2Planck Visualization Project Education and Public Outreach Group, Planck Mission, NASA:University of California, Santa Barbara:Department of PhysicsJatila van der Veen (formerly at Purdue-Cal.)Philip LubinUCSB AlloSphereJoAnn Kuchera-Morin, AlloSphere DirectorLead Application Developers:Wesley Smith and Basak Alper,Ph.D. candidates in Media Arts TechnologyMatt Wright, Media Systems EngineerPurdue University:Purdue-Calumet, VisLabLead Application Developers:Jerry Dekker, Lead ProgrammerJohn “Jack” Moreland,Visualization SpecialistHaverford CollegeBruce Partridge, Friend of the ProjectLead P.I., Planck Visualization Project: Jatila van der VeenPlanck Project Scientist and Lead Principal Investigator at NASA/JPL:Charles R. LawrencePlanck Launch: May 14, 2009photo: Charles R. Lawrence2
3Organization of this presentation: 1. About the Planck Mission and CMB Research2. Planck in Virtual Reality3. Understanding the CMB through Music
4Planck is a Mission led by the European Space Agency, with significant participation by NASA. Planck’s purpose is to map the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation (or CMB)- the oldest light we can detect - with a sensitivity of a few millionths of a degree Kelvin, and an angular resolution as fine as 5 arc minutes on the sky.This is equivalent to being able to detect the heat of a rabbit on the Moon from the distance of the Earth, and resolve a bacterium on top of a bowling ball!4
5The CMB is all around us, bathing the Earth, filling all of the visible Universe! 55
6The CMB originated at the time when the universe first became cool enough so as to be transparent to electromagnetic radiation, approximately 380,000 years after the Big Bang. The CMB is like a wall of fog that we can’t see behind...oldest lightyoungest66
7A condensed slice through spacetime: transparentopaqueCMB wallImage credit:
8Although the early universe was bright and hot, the CMB signal is observed today as microwaves, invisible to human eyes, due to the stretching of space over the past 14 billion years.CMBImage credit:8
9To a first order, the CMB is uniform, and follows a perfect black body thermal radiation curve which peaks at Kelvin. This temperature corresponds to a wavelength of light of 2 mm, or microwave radiation.An observed temperature difference across the sky of a few parts in 1,000 is not part of the CMB, but an artifact of our motion through the cosmos. Because of our net motion through space, the sky temperature appears slightly warmer in the direction in which we are moving, and slightly cooler in the direction from which we are coming.warmercooler99
10In 1992 the COBE satellite revealed small variations in the CMB for the first time, all across the sky, which are independent of the motion of the Earth through space. COBE’s instruments were sensitive to few parts in 100,000 in temperature, and had a spatial resolution of 70 of arc on the sky.Called anisotropies, meaning deviations from uniformity, these small temperature variations that we observe in the CMB today are the light echoes of variations in the distribution of matter and energy in the early universe, which acted as ‘seeds’ for galaxies to form later on, by gravitational attraction.COBE all-sky mapThe CMB anisotropies give us a picture of the Last Scattering Surface of the expanding universe, seen at one moment in time – when matter and radiation first separated. Observing the CMB anisotropies with a sensitivity of a few parts in 100,000 is like measuring centimeter-height ripples on the surface of the ocean as seen from an airplane, a few kilometers above the ground.1010
11For reference, 10 of arc on the sky is approximately equal to the width of your pinky, held at arm’s length.A patch of 5 arc minutes on a side is approximately 6 billionths of the total area of the sky.1111
12Since the 1980’s, numerous balloon-borne and ground-based experiments have mapped portions of the sky at increasingly fine resolution, but only two previous satellites, COBE and WMAP, have successfully mapped the entire sky. This figure compares the resolution with which COBE and WMAP have been able to map the CMB, with that expected from Planck.19892000May 14, 200912
13How will Planck complete its mission of mapping the CMB at such fine resolution?Primary mirror,1.9 x 1.5 metersSecondarymirror1.1 x 1.0 meterThe Planck spacecraft is 4.2 m high and has a maximum diameter of 4.2 m, with a launch mass of around 1.8 tons. The spacecraft comprises a service module, which houses systems for power generation and conditioning, attitude control, data handling and communications, together with the warm parts of the scientific instruments, and a payload module. The payload module consists of the telescope, the optical bench, with the parts of the instruments that need to be cooled - the sensitive detector units - and the cooling systems.1313
14Planck was built by an international industrial team Planck was built by an international industrial team. Different components, including the mirrors, instruments, payload package, and cooling systems were built in France, Austria, Germany, Denmark, Finland, Belgium, Italy, Ireland, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States.1414
15Planck will measure the temperature of the sky across 9 frequency channels.HFI (High frequency Instrument): an array of microscopic temperature sensors called spider web bolometers, cooled to 0.1 KLFI (Low frequency Instrument): an array of radio receivers using high electron mobility transistor mixers, cooled to 20 K.HFI feed hornarrayLFI feed horn array1515
16Peak frequency response for each detector, compared with the sky signals LFIHFI304470100143217353545857
17Expected maps of the sky at each frequency: 1717
18and resolve questions in fundamental physics. What do we expect to learn from the data?From the accurate temperature maps, we will be able to calculate the Power Spectrum of the anisotropies of the CMB extremely accurately. From a careful analysis of this power spectrum, we expect to derive important characteristic properties of the Universe,and resolve questions in fundamental physics.mappower spectrumfundamentalphysics1818
19more on this subject later... What techniques do we use to extract information from these data sets?Planck is measuring the microKelvin fluctuations in temperaturewhich are translated into slightly stretched (red shifted) and compressed (blue shifted) fluctuations in microwave radiation. From these microwave fluctuations, we infer pressure differences in the universe at the time that matter and radiation first separated. These pressure differences indicate lumpiness in the distribution of matter and radiation at the time that matter and energy first separated – the CMB. The power spectrum of the CMB tells us the sizes of the lumps in the early universe. We analyze the power spectrum of the CMB using techniques that we know from the physics of MUSIC.slide adapted from Mark Whittlemore on this subject later...
20Planck will also map the polarization of the CMB Mapping the polarization of the CMB will give us an idea of how photons scattered off charged particles on the Last Scattering Surface. This will give us a picture of the distribution of matter in the universe at that time – similar to the way in which sunlight scatters off the surface of a lake reflects the undulations in the surface of the water.2020
21Educational materials that the Planck E/PO Group Next:Educational materialsthat the Planck E/PO Groupis developing
22Under development at Purdue University Jerry Dekker, Jack Moreland, The Planck Mission in Virtual RealityUnder development at Purdue UniversityJerry Dekker, Jack Moreland,Jatila van der Veen
23Utilizing state-of-the-art visualization, gaming, and distributed computing technology, we are developing applications for the Planck Mission using Virtual Reality to reach the widest possible international audience.23
24flight simulator screen ... Starting from aflight simulator screen ...24
25...the user can explore the mission from launch... to orbital insertion...to data gathering operations...from any vantage point in the solar system.25
26Finally, the user stands “in space” while Planck paints the CMB all around, beyond the starry background.
27Simulation created in the Visualization Laboratory at Purdue University-CalumetOn May 14, 2009, at 13:12 UT, Planck was launched from the European Space Agency’s launch pad in Kouru, French Guiana.
28Distribution goals: Currently still in development and testing. Hi-tech visualization facilities:VR facilitiesPlanetariaVirtual ClassroomsMuseums and Science CentersThousands of potential sites!DVDs for Museums and mass dist.Kiosk interactive displayPassive viewing as movieWeb DistributionDownload, single computerInteractive served applicationComputers in classroomsCurrently still indevelopment and testing.If you wish to receive acopy to test, please sendan toPopular CultureiPhone applicationGoogle UniverseScreen saversAvailable in a variety of 3-D technologies, from simple anaglyph to high-tech varieties.
29The Music of the Cosmos Planck Using sound to explain how we extract information about the early universe from the power spectrum of the CMB.primordialPlanckWMAPCOBEUnder development at UC Santa BarbaraJatila van der VeenJoAnn Kuchera-MorinWesley Smith, Basak Alper, Matt Wright29
30The variations in temperature that we observe in the CMB ......tell us about variations in density in the early universe, which we now observe as...... anisotropies in the CMB.The CMB anisotropies originate from two different processes :Initial distortions in the actual shape of the Universe, which originated in the first moments of its existenceGravity-driven pressure waves in the matter-radiation fluid which filled the young universe during the first 380,000 years of its existence – up to the time when matter and radiation separated.30
31Those gravity-driven pressure waves in the matter-radiation fluid of the early universe not only left their imprints in the light of the CMB; they determined the distribution of matter and energy in the universe at later times, as seen in the large-scale clusters and walls of galaxies.Images courtesy of Professor Max Tegmark, MIT
32In a sense, understanding the CMB That is why it is so important to understand the scale of anisotropies in the CMB: the variations in the oldest light of the universe predict the distribution of matter and energy throughout the universe. This includes “normal” matter, in the form of galaxies that emit radiation, “exotic” dark matter, which gravitates but does not shine, and the stranger still dark energy.In a sense, understandingthe CMBis like deciphering the genetic code of the universe!
33Measuring and analyzing the CMB is based on the same principles which are involved in making music and broadcasting it!Pressure waves (sounds) in the concert hall are converted to electromagnetic radiation, transmitted across spacetime, and reconverted to sound waves that your ears can hear.Similarly, pressure waves in the early universe resulted in variations in the light that was emitted as radiation and matter decoupled. This light has been transmitted across spacetime (nearly 14 billion years!) to our microwave detectors. Using techniques that are familiar to sound engineers, we can convert these light echoes into to sound that your ears can hear.
34Higher frequency = more vibrations/sec = higher pitch. In order to understand how we can listen to the sounds of the early universe, we first need to understand how sounds are produced on Earth.Sound waves are just pressure waves which have wavelengths and frequencies that we can hear. Humans can hear frequencies from around 20 to 20,000vibrations/second (Hertz).Figures adapted from Mark Whittle, University of VirginiaThe frequency, or number of vibrations per second, determines the pitch of the sound we hear.Higher frequency = more vibrations/sec = higher pitch.
35The speed of sound in air is approximately 330 meters/second. So… Higher frequency waves have shorter wavelengths, and lower frequency waves have longer wavelengths, as indicated in these pictures.Frequency and wavelength are related by the speed of sound by the following equation:Wave speed = frequency x wavelengthThus if you know the speed of sound and the frequency, you can calculate wavelength.The speed of sound in air is approximately 330 meters/second. So…The “red tone” of 200 Hz has a wavelength of 330 m/sec / 200 Hz = 1.65 meters.The “cyan tone” of 600 Hz has a wavelength of 330 m/sec / 600 Hz = 0.55 meters or 55 cm.The “magenta tone” of 1000 Hz has a wavelength of 330 m/sec / 1000 Hz = 0.33 meters or 33 cm.
36approximately the volume of a typical rock concert. The amplitude of the pressure variations determines the loudness of the sounds we hear. Higher amplitude = greater variation in pressure = louder sound.Figure adapted from Mark Whittle, University of VirginiaThe temperature variations of the CMB indicate pressure variations of a few parts in 10,000, or ΔP/P of 10-4 = 110 db,approximately the volume of a typical rock concert.
37Finally, we need to understand how instruments produce pleasing sounds: To produce musical tones, you need an object with a well-defined shape and size, which can vibrate – a RESONATOR.Resonators – such as flutes, guitars,drums, or bells - have a fundamentaltone which is the longest wavelengththat can fit within the wallsof a given resonator.The fundamental is the lowestpitch that a given resonator canproduce. Higher harmonics arewhole number multiples of thefundamental frequency.The fundamental frequencytells you the time it takes for thelongest wave to travelacross theresonator and backone time.
38Bag pipe Pipe organ Wooden flute Bigger resonators produce lower tones. Click on the speaker icons to hear music produced by pressure waves vibrating in each of these wind instruments.Bag pipePipe organWooden fluteNext we’ll investigate the sound waves produced by a computer, by real instruments, and by a star such as the Sun.Finally, we’ll apply these concepts to understanding the sounds produced by pressure waves in the early universe.
39The simplest sound wave one can imagine is just a single pure tone, with only one frequency, corresponding to a single wavelength. The top figure shows this tone as a single frequency wave, with a period of 1/440th of a second, or second.wavelengthClick on the speaker to hear a pure “A” of 440 Hz, generated by a computer:The POWER SPECTRUM of any sound tells you what frequencies are present and how loud each one is.Here is the power spectrum of this tone: a single peak at a frequency of 440 Hertz, or cycles/second:3939
40Here are 3 A’s, an octave apart: 220 Hz, 440 Hz, and 880 Hz Here are 3 A’s, an octave apart: 220 Hz, 440 Hz, and 880 Hz. In the top figure, we display the wave form, which is the superposition of the three waves, and in the bottom figure we display the power spectrum of this sound, comprised of these three notes.The power spectra and wave forms shown on these pages were produced using the software “Cool Edit Pro”Click on the speaker to hear the tones.2204408804040
41Here is the sound of a clarinet playing an A of 440 Hz. Notice that even though only one note is being played,the wave form and power spectrum are more complicated thanthose of an A being played by a computer! This is because the way the pressure waves bounce around inside the actual clarinet creates higher harmonics, or overtones, and it is the overtones which allow you to distinguish one instrument from another, and notes played by real instruments from the same notes synthesized by a computer!Compare the sound of the clarinet (above) playing an A of 440 Hertz, with the sound of a pure A played on a computer:4141
42And here is the power spectrum of the clarinet playing an A of 440 Hz And here is the power spectrum of the clarinet playing an A of 440 Hz. The first peak is the fundamental, at 440 Hz. The successive peaks represent the higher harmonics, which are integer multiples of the fundamental. Compare the spectra and sounds of the real clarinet and the synthesized sound generated by a computer.Clarinet playing an A440 Hz8801320etc...Pure A synthesized on a computer has only one peak at 440 Hz.4242
43Let’s compare the sound of a trumpet playing a middle C (261 Hz) with the same note, synthesized on a computer. Here are the wave forms:TrumpetSource:Computer4343
44And here are the power spectra And here are the power spectra. Again, notice the higher harmonics are multiples of the fundamental. The presence of these higher harmonics allows you to tell that this note is played by a trumpet.Trumpet261522783etc...Pure C synthesized on a computer. Notice a single peak at 261 Hz. The absence of the higher harmonics makes this note sound artificial!4444
45A power spectrum is thus a bit like a finger print. The point of all this is to demonstrate that although instruments may play the same pitch at the same loudness, each instrument (resonator) has a unique POWER SPECTRUM which is determined by the size and shape of that instrument.The power spectrum, consisting of the fundamental and higher harmonics, is what gives each instrument its unique sound quality (which musicians call TIMBRE), and allows us to distinguish the sound of a piano from that of a violin, trumpet, clarinet, or a tone produced by a computer.A power spectrum is thus a bit like a finger print.TrumpetClarinetBefore we apply these principles to the CMB, we have to look at one little problem:Poor resonators produce “noisy” power spectra, with poorly-defined peaks. The universe was a poor resonator, since it had no well-defined boundaries in space, thus we have to know how to “clean up” a power spectrum before we can listen to the music of the cosmos!
46If there is a fair amount of “hiss” in a resonating system, it can be difficult to pick out the peaks – the fundamental and higher harmonics – in the power spectrum. For example:Here’s our piper, playingone note :It is difficult to find the fundamental in this power spectrum, but with mathematical tools called Fourier analysis (after the fellow who invented them) we can remove the hiss and pick out the fundamental tone.
47Now we have are ready to analyze the sounds of natural systems, Here is the bag pipe again, but with its power spectrum “cleaned up” to pick out the harmonics from the noise. We hear the fundamental, but the tone has lost its breathy quality, so that it no longer sounds like a bag pipe.Now we have are ready to analyze the sounds of natural systems,starting with the Sun,and then the universe!
48Natural systems such as the Sun and the Earth are also resonators Natural systems such as the Sun and the Earth are also resonators. The Sun, being a ball of gas without well defined boundaries, produces very hissy sounds, like these, which have been compressed by several orders of magnitude so as to be audible to human ears:Source: bison.ph.bham.ac.uk/10 Hz100 Hz~420 Hz1,000 Hz4848
49... Sounds pretty eerie, doesn’t it! Using the same Fourier analysis, we can clean up the Sun’s power spectrum and pick out the fundamental and higher harmonics which are buried in all the hiss. With the hiss removed, and scaled to audible frequencies, the Sun would sound something like this:... Sounds pretty eerie, doesn’t it!
50Finally: Back to the CMB! The early universe was a resonator, albeit a very hissy one, like the Sun.Thus it should have a fundamental tone which was determined by the size of the universe at the time that the CMB was produced – when matter and radiation first separated.We can determine the wavelength of the fundamental from the power spectrum of the CMB, and knowing the approximate speed of sound in the early universe, we can calculate the fundamental frequency.We can clean up the power spectrum, scale the frequencies to the range of human hearing, and listen to the sounds of the early universe!
51Slide courtesy of Mark Whittle, University of Virginia
52Anisotropies of 20 and smaller in the CMB correspond to pressure waves in the early universe... which correspond to the fundamental and higher harmonics in the power spectrum of the CMB.This graphis more fully explained in the next two slides...5252
53Angular resolution of features, in degrees, on the sky fundamentalFigure courtesy of Mark Whittle, University of VirginiaharmonicsSound “Loudness”Spatial frequency of features, expressed as waves over the surface of a sphere. Lower “l” means larger wavelength, lower frequency. l (angular wave number) is approximately calculated as 1800/ where = angular resolution (top scale of this graph).
54scaled to the range of human hearing, and related to notes on a piano. This graph compares spatial frequency on the sky to frequencies of sound,scaled to the range of human hearing, and related to notes on a piano.Amplitude of temperature anisotropiesscaled to units of micro-Kelvin2Figure adapted from website of Mark Whittle, University of Virginia
55Amplitude of temperature anisotropies scaled to units of micro-Kelvin2 Superimposed on the previous graph, here we show the range of spatial frequencies mapped by each satellitePlanckWMAPAmplitude of temperature anisotropiesscaled to units of micro-Kelvin2COBEprimordial shape of the universeFigure adapted from website of Mark Whittle, University of Virginia
56Now for some calculations: Converting meters to light years, we get: The speed of sound in the pre-CMB early universe was approximately:The fundamental wavelength on the CMB tells the distance that the longest wave, with the lowest tone, traveled in the first 380,000 years of the universe’s existence. Converting 380,000 years into seconds, and multiplying by speed of sound gives us the approximate size of the fundamental in “real” units:Converting meters to light years, we get:Thus, 220,000 light years is the wavelength of the fundamental ‘note’ of the CMB. This means 1 wave every 220,000 years!
57We invert this number to calculate the fundamental frequency in Hertz: If the period is 220,000 years, this means that the fundamental frequency is 1 wave /220,000 years, or 1 wave in 6.94 x 1012 seconds!We invert this number to calculate the fundamental frequency in Hertz:1/6.94 x 1012 = x Hz (waves/second)Human hearing ranges from ~ 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, thus the fundamental tone of the universe is between 1.4 x 1014 and 1.4 x 1017 times LOWER than human hearing.(We got this by dividing 20/1.44 x and 20,000/1.44 x 10-13)Since 1 octave = doubling in frequency, this comes out to around51 octaves below the “concert A” of 440 Hz that we played in slide #39!Figure courtesy of Mark Whittle, University of Virginia
58Scaled to human hearing, the CMB sounds something like this: 5858
59Played in Cool Edit, the power spectrum of this sound looks like this: “Cleaned up” using the same tools of Fourier analysis that we used on the sounds of the Sun, we can hear the fundamental and higher harmonics of the CMB, scaled to human hearing:Further filtering givesthis ghostly tone:
60Here is a comparison of the broad, “hissy” CMB spectrum of angular wavelengths (C(l)), compared with a cleaned up power spectrum (P(k)), compared with the filtered single tones of the power spectrum:Figure and sound files courtesy of Mark Whittle, University of Virginia
61The CMB represents the LAST echo of the sloshing sound waves that propagated during the 380,000 years after the big bang.Expanding universe creates deepening sound...Going farther:Sound file courtesy of Mark Whittle, University of VirginiaIf you are ambitious, you can scale the power spectrum by different factors to create the tones of different size universes, then add them together to create a changing tone!
62Changing the properties of the universe would give it a different power spectrum...which would sound different.You can use the program CMBFAST, which can be found at to change the ingredients of the universe, get a new power spectrum, and then listen to its sounds.
63Summary:The CMB Power Spectrum holds clues to understand fundamental cosmological parameters, and may even allow us to distinguish between particle and string models of inflation.The tools for analysis are the similar to other types of harmonic analysis.Starting from the CMB Power Spectrum, you can use any sound editing package to reproduce the sounds of the Universe.This is a great way to incorporate music into a science class: The Universe actually has a primordial sound!
64Planck Visualization Project: Goals of thePlanck Visualization Project:This is a work in progress! If you wish to download a beta-version of the Mission Simulation, please send to for the anonymous ftp site at the Jet Propulsion Lab where you can download it.These slides will be posted somewhere on the site in the near future.Ultimately, we plan to distribute:A Virtual Reality simulation of the Plank Mission, and CMBAn activity guide for teachers on understanding the CMB using musicAn interactive lab for high school and college students, using CMBFAST and listen to the sounds that are derived from the power spectrum of each one.
65References: Mark Whittle, University of Virginia For an in-depth treatment on Big Bang Acoustics:Mark Whittle, University of VirginiaFor more information about Planck:- NASA Planck page at JPL-ESA Planck pageTo receive a preliminary copy of the mission simulation forclassroom use, please send to me at