1. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Model-based Systems Engineering (MBSE) Initiative INCOSE MBSE Workshop 21-22 January 2012 Jacksonville, Florida Sanford Friedenthal Mark Sampson

2. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Topics MBSE Motivation INCOSE MBSE Initiative Overview INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Overview

3. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA INCOSE MBSE Definition 3 formalized application of modeling “Model-based systems engineering (MBSE) is the formalized application of modeling to support system requirements, design, analysis, verification and validation activities beginning in the conceptual design phase and continuing throughout development and later life cycle phases.” INCOSE SE Vision 2020 (INCOSE-TP-2004-004-02), Sept 2007

4. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Motivation

5. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Apollo Moon rockets vs. Gift Cards Accelerating complexity… Apollo Guidance Computer (1966) 1 st IC-based computer 2k core, 36k ‘rope’ memory 11.72 micro-second cycle 55 Watts 70 lbs 24” x 12.5” x 6.5” $$$$$$$$ Hallmark Card (today) 256mb+ memory ~2 ghz 1900 mAh (2 yrs).085 oz 1” x 1” x.25”.$ <$1

6. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Deep Water Horizon Why Systems Engineering? ~5000 sensors, ECU’s, etc. communicating over 9000 connections via 1,000,000+ types of messages, performing 2000+ functions—with each tail number different ~10M LOC, 40-60 ECU’s, ~5000 parameters, ~30,000 functions (typical engine controller ~4000 functions) Rescue Mission Launched By TV An Oregon man discovered that his year-old Toshiba flat- screen TV was emitting an international distress signal (121.5 mhz) picked up by a satellite, leading a search and rescue operation to his apartment in Corvallis, Oregon, Oct. 18, 2004 CNN Complexity everywhere… SE is a process for managing complexity Complexity everywhere… SE is a process for managing complexity

7. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA This requires change… Document Generation Documents Disconnected System Models MBSE

8. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Vision: Integrated systems-oriented decision support… Minimum Turn Radius: 24 ft. Dry Pavement Braking Distance at 60 MPH : 110 ft. Automatic Cruise Control Thermal/Heat Dissipation: 780° Ergonomic/Pedal Feedback: 34 ERGS Hydraulic Pressure: 350 PSI Sensor MTBF: 3000 hrs Power Rating: 18 Amps Hydraulic Fluid: SAE 1340 not- compliant Minimum Turn Radius: 24 ft. Dry Pavement Braking Distance at 60 MPH : 110 ft. 90 ft

9. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA INCOSE MBSE Initiative Overview

10. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Initiative Charter Supports MBSE Component of the SE Vision 2020 Promote, advance, and institutionalize the practice of MBSE through broad industry/academic involvement –Research –Standards –Processes, Practices, & Methods –Tools & Technology –Outreach, Training & Education MBSE Wiki –http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.phphttp://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php

11. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA INCOSE MBSE Roadmap 201020202025 Maturity MBSE Capability Ad Hoc MBSE Document Centric 2010 Well Defined MBSE Institutionalized MBSE across Academia/Industry Reduced cycle times Design optimization across broad trade space Cross domain effects based analysis System of systems interoperability Extending Maturity and Capability Distributed & secure model repositories crossing multiple domains Defined MBSE theory, ontology, and formalisms Emerging MBSE standards Matured MBSE methods and metrics, Integrated System/HW/SW models Architecture model integrated with Simulation, Analysis, and Visualization Planning & Support Research Standards Development Processes, Practices, & Methods Tools & Technology Enhancements Outreach, Training & Education Refer to activities in the following areas:

12. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Initiative Forums MBSE Webinars –10 webinars in 2011 –Average session attendance = 27 MBSE Wiki –http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.phphttp://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php –Populated by MBSE Activity and Challenge Teams –Provides open forum to foster industry collaboration MBSE Track at IS 2011 –Papers, Tutorials, Panel MBSE Workshop at IW 12

13. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Leadership Team Management Chair Mark Sampson Co-Chair Sandy Friedenthal Webinars and Communications - Ray Jorgensen Challenge Teams Biomedical Modeling Steve CornsBiomedical Modeling Modeling and Simulation Interoperability Russell PeakModeling and Simulation Interoperability Space Systems Modeling Chris DelpSpace Systems Modeling Telescope Modeling Robert KarbanTelescope Modeling Activity Teams MBSE Usability Scott WorkingerMBSE Usability Methodology and Metrics John WatsonMethodology and Metrics Model-Based Testing – Frank Alvidrez (NEW) Model Management Joe BedocsModel Management Modeling Standards Roger BurkhartModeling Standards Ontology Henson GravesOntology System of Systems/Enterprise Modeling Ron WilliamsonSystem of Systems/Enterprise Modeling 13

14. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Workshop Observations From INCOSE IW 2011 Well attended –110+ participants! Starting to see the MBSE vision come together –Pieces falling into place –Emphasis on integrated, cross-domain models Real progress has been made –MBSE teams working critical issues –Tangible models addressing real problems More active practitioners participating in modeling activities New Biomedical Modeling Challenge Team

15. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA INCOSE IS 2011 Panel Integrating MBSE into a Multi-disciplinary Engineering Environment Panel presentations and summary: http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php?id=mbse:incose_mbse_is_2011 Panel Questions –What should other engineering disciplines expect from MBSE? –What should systems engineering expect from other disciplines to enable MBSE? –What can MBSE learn from model-based approaches used in other engineering disciplines? –How should the practices and tools be integrated/coupled across disciplines? –How are the system, hardware, and software models managed to ensure an integrated technical baseline? –How should a program be organized to achieve more effective utilization and application of model-based engineering?

16. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Survey Short survey administered at MBSE Workshop –9 questions with rating 1-5 –On-line using Survey Monkey –Link available from MBSE Wiki http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/doku.php –Data not attributed Provides a gross indicator of state of practice –How widely MBSE is used –How MBSE is being applied –Perceived benefit/value of MBSE –Obstacles to adoption 16 Need Your Input

17. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA INCOSE IW 2012 MBSE Workshop Overview

18. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Workshop 2012 Objectives –Assess progress & challenges towards MBSE Vision MBSE Activity and Challenge Team Updates State of Integrated Multi-disciplinary Modeling –Network and interact with other MBSE practitioners Agenda –Saturday, January 21, 2012 (10:30 – 17:15) Activity & Challenge Team Updates –Sunday, January 22, 2012 (08:15 – 17:30) Multi-discipline modeling approaches and integration challenges Advanced Approaches to Integrated Modeling 18

19. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE IW Agenda Saturday, January 22, 2012 10:30 – 12:00 PM Introduction (15 min) – Sanford Friedenthal/Mark Sampson Report from MBSE Activity and Challenge Teams (25 minutes each) –Methodology and Metrics Activity Team – John Watson –M&S Interoperability Challenge Team - Russell Peak –Australia MBSE Working Group – Quoc Do

20. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE IW Agenda Saturday, January 22, 2012 (cont.) 13:00 – 17:15 PM Report from MBSE Activity and Challenge Teams (25 minutes each) –SoS/Enterprise Modeling Activity Team – Ron Williamson –Model Management Activity Team – Joe Bedocs –Space Systems Challenge Team – Chris Delp –Ontology Activity Team – Henson Graves Break –AFIS MBSE Working Group - Michel Galinier –MBSE Usability Activity Team – Scott Workinger –BioMedical Modeling Challenge Team – Steve Corns/Chad Gibson –Modeling Standards Activity Team – Roger Burkhart –Summary and Agenda for Day 2 – Sandy Friedenthal

21. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE IW Agenda Sunday, January 22, 2012 08:15 – 12:00 AM (35 minutes each) Multi-Discipline Engineering modeling approach, key practices, and integration challenges –Digital Tapestry (Chris Oster-Lockheed Martin) –Embedded system design modeling (Jim Ross-Deere & Co) –Model-based Manufacturing modeling (Greg Pollari-Rockwell Collins) Break –Cost/Logistics Modeling (Chris Adams-Raytheon) –System Modeling (John Watson-Lockheed Martin) –Multi-disciplinary mechanical modeling, management and exchange (Dr Clark Briggs-ATA Engr)

22. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE IW Agenda Sunday, January 22, 2012 (cont.) 13:00 – 15:00 Breakouts to discuss integration challenges and opportunities (1.25 hour) –Engineering change scenario – Joe Bedocs facilitator –Requirements flowdown scenario – John Watson facilitator –Integration and Verification scenario – Ron Williamson facilitator Out-briefs (Key Practices, Integration Challenges, Recommendations) – 12 min each –Breakout Session 1 –Breakout Session 2 –Breakout Session 3

23. International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE IW Agenda Sunday, January 22, 2012 (cont.) 15:15 – 17:30 Advanced Approaches to Cross Domain/Cross Discipline Modeling (30 min each) –ESA Concurrent Design Facility – Hans Peter de Koning (ESA) –Multi-disciplinary Approach for Industrial Phases – Harald Eisenmann (Astrium), Joachim Fuchs (ESA/ESTEC) –Model-based Approach using Integrated Visualization – Steve Corns –Progress on Integrating OWL with SysML– Steve Jenkins (JPL) Summary and Wrap-up (15 min)