Presentation on theme: "Texas State Performance Appraisal System"— Presentation transcript:
1 Texas State Performance Appraisal System Putting the Pieces Together
2 These quotes were reportedly taken from actual federal employee performance evaluations: "Since my last report, this employee has reached rock bottom and has started to dig.""His men would follow him anywhere, but only out of morbid curiosity.""This employee is really not as much a has-been, but more a definite won't be.""Works well when under constant supervision and cornered like a rat in a trap.""When she opens her mouth, it seems that it is only to change feet.""He would be out of his depth in a parking lot puddle.""This young lady has delusions of adequacy. ""Takes him 1½ hours to watch 60 minutes."
3 Goals of the Training Review the Performance Appraisal UPPS Explain performance expectations, standards, weights, ratings and scoresDiscuss how to conduct effective appraisal conferencesUpdate you on policy changesExplain how to complete formsExplain the appeals processAnswer your questions!
4 How is performance appraisal done at Texas State? Guidelines for performance appraisal are set forth in UPPS , Staff Performance Appraisal. This UPPS establishes a system for the appraisal, development and documentation of regular staff performance.
5 Goals of Performance Appraisal To provide the opportunity for the supervisor and employee to assess the employee’s past performance.To help assess that the quality and quantity of work performed by Texas State staff members best meets the University needs.To allow for continuous communication between supervisor and employee about job performance.To offer the supervisor and employee the opportunity to develop a set of expectations for future performance.To provide for future development of the employee.To provide supporting documentation for pay decisions, promotions, transfers, grievances, complaints, disciplinary actions and terminations.
6 At a minimum the performance measurement system should provide: A clear sense of direction.An opportunity for employees to participate in setting the goals and standards for performance.Prompt, honest, and meaningful feedbackImmediate and sincere reinforcement.Coaching and suggestions for improving future performance.Fair and respectful treatmentAn opportunity for employees to understand and influence decisions with affect them.
7 History of the Performance Appraisal System 1996: Review of old performance appraisal system. Staff Council endorsed and the President’s Cabinet approved new GOJA.Fall 1997: Initial training for new GOJA.1998: New system implemented.TCHR audit results implemented
8 Advantages of Appraisal System Defines job dutiesIdentifies work products that result from job dutiesDescribes knowledge, skills and abilities (KSAs) needed to perform jobIdentifies the value of each dutyJob duties relate to performance expectations
9 Appraisal CycleBy March 15 of each year, supervisors develop and give each employee a performance plan covering the remainder of the calendar yearIn January and February of the following year each employee’s accomplishment of the performance plan expectations is appraisedThe cycle repeats annually
11 DefinitionsGOJA Booklet - An individualized listing of duties, KSA’s, and other requirements for a positionPerformance Appraisal - a continuous process in which a supervisor assesses an employee’s achievement of previously established performance expectationsPerformance Expectation - a statement on a duty from the GOJA booklet which summarizes a significant portion of the job.Performance Standard - how we know a goal or duty has been accomplished in an acceptable manner. There are four kinds (quality, time, quantity, and resource), and we will review them in a short while.
12 In this session we’ll discuss a fictitious employee named Vicki Anderson. Vicki is a Human Resources Assistant, and we’ll use section 5 of her GOJA to develop her Performance Appraisal Form.Vicki’s supervisor has reviewed her GOJA, and there have been no substantive changes in it. So, the supervisor selects duties to be evaluated.For example...
13 Performance Performance Expectations Standard WT Rating Score This Expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.- Expectations come from Section 5 of the GOJA.- Watch out for double jeopardy! Avoid redundancy.
14 The next step is setting standards. There are four kinds of standards: Quality Standard(How well the expectation is done)Time Standard(When is the expectation is done)Quantity Standard(How much the expectation is done)Resources Standard(Either establishes a limit or specifies resources that are not fully under the employee’s controlNote: The ‘standard’ cannot be ‘perfection,’ but it must meet the business needs of the University. Standards are written at the ‘meets performance standard’ level, which earns a 3 rating.
15 Performance Performance Expectation Standard Wt. Rating Score This expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.Questions are answered in a courteous, accurate, efficient manner with no more than 5-10 valid complaints per calendar year.Worked hours do not exceed budget and time restraints, not exceeding 2-4 valid errors per semester.
16 Valid: well grounded in principles or evidence; logically correct; sound. You must be able to explain that the performance standards are valid. Lack of understanding of this concept will create problems when the performance appraisal meeting is conducted.
17 Performance Performance Expectation Standard Wt. Rating Score This expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.Questions are answered in a courteous, accurate, efficient manner with no more than 5-10 valid complaints per calendar year.Worked hours do not exceed budget and time restraints, not exceeding 2-4 valid errors per semester.
18 Hints for Setting Standards You must have at least one quality standard.It’s usually easier on you the supervisor to track standards by exception. For example:Instead of - “Word processes documents correctly % of the time”Say - “Word processes documents correctly with no more than valid errors during the appraisal period”Express standards as a range, not as a single number.Have no more than 3 standards per expectation.
19 Performance Performance Expectation Standard Wt. Rating Score This expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.Questions are answered in a courteous, accurate, efficient manner with no more than 5-10 valid complaints per calendar year.Worked hours do not exceed budget and time restraints, not exceeding 2-4 valid errors per semester.10
20 Setting WeightsUse GOJA information to establish weights.Weights must add up to 100.If you want the expectations to be of equal weight, divide the number of expectations into 100 and put the result in the weight column.You may work with your employees to set weights and standards.Give each employee a copy of the standards, expectations, and weights for his or her position. This is their Performance Plan for the year.
21 Performance Plan What: Part I of Performance Appraisal Form expectations, standards and weights onlyWhen: Given to each employee annually by March 15Also given within 30 calendars days after any new hire, reclassification, transfer, or demotion.Requirements: Supervisor and employee must initial and date the plan. Each retains a copy.Changes: The supervisor may change plan at any time. Both initial and date the revised plan. Each retains a copy. (Do not send copies to Human Resources.)
22 Performance Performance Expectation Standard Wt. Rating Score This expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.Questions are answered in a courteous, accurate, efficient manner with no more than 5-10 valid complaints per calendar year.Worked hours do not exceed budget and time restraints, not exceeding 2-4 valid errors per semester.103
23 Reminders About Ratings Be Consistent. Performance that rates a 4 or a 2 for one employee should be the same for everyone performing the .The impact of a major error can affect the rating. Document if the rating is not obvious.Don’t rate an employee down for a problem that is out of the employee’s control.If an employee is rated a 1 or a 2 on any of the items in Part I, documentation of these ratings MUST appear on item 2 of Part II, which we will go over a little later.
24 TCHR Audit Changes Related to Ratings Documentation in Section II needed for any rating above or below a “3”- “meets standards.”New criteria added: “Employee complies with policies, procedures, and work related rules and demonstrates appropriate work related behavior.” Yes / No
25 Other Policy Changes Changes made through regular UPPS review process: Proportionate scoring for employees who transfer during the appraisal period or who are simultaneously supervised by more than one supervisor.
26 GOJA CertificationGOJAs must be signed and dated as accurate prior to evaluationPIF- If used, must designate a date for review of performanceProfessional Development plan for staff
29 Common Errors in the Appraisal Process Halo Error - Giving favorable ratings to all job duties based on impressive performance in just one job function. Horn Error - The opposite of halo error. Downgrading an employee. First impression error - Developing a negative or positive opinion of an employee early in the review period and allowing that to negatively or positively influence all later perceptions of performance Recency Error - The opposite of first impression error. Allowing performance, either good or bad, at the end of the review period to play too large a role in determining an employees rating for the entire period. Leniency Error - Consistently rating someone higher than deserved.Severity Error - The opposite of leniency error. Rating someone consistently lower than is deserved. Central tendency error - Avoiding extremes in ratings across employees. Clone Error - Giving better rating to individuals who are like the rater in behavior and/or personality. Spillover error - Continuing to downgrade an employee for performance errors in prior rating periods
30 Errors in the rating process Raters should only notice performance related factors when observing an employees behavior. Unless the behavior affects performance it should not influence performance ratings.Errors in Observation (Attention)Raters can be influenced by general appearance.Workers who start out high in performance and then get worse are rated lower than workers who are consistently low.Errors in Storage and RecallCategorizing the ratee with a trait.Memory DecayKeep a diary or record information about employee performance as it occursErrors in the Actual EvaluationAppraisals serving as a political messageSending a signal to an employee that - “you’re not wanted”Supervisors tend to weight negative attributes more heavily than positive
32 Performance Performance Expectation Standard Wt. Rating Score This expectation is met when:5. Answer employment,employee relation,compensation,classification, and relatedpolicy/procedure questions.6. Monitor budgetallocations.Questions are answered in a courteous, accurate, efficient manner with no more than 5-10 valid complaints per calendar year.Worked hours do not exceed budget and time restraints, not exceeding 2-4 valid errors per semester.10330
33 More on ScoringAfter scoring each of the expectations, add the scores for all of them and enter the total in the last box of the table on Part I.If the overall score is below 300, then you must complete a Performance Improvement Form.
35 “Speaking of scores, where does MERIT fit into all of this?”A score of 300 means an employee isminimally eligible for a merit raise. Butit is up to you and your chain of commandto decide how to use the score.If you use the score to help decide merit,document what factors besides the appraisal score were considered and why merit decisions were made. This is especially true if you have an employee with a score of 425 who did not get a merit and an employee with a score of 350 who did!
37 “What about a new duty or project that is assigned during the year?” Create a generic expectation for “special projects.”Consider the “other duty” to be one of the already existing expectations. Adjust the weights, if necessary, to recognize the increased importance of this expectation.Create a specific expectation for this special project and adjust the weights of the other expectations.Per the UPPS, tell the employee about any changes when they occur. Don’t wait until the appraisal interview.
39 “Besides reviewing their written work, how else can I measure whether my employees are meetingexpectations?”You might use these:- valid compliments and complaints from customers,- customer satisfaction surveys, and- your own observations.Whatever measures you use, the employee needs to clearly understand what your standards are at the beginning of the evaluation period.
40 “I have an employee with an attitude problem.”How do I reflect that ontheir appraisal?”How do you know that your employee has an attitude problem? Probably because of certain behaviors: rudeness to co-workers or customers or not performing duties in a timely manner.Rate the employee based on those behaviors. Not only is this more objective, but is it far more descriptive than saying the employee has an attitude problem. And it allows the employee to know specifically what he or she needs to know to improve.
41 “Do all employees have to be appraised in January and February?”No. Employees who are promoted, transferred, reclassified, demoted, or hired between October 1 and December 31 should be appraised after six months on the job and again after the nextDecember 31.
42 Alternate Appraisal Cycle Based on the needs of the University, the annual appraisal cycle may be tied to:activities or events which do not coincide with the calendar year, oremployee anniversary datesCan be for one employee or a groupVice Presidents must establish by memo to the affected employee(s)Copies go to supervisor, department head, and Human ResourcesAppraisal events are tied to the end of the cycle:Interviews: during the 2 months following cyclePerformance plan to employee: no later than 2 1/2 months after end of cycleSigned forms to VP: no later than 3 months following cycleSigned forms to Human Resources: no later than 3 1/2 months following cycle
43 Appraisal CycleRemember the normal appraisal:By March 15 of each year, supervisors develop and give each employee a performance plan covering the remainder of the calendar year.In January and February of the following year each employee’s accomplishment of the performance plan expectations is appraised.The cycle repeats annuallyIf you work in an area that uses an alternate appraisal cycle, it might be helpful to develop this type of time line for tracking due dates.
44 “Do all employees have to be appraised using this appraisal system?” No. A supervisor may use analternate appraisal system if it:Achieves the goals established in section andIs approved by the President.
45 Completing Part IIPart II of the Performance Appraisal Form should reflect a summary of the employee’s strengths and opportunities for improvement. Discussion of these points may take place during the regular appraisal interview or within ten days of the interview.Part II must be completed if:there were any expectations rated other than a “3”; orthe employee did not comply with any applicable policies, procedures, rules, or guidelines.
46 Performance Appraisal Comments (And What They Really Mean!) Great presentation skillsTakes 2 hours to cover a 15-minute topicGood communication skillsSpends lots of time on phoneExceptionally well qualifiedMade no major blunders yetWork is first priorityToo ugly to get a date
47 Interview Tips Meet in a private place with the employee. Provide a non-threatening environment.Give the employee concrete examples of work behavior that contributed to the rating.LISTEN!!Discuss problems hampering performance and work together on solutions.Be supportive - you’ve invested a lot in him or her.Set specific, not general, goals to be achieved
48 Performance Appraisal Interview Steps Set the Subordinate at ease:Let the individual know the interview will be a two way process. Neither party should dominate the discussionGive a general, overall impression of the evaluationDiscuss each dimension separatelyGet employees impression of themselves first.Explain yourself and your positionIf there is any problems, try together to determine the causeThis will help point out action plans to resolve those problemsTogether setup action places to correct any problemsBe specific about the who, what, and whenBe sure to provide some kind of of follow-up or report backClose the interview on an optimistic note.
49 Preparation for the Performance Interview Keep a weekly log of individual’s performance.Reduces chances of rating errorsMakes writing up an evaluation simplerGive support and back to the ratingPreparation should not begin a week or two before interview takes place.There should always be feedback to the employee so improvements can be made sooner.Allow sufficient time to write the evaluation.Time to review and possibly reviseHave employees fill out appraisal form before interview takes place.Prepares employees for what will take placeSetup an agreed upon time for the interview time convenient for both parties.Be Prepared!Know what you are going to sayDecide some developmental opportunities before the interviewArrange the room in a way that it will encourage discussion.No barriers between yourself and the employees (EX: Large desk)No phone calls or interruptions during interview.
50 Communication Suggestions Do not control the interviewMake it two waysAsk open-ended questions rather than submitting your own solutionsStress behaviors and results rather than personal traitsSay “I noticed that your weekly report has been one or two days late this last six weeks,” rather than, “You tend to be a tardy, lazy person.”Show interest and concernAllow the subordinate to finish a sentence or thought.This includes being receptive to the subordinate’s own ideas and suggestions.
51 “How can I avoid upsetting my employees with the appraisal process?” Treat them consistently.Keep good documentation.Address performance problems when they occur. Don’t wait until the interview to inform them. No surprises!Be supportive. Remain objective. Don’t play favorites.Be prepared for the interview.
53 “What happens after the interview?” After Part I and Part II are complete, the supervisor, employee, and department director sign the form.Within five working days, the employee is given a final copy of the signed form.The original is kept in the employee’s department personnel file, and a copy is forwarded to Human Resources via the Vice President’s office by April 15.
54 Performance Expectations-NEW To Second-Line Supervisors and Administrative Officers:If you supervise supervisors, you must evaluate them on three special Performance Expectations. One additional Expectation is applied to administrative officers. For other employees, these do not apply.Performance Expectations-NEW*1. Leadership: (NEW Definition)Assigns specific responsibilities, recognizes assigned employees’ abilities, capacities, and limitations. Provides advice and help in achievement of assigned employees’ goals.*2. Employee Development: (NEW Definition)Provides encouragement and opportunities for staff to participate in development experiences.*3. Employee Appraisal:Appraises assigned employees in a timely and thoughtful manner.**4. Employee Recruitment:Progress toward achieving increased numbers of women and ethnic minorities in the workforce.
55 AppealsAn employee may appeal an appraisal within 10 working days to the department director. If the employee’s supervisor is the department director, then the appeal goes one level above the director.The employee writes a confidential memo to accomplish the appeal. A copy of the appraisal must be attached. Decisions on appeals must be rendered within five working days. The decision is final.Copies of all Performance Appraisal forms and applicable attachments go to Human Resources for inclusion in the employee’s personnel file.
56 Other Forms The Post-Performance Appraisal Form An optional form to get feedback from the employee about the process.The Performance Improvement Form and Follow-Up to Performance Improvement FormThese forms are completed when performance falls below an overall rating of Be sure and call Human Resources to discuss possible disciplinary actions appropriate to the type of performance problem your employee may be having.The Performance Commendation FormThis form can be used when an employee’s performance has gone ‘above and beyond’ expectations.
58 Reminder: UPPS Changes-TCHR Audit Documentation in Section II required for any rating above or below a “3- meets standards.”New criteria added: “Employee complies with policies, procedures and work rules and demonstrates appropriate work related behavior.” Yes/No- Section II
59 Other UPPS ChangesProportionate scoring for employees who transfer during the appraisal period.Proportionate scoring for employees who are simultaneously supervised by more than one supervisor.New forms to be added to website.
60 How To Contact UsLocation: J. C. Kellam Building, Suite 340Telephone:Office (512)Fax (512)Web:
61 Texas State Performance Appraisal System Putting the Pieces Together