Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

21/09/2010CALICE Manqi RUAN Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet (LLR) Ecole Polytechnique 91128, Palaiseau Status of DHCAL PFA Study.

Published bySamuel Leonard Modified over 7 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "21/09/2010CALICE Manqi RUAN Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet (LLR) Ecole Polytechnique 91128, Palaiseau Status of DHCAL PFA Study."— Presentation transcript:

1 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA1 Manqi RUAN Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet (LLR) Ecole Polytechnique 91128, Palaiseau Status of DHCAL PFA Study

2 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA2 Outline ● Introduction ● SDHCAL Reco Soft Status ● Observation on PandoraPFA ● Preliminary studies ● Single Particle Event ● Tau jet level ● Summary and Plan

3 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA3 BKgrd ● JC Plot + Mark Plot to show leakage & confusion Vs energy

4 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA4 Reco Soft status ● DHCAL: finer granularity = less confusion ~ better performance ● PandoraPFA based reconstruction chain: ● Preliminary RPC digitization : to be upgraded with multiplicity effects → Ran's presentation ● PandoraPFA: learning phase -> optimize the parameters & orders of different modules ● DHCAL based algorithms: under development ● Kalman filter, Density & NN analysis, Hough transform... ● Dedicated clustering + Better hadronic shower energy estimator: to be developed and integrated ● Event Display: to be heavily employed to understand the performance

5 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA5 Pandora: learning phase ● Treating as black box: ● Pandora + Preliminary Digitization + Calibration constant tuning: ● Performance with uds evts: slightly worse @ Zthreshold, comparable @ 360GeV PRELIMINARY

6 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA6 Step back to particle gun ● Simulated with mokka 06-07 ● Pion, Klong: ● Statistic: 160k evts * (AHCAL + DHCAL) ● ( 2k * Energy (10, 20,... 100 GeV)*Polar angle (20, 30, 40,..., 90 Deg) ● Estimator: – Double counting probability (identify partial of the cluster as another PFO) – Probability of failure to link track to cluster (pion only) – Ratio of leading cluster hits number to total (digitized) hits number ● Tau event: low multiplicity jets: ● Visible energy resolution + confusion case analysis ● Chance...

7 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA7 Number of PFOs... ~ 90% of the event has only one reconstructed PFO; Barrel region seems slightly cleaner than Endcap; Evts with multiple PFO: pre interaction or cluster splitting

8 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA8 Total PFO Energy Vs Number of PFOs, 80 Deg Case with only 1 PFO: still have long tail... tracker not so reliable? 1 < Number of PFO < 5: larger estimated energy ~ double counting + pre interaction? Number of PFO > 10: pre interaction + confusion + cluster energy smearing

9 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA9 Single PFO case, 80 Deg Pion decay: 40GeV Pion ~ 12GeV neutrino + 28GeV muon... Evt 821, 40GeV Pion at MCTruth Identify as 46.6GeV PFO With 38GeV cluster Failure of track energy reconstruction?

10 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA10 Higher estimated energy at θ = 80Deg 4 PFOs, Identify as 100GeV Pion + 28GeV Neutron +... Total PFO energy = 130GeV (Evt 286) 2 PFOs, Identify as 100GeV Pion + 45GeV Neutron Total PFO energy = 145GeV Seed at deep ECAL Layer...

11 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA11 Higher estimated energy at θ = 80Deg (Evt 867) Simulation level Interaction at the TPC PFO level: 15PFOs Leading PFO with 54GeV cluster identified as 100GeV pion. Others contribute to double counted 32GeV... Tough case... interaction near the end of Tracker!

12 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA12 Even more crazy... Evt 646: Interaction Inside TPC Confused tracker: 3 LDCTrack found 6PFOs: 2 leading PFO assigned with tracks + cluster, with energy 110GeV (40GeV cluster) and 148GeV (55GeV cluster) Totally reconstructed energy: 264GeV Simulation level PFO level Flag on those kind of evts Relay more on cluster info?

13 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA13 “Lower” estimated energy at θ = 80Deg dude... you are a pion? Evt 346, Interaction at TPC entrance 18 PFOs, Total Energy 79GeV Simulation level

14 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA14 Total PFO Energy Vs Number of PFOs, 20 Deg Crazy single PFO events: pion decay + track energy resolution smearing N_PFO < 10: Linear dependence between N_PFO and total measured energy... ? Number of PFO > 10: pre interaction + confusion + cluster energy smearing, also the Calibration constant seems not optimized.

15 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA15 20Deg polar angle Crazy track energy ~ 217GeV Cluster Energy = 87GeV 20Deg polar angle Total measured energy = 105GeV Higher estimated energy at θ = 20Deg Interaction in the Tracker

16 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA16 “Lower” estimated energy Pion decay: 42GeV neutrino + 58GeV muon... Theta = 20 deg Smearing of Track energy resolution Track energy = 91.2GeV Interaction before Calo + Cluster energy resolution uncertainty

17 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA17 DHCAL: Total PFO energy Most of the Event has nice energy resolution (from tracker) Higher estimated total PFO energy ~ Track energy resolution smearing (forward region) + double counting + interaction before Calo Lower estimated total PFO energy: Pion decay, interaction before calo, track energy smearing (forward), cluster energy smearing...

18 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA18 SDHCAL: Total Cluster Energy Resolution ~ 80%/sqrt(E) Similar behaviour in different polar angle ~1% - 2% event has very low clustered energy -> Pion Decay

19 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA19 Comparing with AHCAL: 80Deg SDHCAL, 10k evtsAHCAL, 20k evts No significant different at low polar angle.

20 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA20 20Deg SDHCAL, 10k evtsAHCAL, 20k evts Nether at high polar angle...

21 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA21 40Deg SDHCAL, 10k evtsAHCAL, 20k evts Nether at high polar angle...

22 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA22 Comparing with AHCAL Maybe slightly more double counting events (1 < NPFO < 5) for DHCAL... More PFOs in forward region comparing to Barrel

23 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA23 Summary on Pion case... ● SDHCAL and AHCAL have comparable performance on number of reconstructed particle for single pion event, with slightly more reconstructed PFO in DHCAL ● Significant more double counting in edge region: need better linking algorithm ● Higher estimated energy: ● For large polar angle: double counting + pre interaction and cluster energy resolution error ● For small polar angle: track energy resolution searing, double counting and pre interaction ● Lower estimated energy: ● Pion decay, pre interaction and energy resolution error. ● Interactions inside tracker region caused lots of uncertainty, our worst enemy??

24

25 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA25 Summary and Plans ● SDHCAL Reco software development is progressing in various directions; ● Pion, Klong conclusion ● Tau conclusion ● Looooooooooong to do list ● Identify man power ● Parameter & order optimization of PandoraPFA ● DHCAL energy estimator & clustering algorithm development ● Testing on benchmark physics processes with – Tau – ZZ, ZH – ttbar, SUSY events with multiple jet final state

26 21/09/2010CALICE 2010@CASA26 DHCAL Pion evts Hadronic Shower is complex... Interaction before calo 100 GeV Pion, 20Deg polar angle; Total Measured PFO energy = 84.46GeV Not satisfactory but fine... Simulation level PFO level

Download ppt "21/09/2010CALICE Manqi RUAN Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet (LLR) Ecole Polytechnique 91128, Palaiseau Status of DHCAL PFA Study."

Similar presentations

Proposal for a new design of LumiCal R. Ingbir, P. Ruzicka, V. Vrba -1-. 31. October 07 Malá Skála.

Proposal for a new design of LumiCal R. Ingbir, P. Ruzicka, V. Vrba October 07 Malá Skála.
SiD PFA Status and Calorimeter Performance Ron Cassell (SLAC) SiD Design Study Meeting 11/15/08.

SiD PFA Status and Calorimeter Performance Ron Cassell (SLAC) SiD Design Study Meeting 11/15/08.
PFA-Enhanced Dual Readout Crystal Calorimetry Stephen Magill - ANL Hans Wenzel - FNAL Outline : Motivation Detector Parameters Use of a PFA in Dual Readout.

PFA-Enhanced Dual Readout Crystal Calorimetry Stephen Magill - ANL Hans Wenzel - FNAL Outline : Motivation Detector Parameters Use of a PFA in Dual Readout.
P. Gay Energy flow session1 Analytic Energy Flow F. Chandez P. Gay S. Monteil CALICE Coll.

P. Gay Energy flow session1 Analytic Energy Flow F. Chandez P. Gay S. Monteil CALICE Coll.
1 Study of the Tail Catcher Muon Tracker (TCMT) Scintillator Strips and Leakage with Simulated Coil Rick Salcido Northern Illinois University For CALICE.

1 Study of the Tail Catcher Muon Tracker (TCMT) Scintillator Strips and Leakage with Simulated Coil Rick Salcido Northern Illinois University For CALICE.
PFA on SiDaug05_np Lei Xia ANL-HEP. PFA outline Calibration of calorimeter –Done –Not tuned for clustering algorithm Clustering algorithm –Done: hit density.

PFA on SiDaug05_np Lei Xia ANL-HEP. PFA outline Calibration of calorimeter –Done –Not tuned for clustering algorithm Clustering algorithm –Done: hit density.
GEM DHCAL Simulation Studies J. Yu* Univ. of Texas at Arlington ALCW, July 15, 2003 Cornell University (*on behalf of the UTA team; S. Habib, V. Kaushik,

GEM DHCAL Simulation Studies J. Yu* Univ. of Texas at Arlington ALCW, July 15, 2003 Cornell University (*on behalf of the UTA team; S. Habib, V. Kaushik,
 Track-First E-flow Algorithm  Analog vs. Digital Energy Resolution for Neutral Hadrons  Towards Track/Cal hit matching  Photon Finding  Plans E-flow.

 Track-First E-flow Algorithm  Analog vs. Digital Energy Resolution for Neutral Hadrons  Towards Track/Cal hit matching  Photon Finding  Plans E-flow.
A preliminary analysis of the CALICE test beam data Dhiman Chakraborty, NIU for the CALICE Collaboration LCWS07, Hamburg, Germany May 29 - June 3, 2007.

A preliminary analysis of the CALICE test beam data Dhiman Chakraborty, NIU for the CALICE Collaboration LCWS07, Hamburg, Germany May 29 - June 3, 2007.
1 N. Davidson Calibration with low energy single pions Tau Working Group Meeting 23 rd July 2007.

1 N. Davidson Calibration with low energy single pions Tau Working Group Meeting 23 rd July 2007.
1/9/2003 UTA-GEM Simulation Report Venkatesh Kaushik 1 Simulation Study of Digital Hadron Calorimeter Using GEM Venkatesh Kaushik* University of Texas.

1/9/2003 UTA-GEM Simulation Report Venkatesh Kaushik 1 Simulation Study of Digital Hadron Calorimeter Using GEM Venkatesh Kaushik* University of Texas.
Preliminary comparison of ATLAS Combined test-beam data with G4: pions in calorimetric system Andrea Dotti, Per Johansson Physics Validation of LHC Simulation.

Preliminary comparison of ATLAS Combined test-beam data with G4: pions in calorimetric system Andrea Dotti, Per Johansson Physics Validation of LHC Simulation.
Development of Particle Flow Calorimetry José Repond Argonne National Laboratory DPF meeting, Providence, RI August 8 – 13, 2011.

Development of Particle Flow Calorimetry José Repond Argonne National Laboratory DPF meeting, Providence, RI August 8 – 13, 2011.
Summary of Calorimetry/Muon Sessions Burak Bilki University of Iowa Argonne National Laboratory.

Summary of Calorimetry/Muon Sessions Burak Bilki University of Iowa Argonne National Laboratory.
Mark Thomson Timing, Tungsten and High Energy Jets.

Mark Thomson Timing, Tungsten and High Energy Jets.
Optimizing DHCAL single particle energy resolution Lei Xia Argonne National Laboratory 1 LCWS 2013, Tokyo, Japan November 11 - 15, 2013.

Optimizing DHCAL single particle energy resolution Lei Xia Argonne National Laboratory 1 LCWS 2013, Tokyo, Japan November , 2013.
Optimizing DHCAL single particle energy resolution Lei Xia 1 CALICE Meeting LAPP, Annecy, France September 9 – 11, 2013.

Optimizing DHCAL single particle energy resolution Lei Xia 1 CALICE Meeting LAPP, Annecy, France September 9 – 11, 2013.
DHCAL - Resolution (S)DHCAL Meeting January 15, 2014 Lyon, France Burak Bilki, José Repond and Lei Xia Argonne National Laboratory.

DHCAL - Resolution (S)DHCAL Meeting January 15, 2014 Lyon, France Burak Bilki, José Repond and Lei Xia Argonne National Laboratory.
International Workshop on Linear Colliders, Geneve 18.10-22.10.10 1 Muon reconstruction and identification in the ILD detector N. D’Ascenzo, V.Saveliev.

International Workshop on Linear Colliders, Geneve Muon reconstruction and identification in the ILD detector N. D’Ascenzo, V.Saveliev.
SiD performance for the DBD Jan Strube CERN. Overview Software Preparation (CERN, SLAC) Machine Environment (CERN, SLAC) Tracking Performance (C. Grefe)

SiD performance for the DBD Jan Strube CERN. Overview Software Preparation (CERN, SLAC) Machine Environment (CERN, SLAC) Tracking Performance (C. Grefe)

Similar presentations

Ads by Google