement of local peopleThe creation of different development programs to assist farm sectors in CEECFurther reduction in prices.
15 The theoretical perspective of International trade Ricardo Smith modelHeckshir Ohlin ModelIntra Industry trade modelStrategic trade Model
16 The Smith Ricardo Model Smith based on Absolute costs- threats labor only factor-countries with lower REAL cost of production has advantage on trade.Ricardo based on Comparative cost-countries with lower RELATIVE costs has the advantage on trade
17 Ricardo based his theory on a number of assumptions -two nations and- two commodities- free trade,- perfect mobility of labour within each nation, but immobility between the two nations,- constant cost of production,- no transportation cost,- the labour theory of value
18 Amount of trade between US and UK US UK_____________________________Wheat (bushels / man-hour)Cloth (yards / man- hour)
19 Price of trade between US and UK US UK_______________________________________Price of 1 bushels of Wheat $ $2.00Price of 1 yard of cloth________________________________________
20 The H- O-Samuelson model HO focus on international differences in factor endowment.Comparative advantages is explained by the abundance of factors-countries with abundance factors will export, with scarce will import.Inter industry trade depend on different type of products trade
21 Intra Industry TradeIIT entails lower income of factor and market adjustment than Inter ind. Trade.Horizontal IIT- vertical IITIIT beneficial it increase competition,Firms grow rapidlyIIT similar product trade create preasure on price reduction
22 Strategic tradeIn imperfectly competitive market trade policy promote firms with unilateral protection such as:Indirect export promotionExport subsidies to deter competitors entering market.
23 Ex: aircraft ind. in political interest BoingProduce Dont Prod.______________________________Airbus Prod , , 0Dont Prod , , 0________________________________
24 Effects of subsidies Boing Produce Dont Prod. ______________________________Airbus Prod , , 0Dont Prod , , 0________________________________
25 PSS and Cobweb theoremSimplest model to illustrate the danger of price fluctuation in econ.Demand decreasing function of current priceSupply increasing function of last year(Time leg behind)
28 Methodology of PSE in the CAP PSE = Q (Pp –Pr.X) + D + IWhere;Q = quantity producedPp = producer price in domestic currency units.Pr = world price in world currency unitX = exchange conversion factorD = Direct government paymentsI = Indirect transfers through policies
29 Estimation of MPS for PSE MPS = (Pp-Pr). QThe unit PSE is the total PSE per tonne or unit of production.Unit PSE= PSE/ QPercentage PSE= PSE/ Q.Pp +D
48 Impact of Support Measures Positive effects;· Subsidy protect producers and rural welfare,· Support insufficient producers to maintain their production,· Subvention redistributes income from domestic consumer who pays a higher price to domestic producers of the commodity (who receives the higher price)· Price support or intervention price, prevent the fluctuation in the market,
49 · Increase competition change of domestic producers, · Subsidies is a trade creation between member countries,· Subsidies contribute indirectly imported product amount where there is a less output,· Increase producer surplus,· Subsidy is more preferable than tariff, subsidy is a direct form of aid· Increase export of commodity,
50 Negative effects,· Subsidy cause an over-production,· Because of subvention some efficient production of exportable commodity in the third country replaced by the insufficient production in the EU,· Subsidy is a trade distortion for non-member countries, and reduce the welfare of the world economics,· Subsidies cause an unfair competition and it is inconsistent with the comparative advantages theory,
51 · Subsidies reduce the welfare of the consumer if there is an over-production, · It is difficult to estimate which producer get subvention, and once it is given it is difficult to remove, (protective tariffs may have the same effect)· Reduce consumer surplus or cost,· Increase product price,· Subsidies cause a producer and consumer cost or deadweight,· Reduce competition of third country producers,Subsidy is used for political purposes, such as work place guarantee