Presentation on theme: "CCFellows2-13-06 Diet, Exercise, and Cancer Risk Diane Baer Wilson, EdD, MS, RD Associate Professor Division of Quality Healthcare Department of Internal."— Presentation transcript:
CCFellows Diet, Exercise, and Cancer Risk Diane Baer Wilson, EdD, MS, RD Associate Professor Division of Quality Healthcare Department of Internal Medicine Co-Director Cancer Prevention and Control Massey Cancer Center Virginia Commonwealth University
Todays objectives Examine dietary-related factors and physical activity related to cancer risk Discuss dietary fat as a model for dietary studies related to cancer risk Review nutrition measurement methods Examine recent research related to BMI and breast cancer
Genes load the gun. Lifestyle pulls the trigger. Elliott Joslyn, MD
Cancer risk factors Age Family history Hormone exposure …… …… …… Tobacco use Diet/exercise Environmental exposures Alcohol Intake
Cancer Risk Factors: Nutrition Top Issues: Energy Balance Weight Exercise Nutrient Composition Dietary Fat Fruit/Vegetables Fiber Soy
Understanding dietary fat/cancer hypotheses Nutrition relatively recent area of cancer research Research seeds: Correlational Animal research Cross sectional RCT
Fat intake/breast cancer, Carroll, 1975.
Dietary Fat/Breast Cancer Animal studies Proportionate level of tumor growth recorded in laboratory rats related to level of dietary fat fed animals over designated period of time. ( s)
Dietary Fat/Breast Cancer Human studies Cross sectional Nurses Health Study-Willett, et al, 2000.
Dietary Fat/Breast Cancer Randomized Clinical Trial Low-fat Dietary Patterns and Risk of Invasive Breast Cancer The Womens Health Initiative Randomized Controlled Dietary Modification Trial Prentice, Caan, Chlewbowski, et al. JAMA 2006;295: (2/8/06)
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Participant Flow in the Dietary Modification Component of the Women's Health Initiative
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Baseline Demographics of Participants in Women's Health Initiative Dietary Modification Trial*
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Nutrient Consumption Estimates and Body Weight at Baseline and Year 1
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Blood Biomarkers for Baseline and Year 3*
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Risk of Invasive Breast Cancer and Other Major Clinical Outcomes
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Breast Cancer Risk by Baseline Dietary Factors
Copyright restrictions may apply. Prentice, R. L. et al. JAMA 2006;295: Breast Cancer Risk Based on Baseline Demographics, Medical History, and Health Behavior Variables
The American view of nutrition information
Dietary Assessment Twenty-four hour dietary recall Food frequency questionnaire Diet record Diet history
Data Collection Methods 24 hour recall method Most common method used for national dietary surveys Information on everything consumed over past 24 hours-relies on memory Trained interviewers non-judgmental neutral
Food Record Method Detailed record of all foods consumed on one or more days at time consumed Less dependent on memory Face to face training on completeness and accuracy essential Accurate portion reporting essential Final record reviewed by professional
Food frequency questionnaires Food frequency surveys most common measurement method in nutrition epi research Average intake, usual intake Easy to complete Foods, clarity, format important
Approaches for Evaluating Dietary Questionnaires Compare mean of nutrient intake Proportion of intake accounted for Reproducibility Validity Compare to biochemical indicator Compare to physiologic indicator Ability to predict disease
Food Recalls/Records Foods Recalls and Records Based on specific foods consumed Attempt to get data on ones true intake, open-ended Can be representative if enough days tested Best method for comparing intake to recommendations Most used to validate FFQ
Designing and Administering Questionnaires Motivated subjects Clear instructions Correct foods Standardized procedures Interview or telephone Portion sizes?
Determining best method Individual intake or group mean? Actual intake or relative ranking? Open-ended method or structured list? Age limitations? Literacy considerations?
Overweight and breast cancer Women who are overweight are more likely to: Develop breast cancer Be diagnosed at a later stage Have higher mortality rates
Overweight and Breast Cancer Review of 26 studies examining the association of pre-morbid weight or weight at diagnosis with recurrent disease or survival ( Rock and Wahnefried, 2002) 17 found increased BMI significantly associated with increased risk of death 2 null findings 7 inverse findings
Overweight and Breast Cancer Weight gain and increased risk Obesity increases peptide hormones-insulin and steroid hormones-estrogen Heaviest women have 3x level of estrogen than lean women without HRT Obesity increases risk of death from breast cancer about as much as mammography reduces it.
Breast Cancer Survivorship With early diagnosis, the survival rate has significantly increased 22% of all cancer survivors are breast cancer survivors Breast cancer survivors comprise the largest proportion of cancer survivors
Weight Gain Weight gain 60% of women report weight gain after diagnosis more prevalent: premenopausal at diagnosis received adjuvant chemotherapy in African Americans caloric intake
Reasons for weight gain: Likely to be at least peri menopausal Being told to keep your strength up during therapy Comfort foods Less exercise Needs more research….
Exercise Type of exercise Walking vs. more rigorous forms Breast cancer Multi beneficial Mental, physical, emotional Integration
Addressing weight gain in African American breast cancer survivors African American women have higher mortality from breast cancer when compared to Caucasian women Some 60% of all women report gaining weight after being diagnosed with breast cancer. However, African American women are especially at risk for this weight gain, after diagnosis of breast cancer, placing them at greater risk for cancer recurrence and shorter survival time.
Testing an exercise intervention in African American breast cancer survivors ( Study 1) Study Aim: Determine the feasibility and impact of a cognitive, behavioral theory-based walking intervention, Walking Counts! in a sample of AA breast cancer survivors. Feasibility: Attendance, compliance, process measures Outcomes: Integration of regular exercise (steps/day) change in BMI, waist, hip, forearm circumferences, body fat %, blood pressure, attitude toward exercise and cancer stress.
Walking Counts!-Methods Eligibility: Breast cancer diagnosis >3 months past cancer treatment Mobile <70 years old Description of the intervention: Health Belief Model Eight week community-based, 75 minute sessions Benefits, barriers, relationship to cancer risk, Personal assessment/problem solving Pedometers, scheduling, and tracking of steps/day Wilson et al; Preventing Chronic Disease 2005
Walking Counts!-Results Feasibility Attendance-70% attended > 7 sessions Retention: 92% retained 1 dropped after enrollment due to scheduling 1 recurred Pedometers Steps only mode 25% needed replacement
Walking Counts!-Results Characteristics of the Sample (n=22) Age (yrs) 55 (39 – 66) Weight (lbs)191 (142 – 271) BMI (kg/m 2 ) 32.7 (25.2 – 47.2) Education: (%) < high school High school graduate Post high school Marital Status: (%) Married Single/Divorced/Widowed 50
Characteristics of the Sample Menopausal Status (%) Pre Post Time Since Diagnosis: (%) 1-6 years 7-10 years More than 10 years Type of Treatment: (%) Chemotherapy Radiation therapy Both Neither Tamoxifen: (%) Yes No Alcohol: (%) Yes No Smoking: (%) Yes No
Walking Counts! Pre/Post Measures Baseline (N=22)Changep value* Anthropometric measures: Steps/day <0.001 BMI (kg/m2) Weight (lb.) Body Fat (%) Waist circumference (in.) Hip circumference (in.) Arm circumference (in.) Systolic B/P (mm Hg) Diastolic B/P(mm Hg) Waist to Hip ratio Attitudinal measures: Exercise Attitude Total Cancer Stress Total * Paired t-test for difference in group means.
Steps/day at Baseline, Post and 3 Month Post Intervention p<.001 B/P***, p=.001*** B/3mth
Other research addressing obesity Nutrigenomics: Studies to help understand the mechanism by which genes may influence chronic disease risk related to nutrients and obesity
Genes and obesity in breast cancer Study Aim: Measure breast cancer gene expression profiles and analyze differences in tumor gene expression according to ethnicity in lean (BMI 30) women Methods: Using tissue samples taken at diagnosis of breast cancer, we will study microarray expression of selected genes in 100 AA and 100 Caucasian women. Co-variates, include menopausal status, serum markers for insulin resistance and obesity, dietary intake and level of physical activity Implications: Study results may help to identify molecular changes and or genetic pathways in lean vs overweight women that contribute to breast cancer outcomes. (OConnell P, Penberthy L, Wilson DB, Dumur K)
Other dietary trials: Womens Intervention Nutrition Study (WINS) Tests effect of low-fat intervention on recurrence in 2500 breast cancer survivors Womens Healthy Eating and Living intervention 3,109 survivors tests increased fr/veg intake, low fat, high fiber on progression of disease
Other nutrition areas of interest:
Soy Dual roles-low vs high levels Food sources only Soy protein 25 g/day Isoflavones-genistein Avoid supplements
Omega-3 fatty acids Slow growth of tumors in animals May increase efficacy of chemopreventive agents Cold water fish- Variable even within fish types Flax seed Canola oil
Supplements Cancer patients start consuming more supplements and herbal products after diagnosis Health claims on labels are not all official terms Watch the research-many products are in trials
What to eat? Emphasize plant based foods Eat 5-10 servings of fruits/vegetables chemopreventive constituents fiber antioxidants Eat less red-meat Pay attention to type of fat Dont eliminate fat Eat more fish
Summary Nutrient driven hypotheses have significant measurement threats to validity Providing the public with sound nutritional guidelines requires a thorough examination of the evidence The evidence for the role of obesity and that for the role of exercise are among the strongest for providing advice to the public Much more scientific research is needed to better understand the role of macro and micro nutrients related to specific cancer risk.
Nutrition is one of the most significant determinants of health and one of the most modifiable. The US Surgeon General